[QUOTE=Cocaine;17910860]is this suppposd to be an elite list, a beginners list or a definitive list[/QUOTE]

Moreso just a definitive list.

[QUOTE=Cocaine;17910860]is this suppposd to be an elite list, a beginners list or a definitive list[/QUOTE]

Elite and definitive.

It can't really be an elite list if we have UO, Chariot, and Norma Jean on it.


[QUOTE=RetiredAt21;17910858]...dude gtfo srsly.[/QUOTE]

They aren't man, sry you getting so riled up, and this is pretty much my thread now:cool:

You wish.

Cha dude, this and the grind thread are practically mine, Lol. But seriously Justin you don't need to pms cause I exlcuded some of your elite bands.

Dude a lot of the stupid **** you listen to wouldn't even be around if it weren't for The Swarm and Left for Dead.

EDIT: you're starting to show how clueless you really are.

Cool story bro.

So how about dat list?

I will not be satisfied until The Swarm and Left for Dead are added.

L4D rules

Fine, lets add both back.

Should we break them up into categories, like idk, 90's / Early 2000 / Modern? Something along those lines.

I should've made a list but I'm too lazy right now to think of Metalcore plus I haven't listen to much Metalcore lately or at all but some of the bands mentioned on some of those lists are pretty mediocre. A lot of essential/awesome **** of course but still, Misery Signals? Norma Jean? siKTH? The Chariot? meh.

and Watchmaker are not metalcore.

how bout who gives a ****

how bout i love you baby :3

should we break our love up into different categories like sex/you buying me dinner/me cleaning you off when you spill food on your shirt/not sweating the little things/etc?

i love how you categorize yourself as a woman right from the start :)

And as long as sex is in on top of the list we are good to go :3

[QUOTE=HighandDriving;17910841]I disagree with both of them, if other ppl don't back you up I say we hold off from putting them on the list.[/QUOTE]

I definitely back up Breathing Is Irrelevant.

I don't know if we can talk about SikTh in this thread but I wish they reunited. :(

I do too. they were unique and ****ing amazing.

SikTh was one of the best metal bands, period. I always wonder if they fit here or in the progressive metal thread. pretty sure they fit in both. same with btbam; TSC made it into our definitive metalcore list but by the time they got to Alaska onward it's really not metalcore anymore..

[I]SikTh was one of the best metal bands, period.[/I]

Wowzors.

SikTh annoyed the **** out of me at times

yeah, not even close

I take back nothing

[QUOTE=Apoc;17910120]Architects, Shai Hulud, Dillinger Escape Plan, Every Time I Die, and Oathbreaker are all awesome[/QUOTE]

I've tried numerous times to get into DEP, but I can never seem to do it, I don't know what it is. And for ETID, is there a specific album to start with? Or should I just go from the beginning?

[QUOTE=witchxrapist;17910167]I consider these essential metalcore:
[I]A crap load of bands[/I] [/QUOTE]

What, no Killswitch? :D

Haha, thanks WxR, I guess I know what I'll be doing this summer. :thumb:

[QUOTE]And for ETID, is there a specific album to start with? Or should I just go from the beginning?[/QUOTE]
If you want their more 'tech' side, get Last Night in Town, if you want their best album get Hot Damn!

[QUOTE=shortz;17911193]I've tried numerous times to get into DEP, but I can never seem to do it, I don't know what it is. And for ETID, is there a specific album to start with? Or should I just go from the beginning?[/QUOTE]

As for DEP, Miss Machine is considered a classic, and for good reason. I recommend starting there.

Where ETID is concerned, to add to Cocaine's suggestion, I really like The Big Dirty and New Junk Aesthetic but I'm in the minority on that one.

New Junk Aesthetic is pretty decent.

[quote=shortz;17911193]I've tried numerous times to get into DEP, but I can never seem to do it, I don't know what it is.[/quote]
You need better maths skills.

[QUOTE=Apoc;17911356]As for DEP, Miss Machine is considered a classic, and for good reason. I recommend starting there.

Where ETID is concerned, to add to Cocaine's suggestion, I really like The Big Dirty and New Junk Aesthetic but I'm in the minority on that one.[/QUOTE]

NJA is good but I wouldn't want somebody to start on tBD. Either Hot Damn or Gutter Phenomenon.

fair enough