[QUOTE=Disconnection Notice]Those choices aren't particularly original.[/QUOTE]
The Wall, DSOTM, Sgt. Peppers and Tommy were the only choices.

[QUOTE=Livewired]The Wall, DSOTM, Sgt. Peppers and Tommy were the only choices.[/QUOTE]

I figured that out after backtracking a few pages.

[QUOTE=Schyma]I wish I had some Zappa and Crimson....:(


Hey Moon you should do a FA on the Dead. :)[/QUOTE]

i can send you some of both. if you want. my aim is PinkFreud05

For my senior paper, I decided to do a report on Storytelling Through Rock Music : Concept Albums, Rock Opera, and Prog Rock. Its gonna be very spiffy. I've been spending all my time at the library checking out every single Prog CD I can get my hands on...its been fun.

So far I've only heard Thick as a Brick (very **** good album) and I have plenty others on hold.

God, I miss those debates.

So, what do you think about maybe.. Tommy vs Sgt Peppers or Tommy vs The Wall?


Edit: Moon, if you want, I'll do all the organization crap and such. I'll record it and post it too.

just do Tommy because it rocks

[QUOTE=Seafroggys]For my senior paper, I decided to do a report on Storytelling Through Rock Music : Concept Albums, Rock Opera, and Prog Rock. Its gonna be very spiffy. I've been spending all my time at the library checking out every single Prog CD I can get my hands on...its been fun.

So far I've only heard Thick as a Brick (very **** good album) and I have plenty others on hold.[/QUOTE]

I wish I could write a paper on music or something like that.

[QUOTE=thickasabrick]

What do you all think of Donovan? I've probably asked this before. I think he's great...favourite songs are probably Hurdy Gurdy Man, Colours, and Mellow Yellow. Most of his songs are great though.[/QUOTE]

I like Season of the Witch

[QUOTE=MalcolmYoungRock]God, I miss those debates.

So, what do you think about maybe.. Tommy vs Sgt Peppers or Tommy vs The Wall?


Edit: Moon, if you want, I'll do all the organization crap and such. I'll record it and post it too.[/QUOTE]
Yeah those debates were awesome.


Even though Zeppelin got schooled. That's when I still thought JPJ was a n00b/Fanboy.

[QUOTE=Johnny B. Good]just do Tommy because it rocks[/QUOTE]


Do you understand the concept of a debate?

There has to be two or more sides.

Sillyhead.

[QUOTE=MalcolmYoungRock]Do you understand the concept of a debate?

There has to be two or more sides.

Sillyhead.[/QUOTE]

Is Tommy really comparable to Sgt. Peppers?

If there are double LPs like Tommy they shouldn't be pitted against albums that aren't-- unfair advantage, you know

[QUOTE=Livewired]Yeah those debates were awesome.


Even though Zeppelin got schooled. That's when I still thought JPJ was a n00b/Fanboy.[/QUOTE]


What was it, Lunch, JPJ and I on Zeppelin and You, Badmoon, and Rock not rolled on the Who.

We got fuc[color=white]king[/color] owned. :lol:

Oh, and Miik occasionally went from side to side.

[QUOTE=MalcolmYoungRock]Do you understand the concept of a debate?

There has to be two or more sides.

Sillyhead.[/QUOTE]
I think he was talking to Seafroggys.

[QUOTE=Livewired]I think he was talking to Seafroggys.[/QUOTE]

I was talking to Johnny B Good, look at the quote.

So Tommy vs The Wall, because I'm sure Sgt Pepper's would kill.

??

yes I was talking to Seafroggys

[QUOTE=MalcolmYoungRock]What was it, Lunch, JPJ and I on Zeppelin and You, Badmoon, and Rock not rolled on the Who.

We got fuc[color=white]king[/color] owned. :lol:

Oh, and Miik occasionally went from side to side.[/QUOTE]

I was originally for The Who, then fought for both sides once I saw the ownage.

[QUOTE=MalcolmYoungRock]What was it, Lunch, JPJ and I on Zeppelin and You, Badmoon, and Rock not rolled on the Who.

We got fuc[color=white]king[/color] owned. :lol:

Oh, and Miik occasionally went from side to side.[/QUOTE]
Lunch was on the Who side and Rock was on ours, i think.

[QUOTE=MalcolmYoungRock]I was talking to Johnny B Good, look at the quote.

So Tommy vs The Wall, because I'm sure Sgt Pepper's would kill.

??[/QUOTE]

I think Sgt. Pepper's is overrated.

One could argue that [I]Blood on the Tracks[/I] was a concept album, even though it would be hard to do.

[QUOTE=lunch998]I was originally for The Who, then fought for both sides once I saw the ownage.[/QUOTE]


Who else was on Zeppelin?? Magicbus?

Over the last year, i have liked the Who more than Zeppelin

[QUOTE=MalcolmYoungRock]Who else was on Zeppelin?? Magicbus?[/QUOTE]

Don't remember. All I remember was that I played a crucial role for both sides.

What was the debate about?

[QUOTE=Johnny B. Good]What was the debate about?[/QUOTE]

Who was better, basically. We compared individual skill, influence, and other things.

[QUOTE=lunch998]Don't remember. All I remember was that I played a crucial role for both sides.[/QUOTE]

We could have done without ya ;)

[QUOTE=Johnny B. Good]What was the debate about?[/QUOTE]


Look back about 200 or 300 pages and you'll see the whole thing.

Who won the debate?

[QUOTE=Badmoon]We could have done without ya ;)[/QUOTE]

Hah. Yea right.

Seriously