No, we shouldn't.

no more officials

much less a marilyn manson official

[url]http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showthread.php?t=295448[/url]

band name thread

[QUOTE=munky_magik]It could be counted as a game thread, which are against the rules. It was also a spam thread, which are also against the rules.[/QUOTE]

Yes but the thing is there was no spam in it

And game threads are against the rules? The mods are freakin fun police around here sometimes

In our defense, I'd much rather have a highly moderated forum rather than the old madhouse that the Rock & Metal forums used to be.

[url]http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showthread.php?t=294661&page=3&pp=25[/url]
Does the Rock & Metal forum really need a thread about disturbed? Also many of the posts are just spam.

[url]http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showthread.php?t=295518[/url]

Should be in the pop punk or maybe the guitar forum?

[url]http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showthread.php?t=295527[/url]

Thread about Nu-metal.

Ok guys, sorry. I have been out of the scene for a few days basically. You guys know I play alot. Anyway, I went back and banned all the idiots that slipped through the cracks.

Don't give up on R&M guys, I told you guys in December that it was going to get bad for the next month or so cus of the influx of new people with new computers and new musicians. Hang tough guys, its gettin better.


[SIZE=5]WE ARE THE BA[I]D[/I]ASSES OF THE FORUM!!!!!!!![/SIZE]

[QUOTE=3074326]In our defense, I'd much rather have a highly moderated forum rather than the old madhouse that the Rock & Metal forums used to be.[/QUOTE]

Hey R+M is looking great, but I'm struggling to come to terms with why that thread was closed

[QUOTE=manuscriptreplica]Hey R+M is looking great, but I'm struggling to come to terms with why that thread was closed[/QUOTE]

Couldn't tell you, I didn't close it.

Thanks for the compliment though, from all the mods. :)

[QUOTE=manuscriptreplica]Hey R+M is looking great, but I'm struggling to come to terms with why that thread was closed[/QUOTE]

What type of game thread was it?

[url]http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/member.php?u=156437[/url]

In hopes a super in here will see it. ban him, spamming the punk forum.

It appears that he is already banned.

Hopefully it's not a false title. I'll check the Banned Users list.

EDIT: Yeah, someone beat me to it. :p Feel free to report things like that in this thread. I know I'm more active in this forum than the Mod forum, so if you need to contact me, Bartender, SonorKen, or Superpeer, this thread will probably work. :thumb:

Yeah I just talked to NPC on aim.

[url]http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showthread.php?t=295642[/url]


Advertisment.

[url]http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showthread.php?t=295644[/url]

Favorite thread.

Closed, yo.

Werd, yo!

[url]http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/member.php?userid=159398[/url]

this little assgrab keeps going around adverting for his gay band.

[QUOTE=manuscriptreplica]Yes but the thing is there was no spam in it

And game threads are against the rules? The mods are freakin fun police around here sometimes[/QUOTE]

That thread would've been all spam, people repeatedly posting the same bands and nothing would have came of the thread. I mean, most people would've looked up Google for the harder letters anyway. Nothing productive could have came from it so what would have been the point in keeping it open?

Game threads don't contribute anything to the forum. If you don't appreciate the Moding style around here, then I don't think theres alot you can do.


[url]http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showthread.php?t=295685[/url]
Most dissapoiting album thread.

zepplin thread
[url]http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showthread.php?t=295724[/url]

Games are pretty overdone. We have said that any game will be considered. You can post your idea here. I don't want list games, they are spam and stupid. If it requires thought, and is fun, and ISNT A LIST, then it should be ok.

[url]http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showthread.php?t=295746[/url]

guitar for-hem

[url]http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showthread.php?p=6440256#post6440256[/url]
created an un-needed thread, could have asked in the official thread.

[URL]http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showthread.php?t=295825[/URL]

*sigh*

hey guys really sorry about the megadeth thread learned my lesson and you can close the thread. Sorry for the inconvenience again.

[url]http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showthread.php?t=295932[/url]
This guy tried to hide his thread with the title. It's the same thread that got closed, which was best guitarist in a metal band.

Hah. Thanks.

Glad to help out.

And I'm glad you're willing to. I wouldn't have noticed that thread, having as little interest as I do in the new Megadeth.

Why's a Vs thread "against the rules"? It's a worthy debate, and I just asked for opinions, not for the Forum Nazis.... but thanks anyway kids. You'd think that in a Musician Forum, you'd be free to discuss anything about musicians... doesn't setting really strict rules go AGAINST the whole foundation of music?! How can regulate what you can and can't talk about when it comes to music? This is the worst forum I've EVER been on. If Axl Rose read this, he'd be impressed. James Hetfield on the other hand would call you all fags.

So i AGAIN ask the Mods to re-open this thread, or at least for there opinions, I gave my e-mail, so if this thread just simply CAN NOT be re-opened, I urge people to give me there oppinions.

the last thing I want to do is go onto the metallica thread and say that "guns and roses rocks!" ,or go onto the guns and roses thread and say that "metallica rocks!", just to get people's responces as to why they think differently.

I believe that a VS thread SHOULD be allowed, and would like to know why it isnt!

that is all.

[QUOTE=SLY_GUY]Why's a Vs thread "against the rules"? It's a worthy debate, and I just asked for opinions, not for the Forum Nazis.... but thanks anyway kids. You'd think that in a Musician Forum, you'd be free to discuss anything about musicians... doesn't setting really strict rules go AGAINST the whole foundation of music?! How can regulate what you can and can't talk about when it comes to music? This is the worst forum I've EVER been on. If Axl Rose read this, he'd be impressed. James Hetfield on the other hand would call you all fags.

So i AGAIN ask the Mods to re-open this thread, or at least for there opinions, I gave my e-mail, so if this thread just simply CAN NOT be re-opened, I urge people to give me there oppinions.

the last thing I want to do is go onto the metallica thread and say that "guns and roses rocks!" ,or go onto the guns and roses thread and say that "metallica rocks!", just to get people's responces as to why they think differently.

I believe that a VS thread SHOULD be allowed, and would like to know why it isnt!

that is all.[/QUOTE]


Because people do it in a mindless fashion for the most part, and also compare or pit bands together that are not even comparable. And also it's all opinion, and fanboy's of the bands will come in and start a flame fest out of the thread. To many subjective opinions + fanboys + vs thread = flame fest and spam.

[QUOTE=SLY_GUY]
I believe that a VS thread SHOULD be allowed, and would like to know why it isnt!
[/QUOTE]

How long have you been here?

[QUOTE=SLY_GUY]Why's a Vs thread "against the rules"? It's a worthy debate, and I just asked for opinions, not for the Forum Nazis.... but thanks anyway kids. You'd think that in a Musician Forum, you'd be free to discuss anything about musicians... doesn't setting really strict rules go AGAINST the whole foundation of music?! How can regulate what you can and can't talk about when it comes to music? This is the worst forum I've EVER been on. If Axl Rose read this, he'd be impressed. James Hetfield on the other hand would call you all fags.

So i AGAIN ask the Mods to re-open this thread, or at least for there opinions, I gave my e-mail, so if this thread just simply CAN NOT be re-opened, I urge people to give me there oppinions.

the last thing I want to do is go onto the metallica thread and say that "guns and roses rocks!" ,or go onto the guns and roses thread and say that "metallica rocks!", just to get people's responces as to why they think differently.

I believe that a VS thread SHOULD be allowed, and would like to know why it isnt!

that is all.[/QUOTE]
Correct me if I'm wrong, but I believe the mods will alow you to make a verses thread if you put some thought into it, and the bands/artists are actually comparable. I agree that great disscusion can be made from these threads, but they are always ruined by idiots. We would get a few people actually dissucsing and giving reasons for why they prefer a band, but we would also get "omg u idiot band x is sooooo much better ten band y bany sux teh big 1!!!!1". The majority of these threads are also extreamly over done (ex:Metallica vs. Megadeth) I see your point, but the threads are ruined by idiots.

but these two bands ARE comarable, so simmilar, that this is a really good debate!

and I've been here for just over a day, so maybe I'm too 'new' to understand your crazy rules. (but you would have known that had you read my first post that is on page 161)

I apreciate you spelling it out for me in english EDDIE VAN HALEN 769

[QUOTE=EddieVanHalen769]Correct me if I'm wrong, but I believe the mods will alow you to make a verses thread if you put some thought into it, and the bands/artists are actually comparable. I agree that great disscusion can be made from these threads, but they are always ruined by idiots. We would get a few people actually dissucsing and giving reasons for why they prefer a band, but we would also get "omg u idiot band x is sooooo much better ten band y bany sux teh big 1!!!!1". The majority of these threads are also extreamly over done (ex:Metallica vs. Megadeth) I see your point, but the threads are ruined by idiots.[/QUOTE]


Werd, he covered the rest of it.

And also, if you don't like this forum or the rules, please leave. There are plenty of people here happy with the forums and the rules, and we don't need some new person coming in here and making a big deal out of the rules that doesn't understand how this forum works or its history of problems that are the reason those rules were created.

Ok, quick question. How come when somebody is banned, you cannot rep that person? I just read that "New Megadeth" thread about the best guitarists, and I REALLY wanna neg rep him. Not that my rep will have much effect, but I mean, that was just dumb.

[QUOTE=SLY_GUY]
and I've been here for just over a day, so maybe I'm too 'new' to understand your crazy rules. (but you would have known that had you read my first post that is on page 161)[/QUOTE]

Yes, I know, I did read your other post. I was making a point.

Page after page of vs threads gets annoying, especially after months of them. There are reasons for the rules here, and the basic idea is that rather than starting the 8,000th awful, overdone vs thread, you become a member of the community, and learn people's opinions of various subjects and bands through discussion in other threads. If you want a quickfire, "I WANT MY VS DONE AND YOU'RE ALL FAGS IF YOU DON'T LET ME" thread, to get context-less, shallow responses, go to a different music forum and leave this one alone.

Oh, and for the thing on your post on page 161, Guns N' Roses and Metallica are not comparable. They are not even in the same genre of music and you want to compare them?


[url]http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showpost.php?p=6445067&postcount=90[/url]

This guy deserves a nice ban slapping.

Okay, he's gone for a couple of days.