I'd like to add :

Buried Alive - Last Rites
Buried Inside - Chronoclast
Architects - Nightmares
sikTh - The Trees Are Dead & Dried Out Wait for Something Wild

Agreed, minus Buried Inside. Editing now.

Also, deadguy's fixation on a co-worker is their best imo.

I agree, I guess I'll change some of them like Coalesce, but with bands like them and Botch it's hard to pick their "Magnus Opus", or "Go-To" albums.

****, I totally forgot about Buried Alive. They rule.

[QUOTE=HighandDriving;17910525]minus Buried Inside.[/QUOTE]
what :mad:

hm i might check some of the ones i dont have, haven't really listened to metalcore in a long while

[QUOTE]Systral - Black Smoker[/QUOTE]

most underrated album in the genre

if you dont have that album in your list foad

Shame we can't edit these lists into the first post, because this thread was started by that ****ing mook hbp.

Maybe starting a new one or getting the mods to edit them in would be a good idea.

Also the list is quite beneficial to me, formatted my laptop and didn't have anything backed up (stupid I know but I am a poor student can't afford a external HD for a few weeks) so it's been a reminder of some the more obscure artists and albums I couldn't remember.

[QUOTE=Txus;17910597]most underrated album in the genre

if you dont have that album in your list foad[/QUOTE]

Yeah Systral owns.

Ya I don't know which one of you guys introduced me to them, but thanks.

I introduced mad noobs to the world of elite metalcore.

You calling me a noob.....punk.

Dude at one point you were listening to entry-level stuff pretty much exclusively.

[QUOTE=2muchket!;17910598]Shame we can't edit these lists into the first post, because this thread was started by that ****ing mook hbp.

Maybe starting a new one or getting the mods to edit them in would be a good idea.

Also the list is quite beneficial to me, formatted my laptop and didn't have anything backed up (stupid I know but I am a poor student can't afford a external HD for a few weeks) so it's been a reminder of some the more obscure artists and albums I couldn't remember.[/QUOTE]

I can, actually, edit it into the first post. Come up with something definitive and I will.

[QUOTE=RetiredAt21;17910772]Dude at one point you were listening to entry-level stuff pretty much exclusively.[/QUOTE]

:lol: BBTS, Cave In, Botch, Coalesce, Knut, and Integrity have been some of my favourite metalcore bands for almost 3 years. I was talking about these guys before you even came back from your hiatus. Ya I like some Mappy bands, sue me.

[QUOTE=Cocaine;17910781]I can, actually, edit it into the first post. Come up with something definitive and I will.[/QUOTE]

Just merge me, Justin, Frankie, and HAD's lists together, and add a few bands you think should fit, cause I know you listen to some elite metalcore too.

Yo Mappy whatcha think of the list below?

[QUOTE=Cocaine;17910781]I can, actually, edit it into the first post. Come up with something definitive and I will.[/QUOTE]

This -

[QUOTE=HighandDriving;17910508]

Converge - [I]Jane Doe[/I]
Botch - [I]American Nervoso[/I]
Knut - [I]Challenger[/I]
Skycamefalling - [I]10.21[/I]
The Dillinger Escape Plan - [I]Calculating Infinity[/I]
Kiss It Goodbye - [I]She Loves Me, She Loves Me Not[/I]
Deadguy - [I]Fixation On A Co-Worker[/I]
Undying - [I]At History's End[/I]
Rosesdead - [I]Stages[/I]
Drowning Man - [I]Don't Touch Us When We're Hot[/I]
Coalesce - [I]Last Call For The Living[/I]
Burnt By The Sun - [I]Soundtrack To The Personal Revolution[/I]
Watchmaker - [I]Erased From The Memory Of Man[/I]
Indecision - [I]Unorthodox[/I]
Shai Hulud - [I]Hopes Once Nourished With Hope And Compassion[/I]
7 Angels 7 Plagues - [I]Jhazmyne's Lullaby[/I]
The Secret - [I]Luce[/I]
Norma Jean - [I]O'God The Aftermath[/I]
Misery Signals - [I]Of Malice And The Magnum Heart[/I]
Taken - [I]Finding Solace In Dissension[/I]
Underoath - [I]The Changing Of Times[/I]
Posion The Well - [I]The Opposite Of December[/I]
Every Time I Die - [I]Hot Damn![/I]
Unbroken - [I]Life. Love. Regret.[/I]
Disembodied - [I]Diablerie, If Only God Knew the Rest Were Dead and Existence in Suicide[/I]
Racetraitor - [I]Burn the Idol of the White Messiah[/I]
Chokehold - [I]Content With Dying[/I]
Integrity – [I]Humanity is the Devil[/I]
Systral - [I]Black Smoker[/I]
Tears of Gaia – [I]Burial[/I]
The Chariot - [I]Everything Is Alive, Everything Is Breathing, Nothing Is Dead, and Nothing Is Bleeding[/I]
Cave In – [I]Until Your Heart Stops[/I]
Fear Before - [I]Art Damage[/I]
The End - [I]Transfer Trachea Reverberations from Point: False Omniscient[/I]
Premonitions of War - [I]Left in Kowloon[/I]
Buried Alive - [I]Last Rites [/I]
Architects - [I]Nightmares[/I]
sikTh - [I]The Trees Are Dead & Dried Out Wait for Something Wild[/I][/QUOTE]

It's def a good list.

I'm telling you if we mixed me, you, Liam, and Justin's lists we'd have pretty much the perfect list of essential metalcore, even if I don't like everything you listed (i.e. Fear Before).

Can't believe I missed Cave In.

Are 7 Angels 7 Plagues like Magnum era MS or Controller era MS?

Better.

Oh, Despised Icon - [I]The Healing Process[/I] and Ion Dissonance - [I]Breathing Is Irrelevant[/I] should be on the essential metalcore list, just because of how influencial they are to the deathcore scene, while staying quite metalcore ruited.

And 7A7P isn't really that much like Misery Signals. It's more a lot of cleaner guitars doing airy melodic riffs and breakdowns with REALLY raw vocals.

[QUOTE=witchxrapist;17910820]It's def a good list.

I'm telling you if we mixed me, you, Liam, and Justin's lists we'd have pretty much the perfect list of essential metalcore, even if I don't like everything you listed (i.e. Fear Before).

Can't believe I missed Cave In.[/QUOTE]

I tried to do that but picked out some I don't think make the cut, I'd be cool with adding the ones I took out back. But Rifs Before Recess are too deathy to be considered metalcore and ATTS, while similar to metalcore, is pretty much whitebelt. You'd like Fear Before - Art Damage, it's way different from their other stuff, sicccck riffage.


[QUOTE=witchxrapist;17910835]Oh, Despised Icon - [I]The Healing Process[/I] and Ion Dissonance - [I]Breathing Is Irrelevant[/I] should be on the essential metalcore list, just because of how influencial they are to the deathcore scene, while staying quite metalcore ruited.

And 7A7P isn't really that much like Misery Signals. It's more a lot of cleaner guitars doing airy melodic riffs and breakdowns with REALLY raw vocals.[/QUOTE]

I disagree with both of them, if other ppl don't back you up I say we hold off from putting them on the list.

Rifles At Recess is one of those early deathcore bands that was still mad hardcore, imo, like listen to [I]Here's To The Broken Boys[/I] or [I]I Died Twenty Times In 1986[/I].

Same with Despised Icon and Ion Dissonance.

It's the new deathcore bands that wouldn't make the cut imo, cause I mean, it's just bad death metal + breakdowns.

As for As The Sun Sets, I've seen this debated lots of places. They definitely have a mix of "mathcore" and whitebelt elements, and just their whole influence on the fake-grind-that's-actually-metalcore scene is through the roof.

[QUOTE=HighandDriving;17910841]I tried to do that but picked out some I don't think make the cut, I'd be cool with adding the ones I took out back. But Rifs Before Recess are too deathy to be considered metalcore and ATTS, while similar to metalcore, is pretty much whitebelt. You'd like Fear Before - Art Damage, it's way different from their other stuff, sicccck riffage.




I disagree with both of them, if other ppl don't back you up I say we hold off from putting them on the list.[/QUOTE]

Dunno what else you missed but you left out Left for Dead and The Swarm, noob.

EDIT: aaaaand Chokehold. Still a noob in my book.

Justin, you can't expect everyone to remember every elite band, that's why we're compling this list as a group. :)

BUT I DO BOW TO YOUR MASTERY.

Also, some sputnik noobs response to my 30 essential metalcore albums list I posted last night:
[url]http://www.sputnikmusic.com/list.php?listid=43518[/url]

:lol:

Oh, also need to be added:
Aftershock - [I]Propaganda[/I]
Starkweather - [I]Crossbearer[/I]
Overcast - [I]Fight Ambition To Kill[/I]

I will fight anyone who I feel isn't properly heiling elite metalcore.

EDIT: hahahaha that list looks like it was made by this dude I know.

[QUOTE=RetiredAt21;17910844]Dunno what else you missed but you left out Left for Dead and The Swarm, noob.

EDIT: aaaaand Chokehold. Still a noob in my book.[/QUOTE]

L4D and The Swarm aren't that amazing, and Chokeholds there, derrrrrr.

[QUOTE=HighandDriving;17910856][B]L4D and The Swarm aren't that amazing[/B], and Chokeholds there, derrrrrr.[/QUOTE]

...dude gtfo srsly.

is this suppposd to be an elite list, a beginners list or a definitive list

[QUOTE=witchxrapist;17910850]Justin, you can't expect everyone to remember every elite band, that's why we're compling this list as a group. :)

BUT I DO BOW TO YOUR MASTERY.

Also, some sputnik noobs response to my 30 essential metalcore albums list I posted last night:
[url]http://www.sputnikmusic.com/list.php?listid=43518[/url]

:lol:[/QUOTE]

We are compling this list as a group but obvious bands will be excluded.

At least the list has O'God the Aftermath.