[QUOTE=leppermessiah]Ya but if we're gonna logically consider this we have to think of what Metallica considers as their best material. We all love Kill em All on this forum but does Metallica consider it some of their best material? Who knows, but what i do know is that when I went to see them in concert, much to my dismay, they ignored KEA entirely. I know in other sets they added in some KEA here and there, but this is why i think that realistically Metallica probably wouldn't consider more than 2 or maybe 3 discs for a greatest hits album. I would love to see more, but IMO it would be 2 or 3.[/QUOTE]

Your right. I would, logically, assume it would consist of what they play most at concerts

[QUOTE=gocaps99]Ok here's what it should be

3 CD's of hits, all of the cds.
1 DVD of music videos
1 DVD of Cliff footage
1 DVD of post-Cliff footage

and then a biga[COLOR=White]s[/COLOR]s poster with a 30 page color booklet[/QUOTE]

That sounds kool. they should do that.

[QUOTE=gocaps99]see this is the thing with this thread. it's the one i post in the most and there's only 5 or 6 regular posters and they're never on. the RM community theres always ppl talking and here im just kinda bored...[/QUOTE]
Believe it or not, this is the only thread I post in, but I just don't have time to be online all the time. Because of that, I miss all the interesting stuff!!! :evil:

Oh my God, I'm playin the acoustic right now, cause my electric is in the other room. Don't play Of Wolf and Man on the acoustic. It sounds like poo.

OT: but congrats on the stars gocaps

[QUOTE=metallicamaniac16]Oh my God, I'm playin the acoustic right now, cause my electric is in the other room. Don't play Of Wolf and Man on the acoustic. It sounds like poo.[/QUOTE]

Acoustic... only play Unforgiven, FTB intro, FFWF intro, One Intro, and Nothing else matters on acoustic

[QUOTE]OT: but congrats on the stars gocaps[/QUOTE]

thanks :thumb:

rep+ to you, you've broken 1000 posts

[QUOTE=gocaps99]Ok here's what it should be

3 CD's of hits, all of the cds.
1 DVD of music videos
1 DVD of Cliff footage
1 DVD of post-Cliff footage

and then a biga[COLOR=White]s[/COLOR]s poster with a 30 page color booklet[/QUOTE]

sounds good where do i sign?

[QUOTE=gocaps99]Acoustic... only play Unforgiven, FTB intro, FFWF intro, One Intro, and Nothing else matters on acoustic



thanks :thumb:

rep+ to you, you've broken 1000 posts[/QUOTE]

wheres mine dude?

[QUOTE=JACKROXYOU]wheres mine dude?[/QUOTE]

up your a[COLOR=White]s[/COLOR]s, you double posted


i'm just jokin, rep+

what the hell is that?

[QUOTE=JACKROXYOU]what the hell is that?[/QUOTE]
it's like xanga in another language or something...

fun

sounds great

[QUOTE=JACKROXYOU]fun

sounds great[/QUOTE]

what's your rep now?

Cheers - still a long way to go though.

Only 457 atm

[QUOTE=iliketoplaydrums10111]i liked metallica's older stuff better than there new (who doesn't?), but my favorite song out of all would be master of puppets.

i like how it goes from there normal stuff in that song, to nice and soft and slow, then to unique solo's

i also like enter sandman, its a preety well balanced song.

lets try to keep this thread alive[/QUOTE]

I totally agree with you there but I'm more into Kill 'em All and Ride The Lightning than anything else. That's not to say I won't listen to
And justice or the older albums, (hell the first cd i ever owned to
was ...And Justice for All), but from Puppetz and below was and will always
be Metallica at their best

[QUOTE=gocaps99]what's your rep now?[/QUOTE]

659

i say they sell all the cds, some music videos, some live stuff, some stuff about cliff, the 300 page book and poster, and then we get to listen to lars ulrich(still an awesome drummer) bitch about not getting enough money for it all.

[QUOTE=FFbassist26]i say they sell all the cds, some music videos, some live stuff, some stuff about cliff, the 300 page book and poster, and then we get to listen to lars ulrich(still an awesome drummer) bitch about not getting enough money for it all.[/QUOTE]

It'll happen no matter what. :cool:

......courtesy of MetalliGreed!!!

Well if people want to talk about Metallica songs outside the fade to black, master of
puppets, etc box, then lets talk about songs like Fight fire with fire, Orion, Blackened,
and Wherever I may roam. First off, songs like fight fire w/ fire and blackened are the
epitome of what (Just my opinion, I don't want to
start no fights) Metallica should sound like. They started off as thrash and should end as thrash. I love the intro to fight fire with fire. It starts off as a soft melody that masks the brutal grind that follows. I LOVE when metal bands do that. I try to implement in my own song whenever possible.
Next, Songs like Orion are just ****ing awesome. I noticed that clear up to the
black album, every album had an instrumental piece.
(My Personal favorite Instrumental is The Call of the Ktulu.) This is a clear example of
musicianship that so many other bands lack. I think that metallica's popularity
with some of their more hardcore fans dwindled when they stopped doing these.
Lastly, Songs like Wherever I May Roam really drive the musicianship point home.

good for you :thumb:

but people like fade, master, etc

myself i love the tracks you mentioned, just dont forget disposable heroes

orian rocks

I think that the perfect example of what Metallica should be is the ...and justice for all cd. You have the thrash on blackened and dyers eve, one and ...and justice for alll are just 2 amazing songs that have quiet, loud, fast, and slow parts, and then theres the instrumental with a little acoustic part, to live is to die. People say that there only good albums were there first three but i highly disagree.

[QUOTE]I think that the perfect example of what Metallica should be is the ...and justice for all cd. You have the thrash on blackened and dyers eve, one and ...and justice for alll are just 2 amazing songs that have quiet, loud, fast, and slow parts, and then theres the instrumental with a little acoustic part, to live is to die. People say that there only good albums were there first three but i highly disagree.[/QUOTE]

I'd have to say that I'd disagree, but only because of the lack of bass on that album. Blackened is a sweet song though, I haven't listened to it for a long time.

[QUOTE=FFbassist26]i say they sell all the cds, some music videos, some live stuff, some stuff about cliff, the 300 page book and poster, and then we get to listen to lars ulrich(still an awesome drummer) bitch about not getting enough money for it all.[/QUOTE]

Hasent that been done before ? :confused:

This Monster Lives
 

Who has seen some kind of monster it kicks *** its worth every penney

I wanna rent it before i buy it ,gotta get some monney though

I want to see it, I hear they got a cheap shot on Mustaine in it though..

I don't understand the rivalry. I don't see why Dave is so sore, but I don't see why its a big deal in the first place either. I'd be pissed if I was kicked out of Metallica, but I wouldn't care like 20 years later, especially if I created Megadeth.

Very true.....Megadeth is my 3rd favourite band they can make just as good music as metallica...but he may be jealous of their popularity and their $$$$

Dave Mustaine in my eyes is a good musician, but nothing more as a person. If he shows more of what he did after he hosted the Dimebag headbanger's ball than maybe I'll give him some more credit.

A 20 year fued is just ridiculous. I think we can all agree that Slayer, Metallica, and Megadeth are all Thrash pioneers. I don't think Mustaine realises how much better it'd be to have a good relationship with them.

[QUOTE=MoX_KIll]I wanna rent it before i buy it ,gotta get some monney though[/QUOTE]

no don't bother. it's a waste of 3 dollars. just go buy it

[QUOTE]Dave Mustaine in my eyes is a good musician, but nothing more as a person. If he shows more of what he did after he hosted the Dimebag headbanger's ball than maybe I'll give him some more credit.


A 20 year fued is just ridiculous. I think we can all agree that Slayer, Metallica, and Megadeth are all Thrash pioneers. I don't think Mustaine realises how much better it'd be to have a good relationship with them.
[/QUOTE]

i think it came to an end. he came to grips with everything with lars in SKOM

[QUOTE=Sliptallica]Dave Mustaine in my eyes is a good musician, but nothing more as a person. If he shows more of what he did after he hosted the Dimebag headbanger's ball than maybe I'll give him some more credit.

A 20 year fued is just ridiculous. I think we can all agree that Slayer, Metallica, and Megadeth are all Thrash pioneers. I don't think Mustaine realises how much better it'd be to have a good relationship with them.[/QUOTE]

Well.. Some people are just like that. Mustaine can't help that he's a dick sometimes. Or for 20 years.. Imagine being kicked out of Metallica yourself, you'de more than likely be pissed you got kicked out of a sucessful band..

[QUOTE=MoX_KIll]Very true.....Megadeth is my 3rd favourite band they can make just as good music as metallica...but he may be jealous of their popularity and their $$$$[/QUOTE]

your avatar kicks as[COLOR=White]s[/COLOR]

20 YEARS MAN! 20! I haven't even experienced that many years of existance and I know I'd probably forgive by now!

[QUOTE=Sliptallica]20 YEARS MAN! 20! I haven't even experienced that many years of existance and I know I'd probably forgive by now![/QUOTE]

But the pain he's gone through. He's just been number two all these years. He's been through 20 years of being the number two guy. He was the guitarist of the greatest band ever, and just effed himself up

[QUOTE=gocaps99]what's your rep now?[/QUOTE]
10, I'm climbin the charts baby!!!

i was actually talkin to Jack, but here ya go. you shuold be up tooo 30? i think? i think you give 2% rep

[QUOTE=Sliptallica]20 YEARS MAN! 20! I haven't even experienced that many years of existance and I know I'd probably forgive by now![/QUOTE]

Yeah hes kinda odd like that. I'm sure I'd forgive someone after 20 years.. But you gotta take into concideration what gocaps said about always being number 2..

waaahoooo repping spree! guys on page 495 got some, now i can't rep for 24 hrs

[QUOTE=gocaps99]i was actually talkin to Jack, but here ya go. you shuold be up tooo 30? i think? i think you give 2% rep[/QUOTE]
I know you were talkin to Jack, but I thought I'd throw it in there anyway for a laugh. Btw, thanks man; you rule!!! :thumb: I'm up to 34 now, thanks to you.

Does Mustaine get any of metallica's money for helping with some songs and such ?