[url]http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showthread.php?p=9001547#post9001547[/url]

thread bout deftones being best ever


edit: dam beaten to it

darn
 

now why u go and do that. i love the deftones and u go and kill my joy. people are so mean nowdays. the deftones live on................

[QUOTE=k-eastwood]now why u go and do that. i love the deftones and u go and kill my joy. people are so mean nowdays. the deftones live on................[/QUOTE]

Making a thread on The Deftones is fine. Making a thread proclaiming them the best band ever isn't. Just chill.

Why not just ask to have the thread title changed and make it a general discussion thread about the band?

[QUOTE=k-eastwood]now why u go and do that. i love the deftones and u go and kill my joy. people are so mean nowdays. the deftones live on................[/QUOTE]

Here, read this [url=http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showthread.php?t=309193]thread[/url], then go and make the best Deftones thread you can. Just don't put the words "Official", "Greatest" or "Best" in the title.

[QUOTE=HeavyRiva]Well, we have had the best:
Classic Rock band
Metal band
Guitarist
Bassist
Favourite song
Favourite album

That leaves only drummers, keyboardists (though GurS ran that in P&K, I think) and frontmen.

I'm not sure if the mods will like too many more competitions in the future. Though in another year or so I might re-run the albums comp.[/QUOTE]
I can't see us doing a keyboardists one.

Are some of the others going to be re-run? Because I would LOVE to do the Greatest Classic Rock band one. :D

[url]http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showthread.php?t=360020[/url] close and unsticky

[url]http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showthread.php?t=374027[/url] sticky


Thank you to any mod who does so.

[url]http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showthread.php?p=9003829#post9003829[/url]
Should have gone in the music recommendations thread

[url]http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showpost.php?p=8984994&postcount=626[/url]
Ban please

why has the thread 'goth poser' been closed yesterday? it was an interesting conversation about the definition what 'goth' is.... plz mods, give me an explanation. in my opinion there was no reason for closing it.

you can close threads when ppl are flaming and nobody discuss, but this was not the case !

[QUOTE=repcak]why has the thread 'goth poser' been closed yesterday? it was an interesting conversation about the definition what 'goth' is.... plz mods, give me an explanation. in my opinion there was no reason for closing it.

you can close threads when ppl are flaming and nobody discuss, but this was not the case ![/QUOTE]
It was an awful thread, and the topic has been discussed to death already. Besides that flaming was bound to start up sooner or later.

[QUOTE=munky_magik]It was an awful thread, and the topic has been discussed to death already. Besides that flaming was bound to start up sooner or later.[/QUOTE]

awful??!! why do you think it was awful... i don't think it was.
and because it has been discussed to death... -> its an interesting topic and there is no 100% definition what goth is and a lot of ppl don't know what it is. so i think it is important to talk about it

[QUOTE=HeavyRiva]Well, we have had the best:
Classic Rock band
Metal band
Guitarist
Bassist
Favourite song
Favourite album

That leaves only drummers, keyboardists (though GurS ran that in P&K, I think) and frontmen.

I'm not sure if the mods will like too many more competitions in the future. Though in another year or so I might re-run the albums comp.[/QUOTE]




You could do Ballads
One-Hit Wonder
One Album
Over Rated
Under Rated

[QUOTE=repcak]awful??!! why do you think it was awful... i don't think it was.
and because it has been discussed to death... -> its an interesting topic and there is no 100% definition what goth is and a lot of ppl don't know what it is. so i think it is important to talk about it[/QUOTE]
The original question was something along the lines of "this guy listens to slayer, but dresses like a goth. what do you thik a goth poseur is?"
That's a bad thread. If there isn't an accepted definition of goth then people are just going to argue the point back and forth for weeks.
If they really care that much about what the definition of goth is then tell them to go [url=http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=goth]here[/url].

[quote]You could do Ballads
One-Hit Wonder
One Album
Over Rated
Under Rated[/quote]
Those competitions would be a complete and utter waste of time.

[QUOTE=munky_magik]The original question was something along the lines of "this guy listens to slayer, but dresses like a goth. what do you thik a goth poseur is?"
That's a bad thread. If there isn't an accepted definition of goth then people are just going to argue the point back and forth for weeks.
If they really care that much about what the definition of goth is then tell them to go [url=http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=goth]here[/url].
[/QUOTE]

yes, that was the begin of the thread: "what do you thinkg a goth poser is?". but afterwards (if you have read the whole thread) you have realized that we pushed the thread to another topic and it wasn't only about poser anymore, it was an interesting conversation about the whole philosphy, the life, etc. of gothic.
read the thread as a whole.

I say give a waring to K-Eastwood he's been warned not to make that thread and ended up make 2 of them. :rolleyes:

"Deftone - Greatest Band Ever"

Edit: He says he's sorry for doing it. I'd say if he does it again ban him but of course it's your call.

[QUOTE=munky_magik]

Those competitions would be a complete and utter waste of time.[/QUOTE]



Maybe so however....

[QUOTE=repcak]yes, that was the begin of the thread: "what do you thinkg a goth poser is?". but afterwards (if you have read the whole thread) you have realized that we pushed the thread to another topic and it wasn't only about poser anymore, it was an interesting conversation about the whole philosphy, the life, etc. of gothic.
read the thread as a whole.[/QUOTE]
Well, if you feel it canged into somethiing worthwhile then you'll have to wait for the person who closed it to answer.

[quote]


Maybe so however....[/quote]
However what? :confused:

I can tell you now that Stairway to heaven will win the best ballad.
Hendrix will win One Hit Wonder.
And No one will be able to agree on over rated or under rated albums.

[url=http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showpost.php?p=9004874&postcount=25249]Advertising[/url]

well, what happens when somebody is posting advertising?
banned? for how long... ?

[QUOTE=repcak]well, what happens when somebody is posting advertising?
banned? for how long... ?[/QUOTE]
Depends on the Mod who bans. Can be a few weeks, can be permanent.

permanent? good to know, cause i making a website about me and there would be a downloadsection where i want to upload some avatars others can download for free. i wanted to publish it on MX...
now i won't do that

[url]http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/member.php?userid=117553[/url]

Being spectacularly annoying.

[url=http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showthread.php?t=207697&page=5]Example[/url]
Multiple posting, bumped a year-old thread, went into an SP thread to bump it just to say he'd already made an SP thread, etc.

He made a couple of advertising threads in Punk/Pop-Punk recently too, though I guess that's irrelevant to the modding in here.

Advertising is advertising no matter where it is.

[url=http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showthread.php?t=373964]Cover song suggestions[/url]

[QUOTE=HeavyRiva]Well, we have had the best:
Classic Rock band
Metal band
Guitarist
Bassist
Favourite song
Favourite album

That leaves only drummers, keyboardists (though GurS ran that in P&K, I think) and frontmen.

I'm not sure if the mods will like too many more competitions in the future. Though in another year or so I might re-run the albums comp.[/QUOTE]

I would like to go back and read the other competition threads and I can't find them in the search(or not looking hard enough) Do you know where I could find them or things that I could type to simplify the search?

a good idea is to figure out who's run a thread like. Then you can simply go to their profile, click threads started by the user and search for what you want. For example YPload did best bassist poll: [url]http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/search.php?searchid=185601[/url]

[QUOTE=Da_Machine]I would like to go back and read the other competition threads and I can't find them in the search(or not looking hard enough) Do you know where I could find them or things that I could type to simplify the search?[/QUOTE]
The search won't turn up anything from before the database crashes that occured. The only ways to find the threads would be to use the 'View all threads created by' in a User's profile.
I know Riva did the favourite album, Pigs(onedifferent one) ran the metal band, YDload did favourite bassist, and Schyma did favourite guitarist, I think. But I can't remember who did the classic rock comp.

[url]http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showpost.php?p=8898723&postcount=7201[/url]
series collection once again updated. I think more attention should be paid since they're quite informative and people spend a lot of time in them.

[url]http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showthread.php?t=374253[/url]

Lots of errors... official thread, wrong forum...

[QUOTE=Stoic][url]http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showpost.php?p=8898723&postcount=7201[/url]
series collection once again updated. I think more attention should be paid since they're quite informative and people spend a lot of time in them.[/QUOTE]

It's good that you are doing this, but pretty soon everyone will be doing personalised series threads, and we won't have anymore room to archive them. :)

They are quite informative, yes, but I'm not sure if any new series's will be included.

[url]http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showthread.php?t=374391[/url]
Favourite thread

[QUOTE=HeavyRiva]It's good that you are doing this, but pretty soon everyone will be doing personalised series threads, and we won't have anymore room to archive them. :)

They are quite informative, yes, but I'm not sure if any new series's will be included.[/QUOTE]

I agree. write-ups are always good, but everyone shouldn't be looking for an archived personalised series.