[QUOTE=PepsiMetal]I have like 15 of their live performances. I have all of those mp3 songs as well, and trust me, they sound pretty much the same. Plus his timing is almost always good.[/QUOTE]
The ending solo in Fade To Black from Cunning Stunts. Tell me Kirk plays that perfectly...

[QUOTE=Chu]The ending solo in Fade To Black from Cunning Stunts. Tell me Kirk plays that perfectly...[/QUOTE]

I really don't like cunning stunts, there doesnt seem to be much energy put into it.

how unfortunate. Having never seen the dvd that is about all i can say.

I thought it was good, but then i watched the live s[I][U][/U][/I]hit DVDs and it just seemed...crap!

Cunning Stunts is an awesome dvd...one of my favs of all time

and pepsi if Harvester of Sorrow will ever upload from yousendit i'll post it on here. The last part he plays in the solo is ****

[QUOTE=leppermessiah]how unfortunate. Having never seen the dvd that is about all i can say.[/QUOTE]
Heh, same here

i think it'd be cool if they made like a Garage Inc. 2. Like covers that range from Pantera to like Shadows Fall or something

i could only stand the 2nd disk of garage inc. it's electric and merciful fate where cool on the 1st disk though.

[QUOTE=\m/Pete\m/]i think it'd be cool if they made like a Garage Inc. 2. Like covers that range from Pantera to like Shadows Fall or something[/QUOTE]
Yeah, that would be pretty cool. I would prefer them to create an original album though

^^ true

[url]http://s36.yousendit.com/d.aspx?id=3DS6OYL6T4W5J3NMCCNXB1BCQ7[/url]

Heres Harvester of Sorrow live

edit: **** my bad guys that was a BIG upload...it wont be too bad if you got dsl

[QUOTE=wrongnote85]i could only stand the 2nd disk of garage inc. it's electric and merciful fate where cool on the 1st disk though.[/QUOTE]

I think Metallica made all of those songs better imo...except maybe Tuesdays Gone

but Astronomy and Turn the Page...much better than the originals

I don't think Sabbra Caddabra was as good as the original

[QUOTE=Chu]The ending solo in Fade To Black from Cunning Stunts. Tell me Kirk plays that perfectly...[/QUOTE]

Im not saying he plays every solo on every concert perfectly. Im saying most of it is perfect. There isn't any guitarist that plays every solo every time perfect. We're all human. :thumb:

i dunno...that is one of my favorite songs off of GI

I like both versions, but i do like how much more upbeat 'Tally's is


Edit: to pepsi..i think Petrucci plays most of his 100% accurate note for note of the time, but then again he is amazing. Oh and did you download that song?

The Mercyful Fate originals> Metallica's efforts.

[QUOTE=\m/Pete\m/]I think Metallica made all of those songs better imo...except maybe Tuesdays Gone

but Astronomy and Turn the Page...much better than the originals[/QUOTE]
Tuesdays gone just did not suit Metallica

Not a big King Diamond fan (vocal wise)

**** im postin the hell outta this thread right now, but anyways i think that Fuel has one of Metallica's best solo's imo

[QUOTE=\m/Pete\m/]Not a big King Diamond fan (vocal wise)

**** im postin the hell outta this thread right now, but anyways i think that Fuel has one of Metallica's best solo's imo[/QUOTE]
Yep. A very good song all around IMO

I think Kirk is a great guitarist, he lights up the ****en stage during every song in concert. Btw, Lars, James, and Kirk can all write plenty good music, you don't last 20+ years as one of the best metal bands out there, to finally being the best band EVER (imo as i have expressed before...), without having 3/4 or all four members writing good music. Between James and Lars, I never even knew that James soloed in any song, thats new to me. I'd like to see a new thrash album come out from them, with musicianship like Black Album, but faster. Only now, how about both of them solo at the same time? Some might say it'll sound sloppy, but how cool would it be to hear nothing but two guitarists just giving it all they got as a goodbye present to their fans?

[QUOTE=hatchedinalab89]I think Kirk is a great guitarist, he lights up the ****en stage during every song in concert. Btw, Lars, James, and Kirk can all write plenty good music, you don't last 20+ years as one of the best metal bands out there, to finally being the best band EVER (imo as i have expressed before...), without having 3/4 or all four members writing good music. Between James and Lars, I never even knew that James soloed in any song, thats new to me. I'd like to see a new thrash album come out from them, with musicianship like Black Album, but faster. [B]Only now, how about both of them solo at the same time? Some might say it'll sound sloppy, but how cool would it be to hear nothing but two guitarists just giving it all they got as a goodbye present to their fans?[/B][/QUOTE]

When they played One when i saw them both james and kirk played that little solo after the main one kirk does...sounded excellent

[QUOTE=\m/Pete\m/]Edit: to pepsi..i think Petrucci plays most of his 100% accurate note for note of the time, but then again he is amazing. Oh and did you download that song?[/QUOTE]

Petrucci is great but I doubt he always plays perfect. And yes I downloaded the song and first thing that came to my mind was why is an audio file 60 MB? lol :lol:

That performance was ok, I dont like harvester of sorrow much though.

i just wanted to bring up something that bugged me that i read. Malmsteem was commenting about Vibratos and said that Kirk has the worst vibrato hes ever heard. He said it was because he has perfect pitch, but i dont hear anything wrong with them at all (well except maybe for KeA, Kirk even said that himself)

Does anybody else think that too?

[QUOTE=PepsiMetal]Petrucci is great but I doubt he always plays perfect. And yes I downloaded the song and first thing that came to my mind was why is an audio file 60 MB? lol :lol:

That performance was ok, I dont like harvester of sorrow much though.[/QUOTE]

yeah i was like "why the hell is this taken so long?" then i looked and it was HUGE! Meh, to each their own, but the main thing i was gettin at was the improvision in the solo...you caught that right?

[QUOTE=\m/Pete\m/]i just wanted to bring up something that bugged me that i read. Malmsteem was commenting about Vibratos and said that Kirk has the worst vibrato hes ever heard. He said it was because he has perfect pitch, but i dont hear anything wrong with them at all (well except maybe for KeA, Kirk even said that himself)

Does anybody else think that too?[/QUOTE]
Malmsteem is all about his ego. He thinks he is the best player alive, and feels he has the right to criticize every other player on the planet.
Ignore him.

Stupid question but who is Malmsteen?

[QUOTE=MXican]Stupid question but who is Malmsteen?[/QUOTE]
Yngwie Malmsteem.
Formerly overwieght neo-classical shred guitarist.
Dominates the Melodic + harmonic minor.
Think Paganini on guitar.
With a horrible, horrible tone.
Has a massive ego.

Yngwie's got a great vibrato though.... :upset:

I dont know why he thinks he soo good, Satch could own him any day

[QUOTE=munky_magik]Yngwie Malmsteem.
Formerly overwieght neo-classical shred guitarist.
Domintae the Melodic + harmonic minor.
Think Paganini on guitar.
With a horrible, horrible tone.
Has a massive ego.[/QUOTE]
Oh yeah, thanks. My mind kinda went blank.

[QUOTE=\m/Pete\m/]yeah i was like "why the hell is this taken so long?" then i looked and it was HUGE! Meh, to each their own, but the main thing i was gettin at was the improvision in the solo...you caught that right?[/QUOTE]

Uh, I didn't notice it the first time, but I know what you mean now.

[QUOTE=hatchedinalab89]I think Kirk is a great guitarist, he lights up the ****en stage during every song in concert. Btw, Lars, James, and Kirk can all write plenty good music, you don't last 20+ years as one of the best metal bands out there, to finally being the best band EVER (imo as i have expressed before...), without having 3/4 or all four members writing good music. Between James and Lars, I never even knew that James soloed in any song, thats new to me. I'd like to see a new thrash album come out from them, with musicianship like Black Album, but faster. Only now, how about both of them solo at the same time? Some might say it'll sound sloppy, but how cool would it be to hear nothing but two guitarists just giving it all they got as a goodbye present to their fans?[/QUOTE]

A goodbye present?
Did I miss something?

[QUOTE=AimlessDave]A goodbye present?
Did I miss something?[/QUOTE]

I think he's going to put a hit out on Metallica.

/Is confused

[QUOTE=hatchedinalab89]I think Kirk is a great guitarist, he lights up the ****en stage during every song in concert. Btw, Lars, James, and Kirk can all write plenty good music, you don't last 20+ years as one of the best metal bands out there, to finally being the best band EVER (imo as i have expressed before...), without having 3/4 or all four members writing good music. Between James and Lars, I never even knew that James soloed in any song, thats new to me. I'd like to see a new thrash album come out from them, with musicianship like [B]Black Album, but faster[/B]. Only now, how about both of them solo at the same time? Some might say it'll sound sloppy, but how cool would it be to hear nothing but two guitarists just giving it all they got as a goodbye present to their fans?[/QUOTE]

......like the first four albums......

\m/Pete\m/
------------

Dude, Yngwie can tear Satch into pieces. He's a big ego, and most of his stuff sounds alike but as a guitar player (not composer) he's far better than Joe.

[QUOTE=btoto]\m/Pete\m/
------------

Dude, Yngwie can tear Satch into pieces. He's a big ego, and most of his stuff sounds alike but as a guitar player (not composer) he's far better than Joe.[/QUOTE]
Yngwie is perhaps a better shredder than Satch. I say perhaps because We don't know the full extent of either of their abilities.

[size=1]I don't know if you knew this, but if you hit the reply button in the bottom right corner of someones post then it quotes the person's message like this[/size]

[QUOTE=hatchedinalab89]I think Kirk is a great guitarist, he lights up the ****en stage during every song in concert. Btw, Lars, James, and Kirk can all write plenty good music, you don't last 20+ years as one of the best metal bands out there, to finally being the best band EVER (imo as i have expressed before...), without having 3/4 or all four members writing good music. Between James and Lars, I never even knew that James soloed in any song, thats new to me. I'd like to see a new thrash album come out from them, with musicianship like Black Album, but faster. Only now, how about both of them solo at the same time? Some might say it'll sound sloppy, but how cool would it be to hear nothing but two guitarists just giving it all they got as a goodbye present to their fans?[/QUOTE]

I agree with you completely (no IMO, it's more than us). Kirk is an amazing guitarist. They all actually write great music. St. Anger didn't disappoint me because of the lyrics or the riffs, it's that Lars thought solos weren't trendy.

I'd like this album to be better than the Black Album. I want it to have fast songs with awesome lyrics and cool solos. I can't wait until it's released.

Metallica isn't retiring anytime soon, unless you've heard otherwise. They will probably go on tour in a year or two after the release of the new album.

[QUOTE=gocaps99] I'd like this album to be better than the Black Album. I want it to have fast songs with awesome lyrics and cool solos. I can't wait until it's released.
[/QUOTE]
It would be rather hard to top the Black Album, because it is the album that Metallica is known for, thanks to Enter Sandman.

[QUOTE]It would be rather hard to top the Black Album, because it is the album that Metallica is known for, thanks to Enter Sandman.[/QUOTE]

i never said it had to be more [I]popular[/I] than the black album, i said i want it to be better (from a true fan standpoint)

[QUOTE=gocaps99]i never said it had to be more [I]popular[/I] than the black album, i said i want it to be better (from a true fan standpoint)[/QUOTE]
what exactly is a "true fan standpoint"?