[QUOTE=lunch998]I'd say Robert Plant was a music god just because of stage presence. And we came to the conclusion awhile ago that Electric Ladyland was better than Band of Gypsys.[/QUOTE]

Bonham>page>Jones>Plant

On a side note:Happy b-day Rob :chug:

'Little Wing' is probably my favorite Jimi Hendrix song, just the softness and slow emotional flutter of it all. It sounds so great, that I'm disappointed it's not all that long. Oh well, there's always Stevie Ray Vaughan's version for that :)

I only have Jimi's Woodstock performance, but I want Live at Berkeley Palace - anybody know if it's any good?

I wasn't talking about talent wise, but people viewed him as a god on stage.

Oh and the Live at Berkely CD is amazing. The best Hendrix live CD I've heard.

[QUOTE=lunch998]I wasn't talking about talent wise, but people viewed him as a god on stage.[/QUOTE]
If you are talking to me, then I was referring to the Electric Ladyland-Band of Gypsys debate. I don't like Led Zeppelin all that much.

[QUOTE=lunch998]Oh and the Live at Berkely CD is amazing. The best Hendrix live CD I've heard.[/QUOTE]
Really? I've heard good things about it, I didn't know if I wanted it though. Don't know if I can stand another 14-minute version of "Voodoo Child" :lol:

[QUOTE=themightyquinn23]If you are talking to me, then I was referring to the Electric Ladyland-Band of Gypsys debate. I don't like Led Zeppelin all that much.[/QUOTE]

My Bad I was talking to the person who said Bonham>Page>Jones>Plant. I would have backed you up if I was around.

[QUOTE=Gimmick]Really? I've heard good things about it, I didn't know if I wanted it though. Don't know if I can stand another 14-minute version of "Voodoo Child" :lol:[/QUOTE]

All the songs are such good quality though, and it's the only live CD with Pass it On(Straight Ahead) on it, which makes the whole CD awesome.

[QUOTE=lunch998]All the songs are such good quality though, and it's the only live CD with Pass it On(Straight Ahead) on it, which makes the whole CD awesome.[/QUOTE]
Sounds good, I'll probably check it out pretty soon. However, I got a lot of Dylan, Doors, and Floyd today for my birthday, so I might have to listen through that. :)

Keith Moon = Rock God

[QUOTE=badmoon349]Keith Moon = Rock God[/QUOTE]

I was thinking about someone from the Who. Keith Moon is probably the best pick, but by 69-70 Roger Daltrey had that frontman God thing going for him, especially live.

David Gilmour perhaps? That guy could reach new planes with his guitar playing. The emotion, the pyschadelic feel, and the melody were all there in all of his solos.

When you think about it, all of The Who are Rock Gods. Unbelievable showey, talented, unique drummer. Unique, ground breaking bassist, genious writer, and good guitarist/vocalist. And one of the most powerful and greatest frontmen.

[QUOTE=badmoon349]When you think about it, all of The Who are Rock Gods. Unbelievable showey, talented, unique drummer. Unique, ground breaking bassist, genious writer, and good guitarist/vocalist. And one of the most powerful and greatest frontmen.[/QUOTE]
Well, the bassist wasn't really a rock god. He was definitely very talented, but he didn't go into the limelight much, he just stood still and played his part. Townsend was definitely a great showman along with Keith and Roger. Those three together were rock gods perhaps, but I just think John was a little too stiff to be a 'rock god'.

[QUOTE=badmoon349]When you think about it, all of The Who are Rock Gods. Unbelievable showey, talented, unique drummer. Unique, ground breaking bassist, genious writer, and good guitarist/vocalist. And one of the most powerful and greatest frontmen.[/QUOTE]

Pretty much, yea. There's no denying any of their talent or live performances. Destroying all their gear helped too, I guess.

[QUOTE=badmoon349]When you think about it, all of The Who are Rock Gods. Unbelievable showey, talented, unique drummer. Unique, ground breaking bassist, genious writer, and good guitarist/vocalist. And one of the most powerful and greatest frontmen.[/QUOTE]

Well they certainly were worshiped like gods back in the day. And they played a huge part in the british invastion.

Yep I guess they are. plus they hold the record for loudest concert ;) (poor pete and his ear thing though).

[QUOTE=Gimmick]Well, the bassist wasn't really a rock god. He was definitely very talented, but he didn't go into the limelight much, he just stood still and played his part. Townsend was definitely a great showman along with Keith and Roger. Those three together were rock gods perhaps, but I just think John was a little too stiff to be a 'rock god'.[/QUOTE]

I guess, but as far as Classic Rock bassists go he is definitely one of best. Maybe by himself he wasn't a god, but on stage with the Who I think he was.

[QUOTE=Gimmick]Well, the bassist wasn't really a rock god. He was definitely very talented, but he didn't go into the limelight much, he just stood still and played his part. Townsend was definitely a great showman along with Keith and Roger. Those three together were rock gods perhaps, but I just think John was a little too stiff to be a 'rock god'.[/QUOTE]

For Entwistle it's not about the showmanship. He's the backbone of The Who, and probably the greatest Classic Rock bassist, and probably one of the most influential bassists ever. He has done so much for bass playing it's crazy.

Oh, I wasn't denying his influence at all. He is a tremendous player with wide influence and playing ability. When I think of a rock god however I think of somebody with more of an electrifying or strong personality. He was more hidden and out of the picture.

It's a shame bassists are overlooked so much. Up with John Entwhistle, Jack Bruce, and John Paul Jones.

On a bit of an unrelated note - can anybody tell me all the members of The Band and what they played?

Also, any recommendations for songs/albums/recordings that I should look for of the Band?

I wouldn't say as much JPJ. He's a decent bassist, and a great musician, but if we're talking skill, he's nothing next to Jack Bruce and Entwistle. Atleast I don't think so.

[QUOTE=badmoon349]I wouldn't say as much JPJ. He's a decent bassist, and a great musician, but if we're talking skill, he's nothing next to Jack Bruce and Entwistle. Atleast I don't think so.[/QUOTE]

I wasn't sure if I should group him with Bruce and Entwistle, but JPJ is overlooked in Led Zeppelin too much, so that's what I was getting at.

[QUOTE=badmoon349]I wouldn't say as much JPJ. He's a decent bassist, and a great musician, but if we're talking skill, he's nothing next to Jack Bruce and Entwistle. Atleast I don't think so.[/QUOTE]

I wouldn't say that he's nothing compared to them. He's very good. But I agree that they are both better.

Silvertide rules!!

Both revolutionized lead bass playing, aswell as Phil Lesh.

Lennon - Give Peace a Chance = Greatest verses ever!

^Ill Agree

[QUOTE=rock not rolled]Hendrix rocks as we all know. One of (not the greatest) guitarists of all time. My favorite album is electric ladyland. Everybody always says that Are you experienced is his best because of purple haze. I think that the music is just generally better on electric ladyland.

Anyone else agree?[/QUOTE]

No I think Are you Are you experienced is much better but Band of Gypsys is his best.........Has anyone herd the Blues Hendrix album?

Yeah, his Blues is just okay to me.

I love Red House

I love playing Red House.

*Sucks at playing Red House for some reason*

O well

Jimi Hendrix Is The Greatest Guitar Player Ever To Live He Rocks!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Yayayayayayyayayyayayayyaywhoooooooooo He Ios The Best

I completely agree (about Classic Rock making a revival).

But I can't help but notice how a lot of you haven't mentioned Pink Floyd, a band composed entirely of gods of rock.

Pink Floyd are the ultimate Gods of Classic Rock, and it does get discussed in here alot. However I muched prefered them with Syd Barret, which they only got one album done (Piper at the Gates of Dawn) before he went crazy, but he wrote most of their songs for the wall and other albums.

Bah, they don't mention Pink Floyd enough then.

Floyd, in general, is to depressing for my tastes. I do enjoy a few of there songs, like Wish your were hear and Money and all that, but I just can't listen to Welcom to the Machine. It gets me in such a bad mood.

:confused:

Roger Waters wrote the Wall.

Barrett wrote a few of the songs though.