That's unconstitutional! Where in the punk forum rules proscribed by the Founding Brain Toad does it say that Fight Club jokes are reason for closure?

We can't talk about Fight Club because it is too cool and popular for King Domenick.

[QUOTE=AIRIC;14607823] King Domenick.[/QUOTE]

And you my loyal subjects.

Grow some balls and keep the thread closed. You cant be a leader if you're indecisive.

Don't listen to macho tough guys like Eric. Do what you feel is right

Honestly, can't we just delete this forum? The only threads that see any action are the Community Thread and the threads where people talk about how they don't like punk anymore.

hey shut up. :(

hello why was i banned

[QUOTE=Egggo;14748483]hello why was i banned[/QUOTE]

No mods here banned you.

oh ok ty ^_^

Reopen my thread please.

pr0n:
[url]http://www.sputnikmusic.com/forums/showpost.php?p=14871589&postcount=1241[/url]

Thanks.

I don't see why the straight edge thread is locked and the Oi thread isn't

Oh wait

[Anxious] because I said so.

Dude, you're a retard.

Here are my reasons, they are perfectly logical.

Oi thread is open because:
1.It pertains to punk
2.People have come in to discuss it and are interested in it.
3.Closing it would imply we don't welcome that kind of music around here, when the forum title implies we do.
4. It would send the wrong message to new users
5. Flamers should stay out of it anyway; closing it would give weight to their behavior.

Straight Edge thread is closed because:
1. The argument is tired
2. It attracts shitty posters like Gannondorf
3. Look back 20 pages and you'll find the same exact thing.


I explained this to you in slsk. If this doesn't make sense to you you are a ****ing idiot. And you have the audacity to bump your Hip-Hop thread, which should have been closed on sight because it has nothing to do with Punk.

Well I was mainly trying to draw Matt's attention, you know, the other mod.

In soulseek you said there are numerous posts from people who want to discuss it when there are like, three. You're pretty intent on keeping one thread open to keep one new guy, but you fail to consider that there are a lot of people who'd like to discuss straight edge too. And "the flaming in there shouldn't be in there anyway" is bulls[COLOR="Black"]h[/COLOR]it, it doesn't mean the thread ISN'T full of s[COLOR="Black"]h[/COLOR]it. You could say the same exact thing about any bad post someone makes in the straight edge thread. Honestly we're lucky for any new threads these days, but you can't lock one thread which was generating actual discussion and keep a thread full of flames open on the grounds that "It's punk"

As far as my hip hop thread, it has everything to do with the community here, because plenty of us listen to hip hop and I feel like we should have a thread to talk about it within the punk forum if we want.

[QUOTE]
As far as my hip hop thread, it has everything to do with the community here, because plenty of us listen to hip hop and I feel like we should have a thread to talk about it within the punk forum if we want.[/QUOTE]
And thats why its not closed.

[QUOTE=you]that there are a lot of people who'd like to discuss straight edge too.[/QUOTE]
[QUOTE=me]1. The argument is tired
2. It attracts poopty posters like Gannondorf[/QUOTE]
[QUOTE=you] it doesn't mean the thread ISN'T full of ****.[/QUOTE]
[QUOTE=me]1.It pertains to punk[/QUOTE]
[QUOTE=you]which was generating actual discussion[/QUOTE]
[QUOTE=me]3. Look back 20 pages and you'll find the same exact thing.[/QUOTE]
[QUOTE=you]and keep a thread full of flames open on the grounds[/QUOTE]
[QUOTE=me]5. Flamers should stay out of it anyway; closing it would give weight to their behavior.[/QUOTE]





[QUOTE]Well I was mainly trying to draw Matt's attention, you know, the other mod.[/QUOTE]
This position is completely voluntary. If Matt wants to do something, his opinion is just as valid as mine because we are both the mods here. He hasn't done anything. My decision stands.

Please take everything I said totally out of context, I'd like to see that done again please.

[QUOTE=Flagjacket;14921276]Please take everything I said totally out of context, I'd like to see that done again please.[/QUOTE]

The reason I formatted it like that is because you obviously didn't read my original reasons because I already addressed all of your points that you brought up. You can go ahead and make another post with the same points brought up again, but you should look at my original reasons next time because I don't feel like typing them again.

Well your reasons are still flawed because straight edge obviously pertains to punk as well. And your reasons for the Oi thread are all basically false anyway.

[QUOTE=Punk Rules Thread]15. Certain threads are not allowed in this forum. For several reasons.
For general spam content/stupidity
Introduction Threads
Picture Threads
Band X Vs Band Y threads
Who is a better [instrument] threads
Whats your favorite song by Band X threads
Threads asking what punk 'is', 'was', if it is dead, etc.

For flame wars/arguments that promote hate among users.
Vegan/vegetarian threads
Straight edge/drug use threads
Political threads.
(For these you can post about them in the Social Issues thread: [url]http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showthread.php?t=427178[/url], or you can post about them in the Politics, News, and World Issues forum if it doesn't break their rules)
[/QUOTE]
Wow, Nick was a ****ing prophet! How did he know how all the sxe threads end up?

Hahahahahaha. Nice.

Third post by this guy I've deleted.

I just like that it was in the thread for reporting problems.

Mod

No you're not.

[url]http://www.sputnikmusic.com/forums/member.php?u=252494[/url]

spamming the rate what the user above you is listening to thread.

[QUOTE=Scuba_Steve;15032674][url]http://www.sputnikmusic.com/forums/member.php?u=252494[/url]

spamming the rate what the user above you is listening to thread.[/QUOTE]

ok steve, you owned me. now my rating is -145. :amaze:
lulz, I got trolled.

[QUOTE=mozartv;15032790]ok steve, you owned me. now my rating is -145. :amaze:
lulz, I got trolled.[/QUOTE]

last time I checked neg repping on a post the deserves neg repping isnt trolling.


:-/

[QUOTE=Scuba_Steve;15032824]last time I checked neg repping on a post the deserves neg repping isnt trolling.


:-/[/QUOTE]

true. i deserved it. no one likes to get rolled. All I can say in my defense is,"That I did it for the lulz."

P.S. can i have some rep. points back? pppppllllleeeeaaaasssseeee!!!!!