It's two kits put together. He plays different kits for different songs.

Mike Portnoy's old style might go a bit better with Akerfeldt and Wilson but I'd prefer a more jazz/hip-hop influenced drummer. I think Abe from Deftones would do well with those two.

That would be interesting Moses.

Or even better, Danny Carey.

I can't stop whoring Danny Carey, I love his drumming style too much. :(

I think Portnoy would be versitile enough to pull it off, tbh. He's not going to be showing off any overly complex beats and such, if he does it wouldn't even fit the music, and Steve and Mikael would be like... wtf, get out.

It'd be like a Flea in the Mars Volta type situation, his basslines on De-Loused bare no resemblance to anything he's done with the Chilli's, and it works really well.

On the opposite spectrum, this owns for me.

Mikael = Favorite singer/maybe guitarist
Portnoy = Favorite drummer
Wilson = Great producer

[QUOTE=Moses]Mike Portnoy's old style might go a bit better with Akerfeldt and Wilson but I'd prefer a more jazz/hip-hop influenced drummer. I think Abe from Deftones would do well with those two.[/QUOTE]


Man he's soo underated. :chug:

EDIT: Referring to Abe.

Thomas Haarke ftw.

Kick up the ol' technicality meter.

[QUOTE=Eleventeen]Portnoy's a good drummer, he's just so damn overrated.[/QUOTE]
I'll drink to that. :chug:

I'd rather have them use Bobby Jarzombek or Gene Hoglan.

[QUOTE=Jude]?

As for Portnoy, I've barely ever listened to Dream Theater so I know nothing about what kind of drummer he is. I've just heard he's good. But the point is, Wilson + Akerfeldt = fu[size=2]ck[/size]-mazing[/QUOTE]
Good god meaning, I want to hear them.

[QUOTE=Jude]?

As for Portnoy, I've barely ever listened to Dream Theater so I know nothing about what kind of drummer he is. I've just heard he's good. But the point is, Wilson + Akerfeldt = fu[size=2]ck[/size]-mazing[/QUOTE]
Well since you're not really acquainted with Portnoy, here's a rather famous video of him just so you can understand how good he really is.

[url]http://drummerworld.com/Videos/mikeportnoysolo.html[/url]
/laughs at his stupid facial expressions.

[QUOTE=Moses]Or even better, Danny Carey.[/QUOTE]

Definitly:thumb:

[QUOTE=Thor]Well since you're not really acquainted with Portnoy, here's a rather famous video of him just so you can understand how good he really is.

[url]http://drummerworld.com/Videos/mikeportnoysolo.html[/url]
/laughs at his stupid facial expressions.[/QUOTE]

/laughs as well.

I cant see the 3 of them playing together.

I can easily see Wilson and Akerfeldt playing, seeing as how they already have in past Opeth albums, but I can agree with not seeing Portnoy not playing with them. They seem more like a group that would have Danny Carey or someone along the lines of that.

Mikael seems to be good friends with Portnoy though. He doesn't even know Danny Carey. Mikael even thanks Portnoy and Dream Theater in the booklet to Ghost Reveries. And it's not like Portnoy wouldn't know what he's doing with them, he's a farily technical, prog rock/metal drummer, I'm sure whatever he does with Mikael and Wilson will be great.

Oh, I was unaware of the Ghost Reveries shoutout. That changes my opinion on things. If they do actually record an album together I'll surely be getting it as soon as it is released.

[QUOTE=Shadius]I think Portnoy would be versitile enough to pull it off, tbh. He's not going to be showing off any overly complex beats and such, if he does it wouldn't even fit the music, and Steve and Mikael would be like... wtf, get out.
[/QUOTE]

Portnoy isn't versatile though.. He's got no groove and sense of dynamics, Lopez and Gavin Harrison (PT's drummer) is in a completely different league to Portnoy

I'm going to have to disagree with you on that. While I can't stand Dream Theater as a band, I have the utmost respect for their abilities. Portnoy is capable of doing many different things on a drumset and is at a higher level than Lopez is.

Portnoys a fine drummer Knifeboy. Listen to the Awake album, he's got enough groove and dynamics to be able to work with Mike and Steve.

This is a hopeless dream, but I'd love to hear Bobby Jarzombek play with them instead of Portnoy. That would be a musical orgasm at it's finest.

I've heard all of DT's catalogue, and I'd say that Mike Portnoy wouldn't be able to write anything like the drumparts for Windowpane or PT's The creator has a mastertape....

He's got enough skill and plenty of time to come up with new ideas so I think he would be able to. I think you're underestimating Portnoy's potential.

I'd love it for him to prove me wrong......

[QUOTE=Flower Dance]Why do you think that?

Not being rude or anything.[/QUOTE]

Because he's a terrible drummer. His feel is completely flat, very robotic touch...I don't think I've ever heard him groove. He's been reusing the same goddam licks since Awake, and about the only thing that seems to change about him is the size of his kit. Steven would be better off just dragging Gavin Harrison with him, as he is 100x the musician that Portnoy will ever be.

[QUOTE=Thor]This is a hopeless dream, but I'd love to hear Bobby Jarzombek play with them instead of Portnoy. That would be a musical orgasm at it's finest.[/QUOTE]

Jarzombek would be a decent choice. Sean Reinert would be awesome as well.
[QUOTE=Knifeboy]PT's The creator has a mastertape....[/QUOTE]

Honestly, he doesn't even have the chops for that. Some of the licks that Gavin pulls in that song are just sick.

If push came to shove and Portnoy ended up having to cover the song, I would put money on the fact that he would replace every fill Gavin played with hand/foot trades. :lol:

woah triple post :p

Don't worry, I'm cleaning it up.

Wow, Reinert would be really good.

^^ Yeah...now THAT is a well-rounded musician.

[QUOTE=JamJar]Reflection, Ticks And Leeches, Lateralus, The Grudge and Aenima are proabably some of his best work.[/QUOTE]

You forgot 46&2. :)

[QUOTE=Deth]Wow, Reinert would be really good.[/QUOTE]
I've only heard his work with Death, and it was pretty awesome. He probably would do well with them.

Yeah, Portnoy has a ton of groove and feel. I don't get the whole OMGHEJUSTPLAYSTECHNICALSTUFFFAST.

Well, groove is a hard thing for some people to grasp.

[QUOTE=Dunkelheit509]I've only heard his work with Death, and it was pretty awesome. He probably would do well with them.[/QUOTE]

Oh, man...that's barely a taste of what he can do. Check out Aghora's self titled album - incredible work there. Cynic - Focus was the classic album that really introduced him to the scene, and his work with Gordian Knot is fantastic.

Yeah, I've heard a few Cynic tracks (thanks to Flynn), and they were pretty decent to.

Hey, I tried this a few months ago and got like 2 responses before I was drowned out in the usual "official thread" mindless banter, but here goes...

I recently got my copy of Lamentations signed by Opeth at Scrape Records in Vancouver. It's super cool, but I can't tell whos signature is whos! Does anyone else have anything signed by Opeth that they can compare this to to help me out? Can anyone identify these scribbles?

[IMG]http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v640/stefanreindl/c2417ecb.jpg[/IMG]

I'm pretty sure the bottom right is Per Wiberg, but beyond that I'm lost!

Mikaels is the one right next to Pers, thats the only one I can pull from memory. I'll to take a look at my signed stuff closly...

I cant identify any of them. I dont have any signed stuff to analyze it either:(

Is there any Opeth fans from Sydney here?I was just wondering if they are going to be doing any in-store signing at Utopia Records?

[QUOTE=Knifeboy]I've heard all of DT's catalogue, and I'd say that Mike Portnoy wouldn't be able to write anything like the drumparts for Windowpane or PT's The creator has a mastertape....[/QUOTE]

The drum parts to Porcupine Tree never really stood out to me. The guy has good groove, definately, I always feel like he should change the beats up a bit more, add some simple, tasteful fills in more often, to be honest. He's a *very* solid drummer with good groove, but Portnoy... Man, if Flea can drop his happy slapping and popping and create some tasteful interesting basslines than Portnoy can tone down while still keeping things interesting.

You know, I'm not saying there arn't better drummers, but I think Portnoy would be a decent choice. Personally I think Lopez would be better because I love his style, or Danny Carey, but he's more unlikely. I think it would be more interesting to see what Portnoy can do in the situation than PT's drummer...seeing as we know what he can do with Steve anyway.

[QUOTE=Shadius]The drum parts to Porcupine Tree never really stood out to me. The guy has good groove, definately, I always feel like he should change the beats up a bit more, add some simple, tasteful fills in more often, to be honest. He's a *very* solid drummer with good groove, but Portnoy... Man, if Flea can drop his happy slapping and popping and create some tasteful interesting basslines than Portnoy can tone down while still keeping things interesting.[/QUOTE]

As Det mentioned on the previous page.. Gavin Harrisons drumming is far from "toned down" compared to Portnoy's drumming...

I know this has been asked a thousand times. But can you recommend an Opeth album that I should start out on?

Thanks:thumb: