lots o f u lol

Mike and I consistently talk about good bands. Other posters not so much. Fatal Energy doesn't mention lame stuff, either.

haha, at least its still active

We try to keep the level of noobery as low as possible.

All Carcass is good, people are dumb

[QUOTE=Anglachel;17876783]All Carcass is good, people are dumb[/QUOTE]

No you're dumb because Heartwork and Swansong are both pretty weak. Heartwork isn't [I]awful[/I] but they sold out hard and aping melodeath stuff is retarded.

I didn't know there was a folk-punk band named Carcass

Folk-punk exploded then promptly imploded and no one cares anymore. 'Cept for Anglachel lol.

Heartwork >>>>>>>>>>>> Swansong

but those two are definitely the weakest.

Heartworks good Swansongs fun you just dont like melodeath do you

I don't hate melodeath but going from an awesome grind band to a sellout melodeath band is lame as ****.

hating on bands for selling out is pretty hipster

How did they sell out?

[QUOTE=Anglachel;17876805]hating on bands for selling out is pretty hipster[/QUOTE]

Drat! It was only a matter of time 'till you whipped out the hipster card and my argument completely fell apart!

[QUOTE=Txus;17876811]How did they sell out?[/QUOTE]

...

They went from a brutal grindcore band to a relatively accessible (almost radio-friendly) melodic death metal band. Come on, bro.

Cmon man

I don't care at all what direction a band took with their music if I still enjoy it I still enjoy it

Heartwork was a good album
Swansong is fun. Its not as good as Heartwork and I'm not saying Heartwork rules or anything but like

'Radio friendly' != bad

Never said you can't enjoy them but they definitely sold out.

That's not selling out to me though. That's just a progression, it's like saying Ulver sold out because they went from Black/Folk metal to Electronica/Experimental music.

[QUOTE=Txus;17876830]That's not selling out to me though. That's just a progression, it's like saying Ulver sold out because they went from Black/Folk metal to Electronica/Experimental music.[/QUOTE]

Perhaps, but the timing of their "progression" was pretty convenient.

EDIT: regarding Carcass

hey

dont let me take that fallacy and turn this thread into PNWI

At least they made decent melodeath. But yeah, I mostly listen to their Grind stuff.

[QUOTE=Anglachel;17876851]hey

dont let me take that fallacy and turn this thread into PNWI[/QUOTE]

What fallacy?

radio friendly
therefore
bad music

Never said bad, I said weak, there is a difference.

oh god damnit

my apologies good sir

Yeah stick to pop-punk bro.

anglachel you consdervative bitch

i bet you're one of those kids that watches discovery channel all day

I like discovery channel when they play stuff that is actually interesting.

I like History channel, gangland is the love of my life

i dont watch tv or listen to a lot of pop-punk god damnit

plus then my comment on "all carcass is good" still stands