They did it live.

Like, 2003.

Edit: Well I downloaded it, unfortunately I only have it one .mp3 too, so you have to fast forward to get to the songs, but I usually just put it on Battery and leave it. It's not the greatest quality, because it's live, but it's not so bad it's unlistennable.

They covered the whole freaking album? my aim is gocaps99

Yeah, the whole 57 minutes. I don't use AIM, sorry.
I'd have to upload it on YSI. (I know I said I'd do it tonight, but some people came around and we went out, so I have to do it tomorrow guys, sorry).

I had the whole thing saved in a RAR file, but I think I deleted it for room. It was really cool though. Keyboards sound kinda cool in the songs.

hey guys, new to the thread...
i think my peace for this thread is this:
i think metallica made good music (except St. Anger) , i respect them, but i do not like their music.

there.

Man, we should count how many of those posts we get^^

[QUOTE=fitzierocker]hey guys, new to the thread...
i think my peace for this thread is this:
i think metallica made good music (except St. Anger) , i respect them, but i do not like their music.

there.[/QUOTE]

Then why are you here? Come into the ***OFFICIAL*** metallica thread and say you dont like metallica how stupid is that. go away.
Geez i think thats like in the neighborhood of 100ish.

Often times new members think they should post in every thread, dispite there interests.

Worse yet he says "i think metallica made good music (except St. Anger)" and then goes on to controdict him self by saying " i respect them, but i do not like their music."
HIPOCRIT!!!!!!!

Where can you read the rules?

The R&M rules are stickied. R&M forum, sixth or seventh thread down, always there.

I can't wait to hear the Dream Theater version of Orion...

[QUOTE=lilmetallica]Worse yet he says "i think metallica made good music (except St. Anger)" and then goes on to controdict him self by saying " i respect them, but i do not like their music."
HIPOCRIT!!!!!!!

Where can you read the rules?[/QUOTE]

Here is a link to the rules page :thumb: [url]http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showthread.php?t=224003[/url]


[QUOTE=lilmetallica]I can't wait to hear the Dream Theater version of Orion..[/QUOTE]

I know same here, I have their version of Master of puppets, but i am led to believe the covered that entire album! Its good stuff I tell ya lol :thumb:

Dream Theater does a very good job playing all the songs, as they are all extremely talented. The only thing that was weak was the vocals. I wouldnt listen to it over Metallica.

John Petrucci is dam[SIZE=2]n[/SIZE] good.

did anybody else know that kirk used to be in exodus. he started the band then droped out before they released there first real album (bonded by blood) i just saw this information. im really just getting into exodus so this may be well known. idk.

[QUOTE=whatduffhuck7]did anybody else know that kirk used to be in exodus. he started the band then droped out before they released there first real album (bonded by blood) i just saw this information. im really just getting into exodus so this may be well known. idk.[/QUOTE]

Every1 that comes in here regularly knows this.

Exodus isnt that good anyways. I saw them live.

[QUOTE=LarsAgi007]Here is a link to the rules page :thumb: [url]http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showthread.php?t=224003[/url]




I know same here, I have their version of Master of puppets, but i am led to believe the covered that entire album! Its good stuff I tell ya lol :thumb:[/QUOTE]
Yeah, I'll upload it to YSI for you guys later.
Everything about it kicks ***, and yes while the vocals do lack in some stages, the almost perfect control of their instruments more then make up for it. Portnoy plays Disposable Heroes with perfect accuracy, never missing a beat. (And it's a little bit faster then Metallica).

Have you guys heard the Pantera cover of Seek & Destroy?

No, is it good?

[QUOTE=RustedPieces]Have you guys heard the Pantera cover of Seek & Destroy?[/QUOTE]

I haven't either. I think an upload is in order :rolleyes:

Agreed. Upload, or feel our wrath!!!

/kidding

/or am I?

I have heaps of mp3s.
The Pantera Seek & Destroy has Jason on bass too :o
I also have a few different version of Battery (Covers) one's titled by Flotsam & Jetsam (Dunno if they ever covered it?), with a heaps funk sounding over the top bass.

[QUOTE=Chu]I have heaps of mp3s.
The Pantera Seek & Destroy has Jason on bass too :o
I also have a few different version of Battery (Covers) one's titled by Flotsam & Jetsam (Dunno if they ever covered it?), with a heaps funk sounding over the top bass.[/QUOTE]

all I got is demos of early metallica :upset:
and they're cds of course...but nothing rare

[QUOTE=Chu]I have heaps of mp3s.
The Pantera Seek & Destroy has Jason on bass too :o
I also have a few different version of Battery (Covers) one's titled by Flotsam & Jetsam (Dunno if they ever covered it?), with a heaps funk sounding over the top bass.[/QUOTE]
Pantera covered it more than once...as well as Whiplash.

I have the video of the PanTallica thing btw...

[QUOTE=LarsAgi007]Here is a link to the rules page :thumb: [url]http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showthread.php?t=224003[/url]




I know same here, I have their version of Master of puppets, but i am led to believe the covered that entire album! Its good stuff I tell ya lol :thumb:[/QUOTE]
They did a concert called: 'Master of Metallica' where they covered all of 'Puppets.

The cover of Orion is weak by the way.

[QUOTE=Fernandes Power]The cover of Orion is weak by the way.[/QUOTE]
I didn't think so.

[QUOTE=Chu]I didn't think so.[/QUOTE]
Really??

I think most of its pretty bad... the Battery ones ok, MoP is well played but makes me giggle cuz of Jordan and James, Sanitariums really good apart from the vocals (seriously James... stop), Thingy wasnt bad, Disposable Heroes was ok but I remember something I didnt like about it... Leper Messiah I havent heard, Orion just felt weak on the whole... I dont think John did a great job of it and Damage Inc. was good... but fails to compare to any version of Metallica playing it.

[QUOTE=RustedPieces]Exodus isnt that good anyways. I saw them live.[/QUOTE]


Yea they really arnt.


Its very boring thrash metal imo.

I thought all around DT owned Metallica, well maybe the only thing I didn't like was the lack of bass in Leper Messiah, that was partly because of the live recording I guess though, and obviously James' vocals.

I really liked Disposable Heroes though, Portnoy was amazing.

What did you think of the little jizz after Orion? (Assuming you have heard the same version as me).

[QUOTE=Chu]I thought all around DT owned Metallica, well maybe the only thing I didn't like was the lack of bass in Leper Messiah, that was partly because of the live recording I guess though, and obviously James' vocals.

I really liked Disposable Heroes though, Portnoy was amazing.

What did you think of the little jizz after Orion? (Assuming you have heard the same version as me).[/QUOTE]
I cant remember little details like that... I only watched a video of it once, that was on my old computer.

Theres no-way Dream Theater could own Metallica playing Metallicas own material... seriously. You sound like a fanboy by saying that. :p

[QUOTE=Fernandes Power]I cant remember little details like that... I only watched a video of it once, that was on my old computer.

Theres no-way Dream Theater could own Metallica playing Metallicas own material... seriously. You sound like a fanboy by saying that. :p[/QUOTE]
Maybe I am, but in a way I do prefer Metallica's writing ability, I just think DT can play the songs better. I have two videos, one of Master of Puppets, and the other of Sanitarium, and I think Petrucci really plays them well. (And an mp3 of the whole album (57 Minutes, 80mb)).

Hey wat sup with metallica these days?

[QUOTE=Chu]Maybe I am, but in a way I do prefer Metallica's writing ability, I just think DT can play the songs better. I have two videos, one of Master of Puppets, and the other of Sanitarium, and I think Petrucci really plays them well. (And an mp3 of the whole album (57 Minutes, 80mb)).[/QUOTE]
Ok, but what I am saying is that Dream Theater cant play them better... this would be impossible, but rather that they play them in a style you prefer more.

[QUOTE=BCDRUMMER121]Hey wat sup with metallica these days?[/QUOTE]
Theyre taking some time out currently... but will be in the studio very soon, Im sure.

My guess is for a new album mid-2006.

[QUOTE=Chu]Maybe I am, but in a way I do prefer Metallica's writing ability, I just think DT can play the songs better. I have two videos, one of Master of Puppets, and the other of Sanitarium, and I think Petrucci really plays them well. (And an mp3 of the whole album (57 Minutes, 80mb)).[/QUOTE]

Thats not possible to play a song better than the original writer, if u are playing it the way that they wrote it. The best is the way that they made it. Plus James H's vocals pwn James L's.

[QUOTE=R. Blythe]Thats not possible to play a song better than the original writer, if u are playing it the way that they wrote it. The best is the way that they made it. Plus James H's vocals pwn James L's.[/QUOTE]
Exactly.

[QUOTE=RustedPieces]Have you guys heard the Pantera cover of Seek & Destroy?[/QUOTE]
i have

so i read in the paper that metallica did a small show for a nightclub,this means they are still together!!just wondering when the new album is comin out...

[QUOTE=willis2441]so i read in the paper that metallica did a small show for a nightclub,this means they are still together!!just wondering when the new album is comin out...[/QUOTE]
Oh wow... *dies*.

Are you posting from 2 years ago? :rolleyes:

[quote=Chu]I thought all around DT owned Metallica[/quote]
Like I already said, it's my ****en opinion they played it better.
Next time read the ****en post thoroughly before you ****en reply, k?