[QUOTE=HomeCatMickey8]Sunny Day Real Estate- Diary
Mineral- The Power of Falling
Bright Eyes- Lifted (Keep Your Ear to the Ground, the Story's in the Soil.)[/QUOTE]
hell yes

[QUOTE=CommieCanada]hell yes[/QUOTE]

Well I saw your post and I was like "wow, I think I like this dude". But I would've included those either way. I mean com'mon, whoever doesn't give Diary a 100% should be taken out to the back and smacked around a bit.

[QUOTE=HomeCatMickey8]Pop Punk:
Thursday-Full Collapse... can't beleive only one other person thinks so
[/QUOTE]

No kidding it's probably one of the greatest albums that have ever graced my ears.

[QUOTE=HomeCatMickey8]Well I saw your post and I was like "wow, I think I like this dude". But I would've included those either way. I mean com'mon, whoever doesn't give Diary a 100% should be taken out to the back and smacked around a bit.[/QUOTE]
no kidding, its the second best album ever recorded imo, just behind The Cure's Bloodflowers

[QUOTE=Society Sellout]No kidding it's probably one of the greatest albums that have ever graced my ears.[/QUOTE]

It's like a crack binge on a piece of plastic... that's how good it is.

[QUOTE=HomeCatMickey8]It's like a crack binge on a piece of plastic... that's how good it is.[/QUOTE]
darn right. The rest of their albums are good too but don't get any respect around here

[QUOTE=CommieCanada]darn right. The rest of their albums are good too but don't get any respect around here[/QUOTE]
I love all their albums. [I]I gave War All The Time[/I] a 10/10 in this thread.

I don't know if WATT gets a 10, but at least a 9.5 + some mad props... esspecially for "Falling Bomb", because an all piano song, which is something new for them on an LP, and it's really pretty. "For The Workforce, Drowning" was amazing, and probably one of my top 10 songs. So many good songs, that now I'm thinking it might deserve a 10/10, which is amazing that a band can throw out two perfect albums consectivily... Let's hope for three, whenever it's coming out.

Their new demos are quite amazing too I can't wait for their new album.

WATT doesn't quite get a 10 for me some it wasn't quite as powerful to me as FC was.

Sum 41 - Chuck
Blink 182 - Blink 182
The All-American Rejects - The All-American Rejects
Bowling for Soup - Drunk Enough To Dance

those are my favorite "whole albums" to just sit down and listen to

Green Day - American Idiot

OMGZ!1111!1EleVEn!!1!
i'MUsT be a aSELLOuT Sk8r KiDDD4 thinkING itSa GOod ALbuM oMGZ!!1!1!1!!2PWNME

Alot of the albums posted aren't even pop-punk.

Lifetime - Jersey's Best Dancers
Taking Back Sunday - Tell All Your Friends
The Starting Line - Say It Like You Mean It
The Ataris - So Long Astoria
Sum 41 - All Killer, No Filler
The Adicts - The Sound Of Music

[QUOTE=RetiredAt21]Alot of the albums posted aren't even pop-punk.

Lifetime - Jersey's Best Dancers
Taking Back Sunday - Tell All Your Friends
The Starting Line - Say It Like You Mean It
The Ataris - So Long Astoria
Sum 41 - All Killer, No Filler
The Adicts - The Sound Of Music[/QUOTE]
Are you saying you'd give those albums 10/10, or are you saying they're not pop-punk?

Because either way, "So Long, Astoria" was the worst Ataris album ever.

Reading over this thread, I never realised how close Pop-Punk and Indie Pop are.


I haven't heard a 10/10 pop-punk album to date. A few good ones, nothing mind-blowing. Maybe it's because I'm not that emotionally vested in the genre, I don't know.

[I]Diary [/I]is like a 6/10.

1,039 Smoothed out Slappy Hours
Deja Entendu
Take this to your grave

[QUOTE=Dreww]Green Day - American Idiot

OMGZ!1111!1EleVEn!!1!
i'MUsT be a aSELLOuT Sk8r KiDDD4 thinkING itSa GOod ALbuM oMGZ!!1!1!1!!2PWNME[/QUOTE]

hahahaha :lol:

Your an idiot.

[QUOTE=Dreww]Green Day - American Idiot

OMGZ!1111!1EleVEn!!1!
i'MUsT be a aSELLOuT Sk8r KiDDD4 thinkING itSa GOod ALbuM oMGZ!!1!1!1!!2PWNME[/QUOTE]
That album blows. Hard.

And you're little n00b writing isn't even remotely funny.

Thrice and Underoath are definately not pop punk. Thrice is Hardcore, and Underoath, considering what i've heard about them, seems like a harcore band too

^^ That's nice.

ha, i thought i was posting on page 1... Forgot there are usually other pages.

Why are people saying FC is better than War All The Time? FC was the album with the annoying vocals in it, WATT was way better.

Thursday aren't pop punk either!

[QUOTE=TheRedDeath19]ha, i thought i was posting on page 1... Forgot there are usually other pages.

Why are people saying FC is better than War All The Time? FC was the album with the annoying vocals in it, WATT was way better.

Thursday aren't pop punk either![/QUOTE]
No one cares that they aren't pop-punk.

And FC was, in many aspects, better than WATT. That seems to be the general consensus anyways.

Only slightly better, but still better.

[QUOTE=hey, you're not cory!]Only slightly better, but still better.[/QUOTE]
That's how I feel. There are a couple songs that put it ahead for me. If those 2 songs weren't on it I think they'd be level.

Are you kidding? [I]Full Collapse[/I] is miles better than [I]War All The Time[/I].

Bah, ur ghey.

haha this thread got hijacked by thursday!

Green Day - Dookie
The Starting Line - Say It Like You Mean It
The Ataris - End Is Forever
Saves The Day - Stay What You Are
Motion City Soundtrack - I Am The Movie

[I]Not Pop-Punk But Damn Good[/I]
Senses Fail - Let It Enfold You(Yes I like it better than the EP)
Thrice - The Artist In The Ambulance

[QUOTE=PostHardcore6859]
[I]Not Pop-Punk But Damn Good[/I]
Senses Fail - Let It Enfold You(Yes I like it better than the EP)
[/QUOTE]

How is Senses Fail anything but pop-punk. I can understand about Thrice because they are mostly hardcore but Senses Fail is straight up pop punk with a touch of screaming.

[QUOTE=cbmartinez][I]Diary [/I]is like a 6/10.[/QUOTE]

UHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!??!!!!!!!!!!!

the vandals-live fast dirrhea
the ramones-rocket to russia
bad religion-no control

[QUOTE=morrissey]Reading over this thread, I never realised how close Pop-Punk and Indie Pop are.
[/QUOTE]


dont let the indie crowd hear that

[QUOTE=wwjd388]wow Deja Entendu is pretty good huh? i have had your favorite weapon for a long time but i never picked that one up... mabey i should...[/QUOTE]

how do you sleep at night.


brand new-deja entendu.

[QUOTE=hey, you're not cory!]That album blows. Hard.

And you're little n00b writing isn't even remotely funny.[/QUOTE]
I dont think it was supposed to be funny. Stop thinking youre better than him. :)

[QUOTE=Mr Clean]I dont think it was supposed to be funny. Stop thinking youre better than him. :)[/QUOTE]

So, you think that the kid wasn't being overly sarcastic in an attempt to get a laugh by adding several useless forms of punctuation and spelling like a retard?

No, he was trying to be funny. And he failed. Accept it.

saves the day - say what you are
TSL - say it like you mean it.

these may not be my favourite CD's, but when i listen to them i can't think of anything bad about them, and i would add anything to them.

Saves The Day - Through Being Cool
Lifetime - Jersey's Best Dancers

I've been listening to Bayside recently, (mainly in respect) and I think Sirens and Condolences is worthy for a 10/10.

[QUOTE=Inaudible]I've been listening to Bayside recently, (mainly in respect) and I think Sirens and Condolences is worthy for a 10/10.[/QUOTE]

:thumb: good man, i second sirens and condolences, also
Bigwig: Invitation to tradegy
Saves the Day-Through being cool

and for the thrice and underoath goons, id put thrice as pop-punk/post hardcore and for underoath, well...i havent heard their newer stuff but from what i hear its really pop-punk

Hopesfall - [I]The Sattelite Years[/I]

I'm listening to it now and it's reminded me how awesome this album really is.