I like Pink Floyd and Grateful Dead. No matter how many instruments they play.

Badmoon, sorry for being a douche in the other forums.

End this arguement!

This would be a good debate topic.

But if you use 3d recording, you don't get that sweet echo effect when the vocals leak into the drum mics :thumb:

(Plant on Whole Lotta Love, just about 4:00 minutes)

[QUOTE=magicbus]But if you use 3d recording, you don't get that sweet echo effect when the vocals leak into the drum mics :thumb:

(Plant on Whole Lotta Love, just about 4:00 minutes)[/QUOTE]

That's why most Zeppelin recordings rule.

Still 3D recordings are way better

No seriously! Listen to that part! Its sweet! I even left the time!

[QUOTE=Schyma000]Still 3D recordings are way better[/QUOTE]

Yea but if the band doesn't use 3D recordings, then you feel alittle more like it's a "live" recording. Any you know what they play in the studio, they can play live as well. (Obviously the Beatles and the Dead can play live, thats not what I was refering to.) It just seems more real to me if you don't 3D record.

[QUOTE=lunch998]Yea but if the band doesn't use 3D recordings, then you feel alittle more like it's a "live" recording. Any you know what they play in the studio, they can play live as well. (Obviously the Beatles and the Dead can play live, thats not what I was refering to.) It just seems more real to me if you don't 3D record.[/QUOTE]

I agree. I decided if I was in a band, I would try both, but prefer non 3D, and only use it a little. It seems more authentic to me that way.

The Beatles really didn't do that many live shows...

[QUOTE=Schyma000]The Beatles really didn't do that many live shows...[/QUOTE]
Rooftop Concert was sweet though.

[QUOTE=Schyma000]The Beatles really didn't do that many live shows...[/QUOTE]

Maybe not, I just added that in to avoid an arguement. But we all know the Grateful Dead can play live.

[QUOTE=Schyma000]The Beatles really didn't do that many live shows...[/QUOTE]

Uh, that's all they did from 1960-66.....except for the time to make their movies and record their albums. That's why they quit touring.

I'm pissed that the polls aren't open that long. I wanted to vote for Blue Oyster Cult so bad in #1, but I haven't been online for the past 36 hours, I'm pissed. Is it possible that it can be changed? (or is it gonna move on anyway?)

[QUOTE=lunch998]Yea but if the band doesn't use 3D recordings, then you feel alittle more like it's a "live" recording. Any you know what they play in the studio, they can play live as well. (Obviously the Beatles and the Dead can play live, thats not what I was refering to.) It just seems more real to me if you don't 3D record.[/QUOTE]

Well, it would be "live" if they took only one go at a track. Otherwise, if they weren't using the 3D recording, they'd just be playing it live, but taking many goes at the song.

yah that was there last concert, probably where u2 got the idea eh

[QUOTE]Why do politicians have debates? Why do news channels have Debate shows?[/QUOTE]

Thats different. In a political debate, you can say "i have the facts right here that so and so did a better job, they are irrefutable truths." if anyone said "it is a fact that pink floyd is the greatest band ever" people would call them an idiot.

[QUOTE]Not really Badmoon made reasonable point and maybe Ill cheak out a little more Dead...and maybe not[/QUOTE]

He did make reasonable points, but its just as easy to say "hey, you should check out the Dead, they're really awesome." Also, him just saying "The Dead are better than Pink Floyd" won't (hopefully) convince you. You'd have to listen to them and make up your own mind. Which can be done by avoiding the argument with a lot less hassle than if you do it through the argument.

[QUOTE=Seafroggys]Uh, that's all they did from 1960-66.....except for the time to make their movies and record their albums. That's why they quit touring.[/QUOTE]

When as successful as the Beatles you dont really need to tour...**** I wouldn't :thumb:

[QUOTE=Seafroggys]Uh, that's all they did from 1960-66.....except for the time to make their movies and record their albums. That's why they quit touring.[/QUOTE]

When your as successful as the Beatles you dont really need to tour...**** I wouldn't :thumb:

I checked out American Beauty. I liked Truckin'.

[QUOTE=DeusExMachina]Thats different. In a political debate, you can say "i have the facts right here that so and so did a better job, they are irrefutable truths." if anyone said "it is a fact that pink floyd is the greatest band ever" people would call them an idiot.



He did make reasonable points, but its just as easy to say "hey, you should check out the Dead, they're really awesome." Also, him just saying "The Dead are better than Pink Floyd" won't (hopefully) convince you. You'd have to listen to them and make up your own mind. Which can be done by avoiding the argument with a lot less hassle than if you do it through the argument.[/QUOTE]

No its much more fun to rant at each other by the way nice title Across the Universe is so great :thumb:

[QUOTE=magicbus]I checked out American Beauty. I liked Truckin'.[/QUOTE]

Who doesn't??

Box of Rain is my favorite off American Beauty.

I love that song.

I prefer "Sugar Magnolia" and "Ripple/Brokedown Palace" (I play those two as one usually).

Sugar Magnolia is pure brilliance, I also think Ramble on Rose is brilliant.

Yeah, that's a great song. I really like "China Cat Sunflower"'s time signatures.

You know... did any of us concider Elvis, Jerry Lee Lewis, Johny Cash or Buddy Holly for the poll?

DVG.

I'm pretty sure Elvis is one of the polls, but the others you would have to ask Rock not Roll about.

Were the Doobie Brothers on the list? I don't remember seeing them.

[QUOTE=Woodstock]Were the Doobie Brothers on the list? I don't remember seeing them.[/QUOTE]
[QUOTE]Group 3

Mountain
John Lennon
Kiss
Jimi Hendrix Experience
Blind Faith
Alice Cooper
Fleetwood Mac
Guns N Roses
Queen
The Doobie Brothers [/QUOTE]

yep

Me=Blind. Thanks.

I found this website. classicrockforums.com

I might join.

[QUOTE=badmoon349]I prefer "Sugar Magnolia" and "Ripple/Brokedown Palace" (I play those two as one usually).[/QUOTE]

Ripple is good I like the hiddin track version of it better (#17 on Beauty)
Hated Sugar Magnolia the vocals are very annoying

[QUOTE=DVG]You know... did any of us concider Elvis, Jerry Lee Lewis, Johny Cash or Buddy Holly for the poll?

DVG.[/QUOTE]
Isn't Johny Cash more country than rock?

yeah, i would have liked to see buddy holly on one of those lists..don't know how well he'd fare though =p

to throw out a question, anyone here a fan of leon russel?

I havent't been here in a long time.....3 days

I missed 4 of the Polls however I will be voting for Buffalo Springfeild in the upcoming one.


Anything to get Neil in to the top.


Floyd>Grateful Dead

Oh yeah I also found this cool country/Bluegrass remix of the Wall done by this country band speaking of Floyd and The Grateful Dead.

If anyone wants some songs I'll send them to you on AIM

My dad had the C.D.

Anyone home?

Yes.

Yeah this is slow today.........so lets list bands better then the Grateful Dead

Hey Im making a mix CD... I've got
Heroin, Velvet Underground
White Rabbit, Jefferson Airplane
Harvest Moon, Neil Young
Cinaminn Girl, CSN&Y
Rud Mude and Texas Flood, Stevie Ray
What else should I download?