audacity

whats that supposed to mean

free software = you are bad because money equals quality

I liked your stuff, ethan, but you need to hire someone to properly master your work

it was barely listenable

it's hardly barely listenable lol

jesus haven't any of you heard any tour demos

it's obviously listenable

it is barely listenable, it's so loud and everything is clipping all of the time to the point where it hurts my ears to listen to it

turn it down ya shitter

what are you listening on? nothing is clipping except the cymbals at some points and overcompression causes some staticy shit from time to time

trust me I don't need to hear about the mix I know but it's a first release and just so we have something to put on a merch table.

[QUOTE=publicastration;18833535]what are you listening on? nothing is clipping except the cymbals at some points[/QUOTE]

look at the waveform dude

[QUOTE=publicastration;18833535]what are you listening on? nothing is clipping except the cymbals at some points[/QUOTE]

sennheiser hd650

@fingers
well that's not a real solution but yeah that would make it listenable


I don't see why you can't just agree that you need a real sound engineer to master your work. I even said I liked it just that the mastering sucked

when have I disagreed that it could use real production? It's more or less a tour demo so I don't think production matters as much at this point

[QUOTE=publicastration;18832025][url]http://eurekadriver.bandcamp.com/album/i-hardly-knew-her-ep[/url]

:rolleyes:[/QUOTE]

it was nice of you to give deaf people the opportunity to work in the music world.

was it the same deaf guy throughout, or did you have4 a different on for engineering, production and mastering?

it was done really haphazardly and trust me our 2nd guitarist (if he's with us that long) is not touching any more production

more or less we tracked in logic then exported the wavs into another program for another dude to "master" then took two mono exports from that panned em and smashed em together yeah it's really not good

[QUOTE=publicastration;18833544]when have I disagreed that it could use real production? It's more or less a tour demo so I don't think production matters as much at this point[/QUOTE]

well I dunno you got all insulted when I said you needed it

and ah I thought it was supposed to be an ep

you know since it has EP in the name

[IMG]http://i.imgur.com/ctWCi.png[/IMG]
[IMG]http://i.imgur.com/9dnEq.png[/IMG]

tons of clipping

[QUOTE=Gorgon;18833555]well I dunno you got all insulted when I said you needed it

and ah I thought it was supposed to be an ep

you know since it has EP in the name[/QUOTE]

I kept telling them to call it a demo

and to be honest maybe its just the speakers I'm listening on but you can more or less hear everything pretty well so I don't think that's "hardly listenable". clipping doesnt bother me cause i listen to a lot of bm though so idk

@Mr. Reviewer - don't need the analysis to hear that - sounds like shit from the off

don't need your comments to know it's not great when I've acknowledged as such many times

but you know

totally constructive criticism on the least important aspect of the subject

[i]what this forum is known for[/i]

well he said nothing was clipping except the cymbals so i was just

[quote]don't need your comments to know it's not great

but you know

totally constructive criticism on the least important aspect of this release

what this forum is known for[/quote]

the overall sound is the least important aspect?

[QUOTE=publicastration;18833562]I kept telling them to call it a demo

and to be honest maybe its just the speakers I'm listening on but you can more or less hear everything pretty well so I don't think that's "hardly listenable". clipping doesnt bother me cause i listen to a lot of bm though so idk[/QUOTE]

ahh well that'd be better

I have a pretty nice headphone set up and a really nice speaker set up (dad gave it to me :3) so clipping really gets on my nerves. I could listen to it, that's why I said it was barely listenable, I just mean that the clipping etc. makes it annoying

the music was good though

I wil give it a better listen through and tell you what I think. I play bass so maybe that'd be the best advice I can give? I've been playing for 7 years, if that makes a difference.

yeah the music itself isnt bad
from what i could hear at least

yeah you probably would hear the clipping more on headphones too

i should have stepped up and had more of a hand in the production it would have sounded loads better. our 2nd guitarist just acts like he knows what he's doing (he doesn't) and we wanted to get something out so we just went with what we could work with. You should have heard the tracks right after they were "mastered" before I bitched about them, shittons of reverb on. EVERYTHING.

[QUOTE=StaffReviewer;18833568]


the overall sound is the least important aspect?[/QUOTE]

well in something i would call a demo yeah

[QUOTE=publicastration;18833565]don't need your comments to know it's not great when I've acknowledged as such many times

but you know

totally constructive criticism on the least important aspect of the subject

[i]what this forum is known for[/i][/QUOTE]

there's this thing called the volume control.

if i want it louder i turn it up, if i want it quieter, i turn it down. the quality will remain the same. it's a shame what you've linked is clippy as all hell and detracts significantly from the listening experience because i'm sat here going "this sounds bad".

thats true i guess

[quote]i should have stepped up and had more of a hand in the production it would have sounded loads better. our 2nd guitarist just acts like he knows what he's doing (he doesn't) and we wanted to get something out so we just went with what we could work with. You should have heard the tracks right after they were "mastered" before I bitched about them, shittons of reverb on. EVERYTHING.[/quote]

thats y being in bands sucks

i think my friend might produce our full length.

I went to school with him and he was one of the 4 people in my audio class who actually gave a shit and the stuff he's been doing now is sounding pretty good

it still sounds better than carbonized gnawing mandible

speaking of which, you should get brent to "remaster" your demo

lol

[url]http://www.box.com/s/e87b714e194df267dae1/[/url]

got some good bass