0.0002/5. I heard Metallica lost so much money because of Napster that they couldn't afford to make good music anymore.

4/5. deal with it and don't give me this garbage because children of bodom are terrible. korn sucks so don't even start there. dream theater is over indulgent. iron maiden have been rehasing since powerslave.

the production values weren't so great, but have you heard kill 'em all? the drum sounds like a trash can, but when you disconnect the snare it does sound like that. in parts jame's voice is distored like ministry uses.

why are you so scared of change? you can still go to a metallica concert and they'll still play one and master of puppets. so stop complaining.

oh and load was and still is a good CD.

Worst Metallica cd I've heard.
Nonetheless 3/5

[QUOTE=Crashingleg]0.0002/5. I heard Metallica lost so much money because of Napster that they couldn't afford to make good music anymore.[/QUOTE]
:lol::lol:
Good work
And, ive listened to this a few more times, and it's just gotten worse
0.5/5

What a waste of money, I want my $13 back. At least they could've made the DVD exciting, but it was just boring. It's always a bad thing when you're trying to convince yourself that an album is good after you've bought it, but release it sucks. -5/10 (if possible) Worst CD I've ever bought.

SHOCKINGLY BAD.

I would expect a lot better from metallica. St anger is a reasonable song but overall the album is very poor. Their older stuff is infinately better.

ya i thought that this cd sucked compared to their other ones......there was no solos in this cd like all of their other cds....that is what i was looking forward to..,.

2/5........it wasnt very good.....*go ahead and flame me**

[QUOTE=ieatalotoftacos]What a waste of money, I want my $13 back. At least they could've made the DVD exciting, but it was just boring. It's always a bad thing when you're trying to convince yourself that an album is good after you've bought it, but release it sucks. -5/10 (if possible) Worst CD I've ever bought.[/QUOTE]


.....ya i agree with u...all of the way....

Ya know, I am an old school rocker & a metallica fan from way back....
but as I listen to this band trying to update their sound , they seem to have lost their original edge on this CD.
And I have to tell ya...That snare sound on every song, drives me frickin crazy...it is annoying & obnoxious....
I guess when you are this rich & famous, when the producer or engineer knows you have a crappy snare sound, but they let you leave it that way...You know you are way too rich & famous....

Jay

I dont think that they could meet there own standards for this album, although they accomplished what they wanted to with it.

i think that metallica thought it was goin to be easy to make the album an they just never tried since they dont need to achieve anythin more....they might of got fed up of playing there old music since they have been doin it for so long maybe they just wanted a change. they should hopefuly listen to the fans if they make another album and it should be better. meh anyway if they think that it was a success then gud for them an they should do whatever they want :thumb:

f****** $#1t£

at least its better than load and reload

st.anger sounds like they recoreded the first few minutes then just repeated it and repeated it i wouldnt mind but its not even good

1.001/5

[QUOTE=metallicaman89]f****** $#1t£[/QUOTE]

shut up. and on the subject of this thread, DON'T come in here and say nothing but IT SUCKED. give a full explanation of yourself, and don't say its the worst album ever, cuz trust me, i've heard MUCH worse in any and/or all genres.

I think this cd is pure crap. It just isn't Metallica.

the album hmmmm..... 2/5

live stuff off this album.... 10/5, all the stuff off St anger goes CRAAAAAAAAZY live. i love it

[QUOTE=jono1]at least its better than load and reload[/QUOTE]


Haha, since when? At least I can listen to songs off those two albums, I can't find one, and I said ONE song off of St. Anger that I like.

I don't think this album shoulda been classified under "Metal", but whatever.. I give it a "1/5". That is also the rating I give pop-punk bands and emo bands. Good job Metallica :thumb:.

4/5 for your review :thumb:

The album gets a 2/5.

My friend hates metallica because he watches a lot of muchmusic (Canadian MTV) and they play st anger and frantic and he thinks that that is all that Metallica ever made. The idiot.

In the grand pile of poop that Metallica is...this album is the best. 5/5.

[QUOTE=metallica_pyro]9 out of 5!! One of Metallica's best albums!![/QUOTE]
are u effing stupid? go listen to Ride the lightning, Master of Puppets, Kill 'em All, or the Black Album before you ever say anything again....

i can't believe you're still talking about a review made 7 months ago

this album was the worst ever by metallica .5/5

I thought it was a huge disappointment :angry:

metallica are doing what they've allways done, which is change to suit a new audience. and the new audience unfortunately likes tuneless songs with shouting and not singing, not like het's real singing voice, which was utterly fantastic. but i have heard they've learned a lessons and gone back to the old stuff, eg. sad but true, the unforgiven etc. yay!

st. anger = 1/5

this album sucks ***

Sure the new Metallica isn't what we all hoped it'd be. But wouldn't it be pretty boring if they put out an album that sounded just like Kill 'em All? or even one just like Reload or something. They'd just be doing the same thing again. The thing is, they could have gotten a ****ty sound without TRYING to make it sound bad. They could have just used simple equipment if they wanted it to sound raw. But whatever, it sounds like a garage band. But that's not what nu-metal sounds like anyway. I don't really like this album, but i'm proud of them for having the balls to put this out. We know and they know they are incredible musicians

Have to ay i like this review. i like St.Anger, go ahead, dish it out but i like the album. and even though i like the album it was soooooo refreshing to see constuctive criticizm rather than just mindless mudslinging. so whilst i disagree woth the rating, like the review. personality i rate st.anger a solid 3 to 3.5 outta 5, but definately not up there with the ***-kickery of master of puppets or ride the lightning.

Sad but True? The Unforgiven, whatch out we got a black album junkie! dont get me wrong the black album was great, commercial or not it has some heavy-*** **** on it. Even Kerry King agreed woth that, but come on, the good old **** is stuff like hit the lights, damage inc. metal militia (not played live since 1986 i think, but cracked out recently).

Bassman probably isnt one of these people, but there are idiots out there who think liking enter sandman makes them hardcore metal heads. kill those people.

Although i understand how bass players would prefer black album, load and reload, bass was used a bit more on those albums. pity Jason was too **** to play bass the REAL way, without a pick.

What the hell were they thinking.
It sounded like they took some korn songs and SLAGHTERED THE HELL OUT OF THEM!!!!!!!!!
wrist sliting bad
-5/5