[QUOTE=leppermessiah]no need to apologize, i was just happy to actually be there. :p I'm pretty sure John plays keyboards and piano, Paul might've on some tracks. Don't know who plays harmonica on songs like "love me do"..my guess would be Paul.[/QUOTE]

Ringo plays harmonica on Love Me Do. He had just joined the band about two weeks before the single's release.

really? didn't know that. how about in sgt. pepper? who played those instruments?

[QUOTE=DeusExMachina]George Martin played that funny keyboard solo on In My Life, if I'm not mistaken.[/QUOTE]
Haha, it's hard for me to picture that.

[QUOTE=Canadian_Guy]Ringo plays harmonica on Love Me Do. He had just joined the band about two weeks before the single's release.[/QUOTE]
Then why does John play it during live performances?

Ringo never played harmonica. John did, but he was later embarresed by it.

Yes, Mr. Martin did do the organ thingie in In My Life at halfspeed.

If you read John's first few pages in the anthology it talks about him playing harmonica

[QUOTE=Canadian_Guy]Ringo plays harmonica on Love Me Do. He had just joined the band about two weeks before the single's release.[/QUOTE]

I know for fact that it was john cause john was originally supposed to sing the lead part for love me do but couldnt cause he had to play the mouth harp.

sounds like quite the debate. I have no clue who played the harmonica so i'll just keep watching lol.

John also played the harmonica on "Oh Yoko!" off his solo album Imagine.

Earlier in this thread people were saying that Paul invented his own unique scream but I think his sounds a lot like Little Richard's on songs such as Tutti-Frutti and Good Golly miss Molly.

Paul played drums for a short period while Ringo was off having a break from the band when he felt out of it.

[QUOTE=Walrus Gumboot]If you read John's first few pages in the anthology it talks about him playing harmonica[/QUOTE]

It's hard to go against an anthology. I'm gonna have to go with John on this one.

[QUOTE=clown_phobia]John also played the harmonica on "Oh Yoko!" off his solo album Imagine.

Earlier in this thread people were saying that Paul invented his own unique scream but I think his sounds a lot like Little Richard's on songs such as Tutti-Frutti and Good Golly miss Molly.[/QUOTE]

That solo in Oh Yoko! Is one of my favorites (I say that about most harmonica solos)
AND John played it in a Hard Day's Night he played it in " I Should Have Known Better"

Once upon a timeI saw some parody of Little Richard where he was like "I taught Paul McCartney how to scream!"

[QUOTE=TheDMV]It's hard to go against an anthology. I'm gonna have to go with John on this one.[/QUOTE]

The anthology is all-knowing.


*opens anthology*


*holy grail-like shine filters out of book*

[QUOTE=Canadian_Guy]The anthology is all-knowing.


*opens anthology*


*holy grail-like shine filters out of book*[/QUOTE]

It just has that effect

Somehow with that avatar, it seems as if you actually are Bob Dylan, it's strange...

[QUOTE=JamesPatrickPageZoSo]I know for fact that it was john cause john was originally supposed to sing the lead part for love me do but couldnt cause he had to play the mouth harp.[/QUOTE]

Wait a second! There was a harmonica on Love Me Do?!?!!?!?!?!?!

(kidding...)

[QUOTE=DeusExMachina]Wait a second! There was a harmonica on Love Me Do?!?!!?!?!?!?!

(kidding...)[/QUOTE]


I just found myself humming that song, but it was before I entered this thread! :eek:

its a sign

I heard Paul played guitar on some songs..which were they?

blackbird, yesterday are two....

[QUOTE=Walrus Gumboot]It just has that effect

Somehow with that avatar, it seems as if you actually are Bob Dylan, it's strange...[/QUOTE]

OH SH[COLOR=White]I[/COLOR]T MY COVER HAS BEEN BLO - I mean, that's just silly! Perish the thought at once.

Please tell me some great facts only fanatics would know.

[url]http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/attachment.php?attachmentid=14353&stc=1[/url]

Proof that John plays harmonica.

[QUOTE=Sgt_Pepper]I heard Paul played guitar on some songs..which were they?[/QUOTE]

I think played lead on Taxman and She came in through the bathroom window.

On the "Back in the Us" DvD he plays guitar on a bunch of songs. The best by far is when he plays "Sgt. Peppers Lonely hearts club band (Reprise)" and "The End" It really shows how he still knows how to rock. If you have the money, and youre a McCartney fan, i STRONGLY suggest you pick up this DvD. Its my favorite DvD in my extensive collection Ive watched at least over 100 times now.

/Hardcore McCartney fan.

[QUOTE=clown_phobia]Please tell me some great facts only fanatics would know.[/QUOTE]

Paul and john when they were young, took a bus over 50 miles across town to meet a kid that knew the B7 chord. (or Bm i cant remember)

Paul and John met george on a bus, and once they heard him play, they put him in the band.

Before Ringo was in the beatles he played in a band called "Rorrey and the Hurricains"

I read alot of books about the beatles in junior high.

Has anyone seen the ticket prices for Paul Mccartney's US tour? They're ridiculously overpriced in my opinion.

I know. I'm still going. :D

[QUOTE=Iron_Weed][url]http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/attachment.php?attachmentid=14353&stc=1[/url]

Proof that John plays harmonica.[/QUOTE]

Bull. He's sneezing.

[QUOTE=GeorgeHarrison]I think played lead on Taxman and She came in through the bathroom window.

On the "Back in the Us" DvD he plays guitar on a bunch of songs. The best by far is when he plays "Sgt. Peppers Lonely hearts club band (Reprise)" and "The End" It really shows how he still knows how to rock. If you have the money, and youre a McCartney fan, i STRONGLY suggest you pick up this DvD. Its my favorite DvD in my extensive collection Ive watched at least over 100 times now.

/Hardcore McCartney fan.[/QUOTE]
I have the Back in the US DVD too, I love it.

I've got the CD.

[QUOTE=GeorgeHarrison]Paul and john when they were young, took a bus over 50 miles across town to meet a kid that knew the B7 chord. (or Bm i cant remember)

Paul and John met george on a bus, and once they heard him play, they put him in the band.

Before Ringo was in the beatles he played in a band called "Rorrey and the Hurricains"

I read alot of books about the beatles in junior high.[/QUOTE]

I thought John saw Paul play with his band and he invited him to join the band, and then Paul introduced John to George. They didnt both meet him at the same time...in the Imagine documentary John says he picked paul as his partner not george, george came through paul.