[QUOTE=jangus]I love when people try to sound like they know a lot about Pink Floyd, and then spell Barrett wrong (and his mental complications were during and after Piper)
[/QUOTE]

Forgive me if i'm wrong, but isn't Piper at the Gates of Dawn Floyd's first cd like he said?

[quote]Actually, Gilmour can still sing amazingly well. Check out the DVD that came out recently. I think his sing has, if anything, improved. Also, Gilmour has said that part of the reason he doesn't want to do another tour is because it would involve making a new album.[/quote]
I agree. And he is still an amazing guitar player. Nick still can play drums, and has with Roger, and of course Roger can still play bass. I'm sure Nick still plays the piano sometimes as well.

[quote=]my big fear about bands like cream and pink floyd who have rumors of getting back together is they do get back together and put out a new cd and the cd is crap like so many bands that have reunions do.[/quote]

But that is true too. The album most likely wouldn't even compare with their past stuff. But the album isn't what I want to see, just a tour.

Sale wise

Gilmour's solo albums > Roger's albums

My preference

Gilmour's solo albums > Roger's(though I havent heard too much)

[QUOTE=Gilmour]Sale wise

Gilmour's solo albums > Roger's albums

My preference

Gilmour's solo albums > Roger's(though I havent heard too much)[/QUOTE]

pink floyd ALL TOGETHER>then any of their solo carrerrs put together. who cares who had the better solo carrer everybody knows that it. All comparing the individual artists solo carrers is cause annoying roger>gilmore roger<gilmore fights

[QUOTE=HempKnight]pink floyd ALL TOGETHER>then any of their solo carrerrs put together. who cares who had the better solo carrer everybody knows that it. All comparing the individual artists solo carrers is cause annoying roger>gilmore roger<gilmore fights[/QUOTE]

Obviously we care because we are discussing it. You are the one creating a fight right now, we are all just discussing it normally. I was just pointing out that Gilmour's albums had better sales, and that I prefer them. Now STFU.

I still think it's viable. They're not enemies anymore as far as I can tell. Maybe not friends, but not enemies is still a step up.

Is that Gilmour DVD that was released recently any good?

I saw the Comfortably Numb clip, and I liked it alot, but is the rest of the DVD good too?

YES! The Gilmour DVD > your children. Seriously. Buy it!

wow today i heard comfertbly numb off a decilet sound of thunder on the raido. that has got to be the best recordingof it ive heard.

[QUOTE=HempKnight]wow today i heard comfertbly numb off a decilet sound of thunder on the raido. that has got to be the best recordingof it ive heard.[/QUOTE]
Learn how to spell for christ sake.

well u know what means who care about the spelling so hows bout we talk about the music :thumb:

[QUOTE=HempKnight]well u know what means who care about the spelling so hows bout we talk about the music :thumb:[/QUOTE]
No it's not like that. I'm giving you fair warning ahead of time to take the time to spell out your words instead of speaking like a 5 year old. People will consistently flame you and -Rep you because you spell like that, And it's just pathetic grammar. It's all about the music bud, Just trying to give you a tip or two :)

o ok i read it wrong i guess, ill try to watch that in the future thanks :thumb:

You had better. I'm sure the members of Pink Floyd would be angry at you for spelling poorly in a thread about them.

[QUOTE=HempKnight]Wow! Today, on the radio, I heard Comfortably Numb (the version from Delicate Sound Of Thunder. I think that it has got to be the best recording of it I've heard to date.[/QUOTE]

Well, Gilmour's voice is a lot more melodic than Waters, hence the song is "easier" on the ears. However, I think it loses a bit of it's artistic value, id est the doctor's voice is least intrusive and unpleasant.

[QUOTE=HeavyRiva]Well, Gilmour's voice is a lot more melodic than Waters, hence the song is "easier" on the ears. However, I think it loses a bit of it's artistic value, id est the doctor's voice is least intrusive and unpleasant.[/QUOTE]

yea now that you mention it i remember thinking that

I love the versions on the DVD of Gilmour. People say they don't like the guest singers for some reason, I thought they were great. And yeah, HempKnight, it is all about the music, but typing decently is nice. Tyinpg leyk dis iz rly obniouxs.

omgz liek who lovs Punk Floud as mch as me!!!!!!eventyseven

I was wondering what people's favourite songs off PATGOD because I'm having a difficult time deciding although I believe its Instellar Overdrive.

[QUOTE=Livewired]I was wondering what people's favourite songs off PATGOD because I'm having a difficult time deciding although I believe its Instellar Overdrive.[/QUOTE]

I'd have to agree, maybe Astronomy Domine.

[QUOTE=lunch998]I'd have to agree, maybe Astronomy Domine.[/QUOTE]
Yeah I count the C.D. because I don't own the LP.

[QUOTE=lunch998]I'd have to agree, maybe Astronomy Domine.[/QUOTE]

i love Astronomy Domine, thats the song that got my into syds work in the first place.

[QUOTE=Livewired]Yeah I count the C.D. because I don't own the LP.[/QUOTE]

Nevermind that, I was thinking about something different. See Emily Play was on the original album, but not the Cd.

I got a question for everyone. What is your favorite Pink Floyd CD. I have heard a lot of their songs and I would like to purchace one but I don't know what one I would like. Any ideas?

Bike is my favorite just because the lyrics are so **** funny.

My favorite Floyd CD is probably Animals, but get DSOTM first.

[QUOTE=SofaKing713]I got a question for everyone. What is your favorite Pink Floyd CD. I have heard a lot of their songs and I would like to purchace one but I don't know what one I would like. Any ideas?[/QUOTE]

You have to start with Dark Side of the Moon. It is no longer my favorite(actually I like it much less now than most people do) but it will capture you once you first get it, and will bring you into Pink Floyd.

[QUOTE=lunch998]Nevermind that, I was thinking about something different. See Emily Play was on the original album, but not the Cd.[/QUOTE]
Yeah I thought it was on the original lp. Oh well.

[QUOTE=SofaKing713]I got a question for everyone. What is your favorite Pink Floyd CD. I have heard a lot of their songs and I would like to purchace one but I don't know what one I would like. Any ideas?[/QUOTE]

Definitely Dark Side of the Moon. Then probably Wish You Were Here.

Meddle is the best instrumentally and the wall has the best lyrics so its a tie in my mind

[QUOTE=SofaKing713]I got a question for everyone. What is your favorite Pink Floyd CD. I have heard a lot of their songs and I would like to purchace one but I don't know what one I would like. Any ideas?[/QUOTE]
My favorite CD would be Animals but as some one else said its best to start with Dark Side of The Moon.