So for the list, would the Album/Cd have to be released during the artist's career, or can it be any official live recording? (Example - Hendrix Live At Berkely)

How the west was won has to be on there.

*gets hit in the head with a banjo by badmoon*

[QUOTE=Medopalis]On the topic of live albums, I'm listening to Mountain Jam off Disc 2 of Live At Filmore East...9 minutes down, nearly 25 to go. :lol: I like disc 1 of that album, but disc 2 > most other music.[/QUOTE]
Agreed. Mountain Jam is the most kickass song, especially the bass solo :cool:

[QUOTE=rock not roll]How the west was won has to be on there.

*gets hit in the head with a banjo by badmoon*[/QUOTE]

That's what I was hinting at.

Honorable mentions:

The Who - Live at Leeds
Led Zeppelin - How the West was Won
Peter Frampton - Frampton comes Alive
Gov't Mule - The Deepest End
Allman Brothers - Fillmore East
Allman Brothers - Beginnings
Grateful Dead - Europe '72
Grateful Dead - Live Dead
Deep Purple - In Japan
ect

[QUOTE=rock not roll]How the west was won has to be on there.

*gets hit in the head with a banjo by badmoon*[/QUOTE]
:lol: I don't care what badmoon says that should be on there.

What's the best Dead live stuff? So far I have Live at Leeds, Live at Fillmore, and How the West Was Won. Can Wheels of Fire Disc 2 count?

[QUOTE=badmoon349]Honorable mentions:
Led Zeppelin - How the West was Won
[/QUOTE]

Even you admitted it.

Oh What about Floyd?

[QUOTE=badmoon349]Honorable mentions:

The Who - Live at Leeds
Led Zeppelin - How the West was Won
Peter Frampton - Frampton comes Alive

Allman Brothers - Fillmore East


Grateful Dead - Live Dead
Deep Purple - In Japan
ect[/QUOTE]


:thumb: agreed.


To whoever the hell kept pushing Procol Harem on me, the classic rock radio station in Calgary played Conquistador ;). I enjoyed it even more before it was not coming out of my semi-broken headphones.

I'm just trying to please the group.

I personally would add at least two more Dead album, but no one would agree. Or we could add Dylan and The Dead?

[QUOTE=badmoon349]Led Zeppelin - How the West was Won[/QUOTE]
:eek: Did he just say what I think he said? Queen Live Magic anyone?

EDIT: Oh yes Dylan and The Dead could be on it.

[QUOTE=rock not roll]:thumb: agreed.


To whoever the hell kept pushing Procol Harem on me, the classic rock radio station in Calgary played Conquistador ;). I enjoyed it even more before it was not coming out of my semi-broken headphones.[/QUOTE]

Don't try to even it out. Each album you took out was a 5/5 for sure.

[QUOTE=badmoon349]I'm just trying to please the group.

I personally would add at least two more Dead album, but no one would agree. Or we could add Dylan and The Dead?[/QUOTE]

I'll give you Dylan and the Dead if you give me something by Cream.

I think we should have a Hendrix album in the list.

[QUOTE=lunch998]I'll give you Dylan and the Dead if you give me something by Cream.[/QUOTE]
Dylan and The Dead>Cream IMO

[QUOTE=Woodstock]I think we should have a Hendrix album in the list.[/QUOTE]
Like Live at Berkeley which I just listened to today and loved.

Cream's best live album wasn't completely live, how can we count that?

Band of Gypsys

[QUOTE=jpjrulestheworld]Like Live at Berkeley which I just listened to today and loved.[/QUOTE]

Yes. I told you. I'll vouch for Live at Berkely too.

[QUOTE=jpjrulestheworld]Like Live at Berkeley which I just listened to today and loved.[/QUOTE]

Subtract Live at Berkley and and put Band of Gypsies. IMO

[QUOTE=Schyma000]Band of Gypsys[/QUOTE]
Ding Ding Ding

It's a great live one.

Shall we make a poll with this?

I think Live at Berkely is better.

not yet

Live in London, Floyd....

but not many have even herd it so....:(

[QUOTE=badmoon349]Honorable mentions:

The Who - Live at Leeds
Led Zeppelin - How the West was Won
Peter Frampton - Frampton comes Alive
Gov't Mule - The Deepest End
Allman Brothers - Fillmore East
Allman Brothers - Beginnings
Grateful Dead - Europe '72
Grateful Dead - Live Dead
Deep Purple - In Japan
ect[/QUOTE]

"Beginnings" was not a live album.

[QUOTE=lunch998]I think Live at Berkely is better.[/QUOTE]

Haven't herd it so....I shall download it.

I found that "Band of Gypsies" was average overall.

And we have to include SOME Frank Zappa. How about one of the "You Can't Do That On Stage Anymore" albums?

[QUOTE=Disconnection Notice]"Beginnings" was not a live album.[/QUOTE]


Yea, you're right. I must have picked it out while going through my Allman collection. :chug:

[QUOTE=Disconnection Notice]I found that "Band of Gypsies" was average overall.

And we have to include SOME Frank Zappa. How about one of the "You Can't Do That On Stage Anymore" albums?[/QUOTE]
I think Band of Gypsys is hardly average, it's spectacular.

even though many people think the clash as a punk band london calling is classic rock period

Very much agreed

[QUOTE=heavyfender]even though many people think the clash as a punk band london calling is classic rock period[/QUOTE]

Yes, i'll agree. It's not like there can't be classic punk rock which is sort of classic rock and punk and such.

Umm, either way I agree :)

I agree with the statement on rap...it is crap! I can't stand that mindless "music"...theres noting to it! Anyone can rap...now Clapton, Zeppelin, Hendrix...those guys/band use talent! I am still utterly amazed at how good they are.

[QUOTE=Woodstock]I think Band of Gypsys is hardly average, it's spectacular.[/QUOTE]

Other than "Machine Gun" it was really sloppy.

[QUOTE=rock_legand]I agree with the statement on rap...it is crap! I can't stand that mindless "music"...theres noting to it! Anyone can rap...now Clapton, Zeppelin, Hendrix...those guys/band use talent! I am still utterly amazed at how good they are.[/QUOTE]

...stop talking.

[QUOTE=rock_legand]I agree with the statement on rap...it is crap! I can't stand that mindless "music"...theres noting to it! Anyone can rap...now Clapton, Zeppelin, Hendrix...those guys/band use talent! I am still utterly amazed at how good they are.[/QUOTE]

Look, we stopped talking about the a long itme ago. We just talk about classic rock music in general now. So shape up or leave.

[QUOTE=Disconnection Notice]Other than "Machine Gun" it was really sloppy.



.[/QUOTE]

Sloppy, or inivative?



Ahh, who am I kidding? Sloppy :(

Are you aware that you spelled "legend" wrong in user name?

[QUOTE=rock_legand]I agree with the statement on rap...it is crap! I can't stand that mindless "music"...theres noting to it! Anyone can rap...now Clapton, Zeppelin, Hendrix...those guys/band use talent! I am still utterly amazed at how good they are.[/QUOTE]

Oh, you would be the one that said Led Zeppelin was punk.

[QUOTE=rock not roll]Sloppy, or inivative?



Ahh, who am I kidding? Sloppy :([/QUOTE]

Have to give you props for the effort though. Good attempt.