[QUOTE=RockAndRoll]ack, tommorow is not good.[/QUOTE]

How about a mini debate right now?

Everybody is on AIM right now I assume...

Tomorrow is the Aim album-trade so we should try it another time.

i guess i can do it... dont have AIM tho, but i can get it. *groan* that means ill have to wake up at 8AM. Ill just sit in, but i dont mind argueing for Zeppelin.

DVG.

[QUOTE=MalcolmYoungRock]How about a mini debate right now?

Everybody is on AIM right now I assume...[/QUOTE]

I can't, I've been avoiding my homework as usual. It's almost 10 on the east coast too, so I should go do that.

If anyone wants to talk to me on Aim, my screen name is lunch998.

Augh, everybody I know holds off their homework.

I do it first thing :thumb:.

Then again, my parents force me too....

So have I made my point? Or are we still going to debate a pointless arguement?

Why not debate which one had more influence or more talent? Not which one is better?

[QUOTE=rock not roll]So have I made my point? Or are we still going to debate a pointless arguement?

Why not debate which one had more influence or more talent? Not which one is better?[/QUOTE]
That is a good idea...

I think what we should do is we should do one of those band vs band things.

Once we go to the point where we can't debate any longer about a band we pick a winner then get a new band.

Something like that..

Edit: Or we can also do it like that

Debate on 2 bands and which had the most influence and then we move on to another band to debate with the band that won or had the "most influence"

[QUOTE=rock not roll]So have I made my point? Or are we still going to debate a pointless arguement?

Why not debate which one had more influence or more talent? Not which one is better?[/QUOTE]

The point of debating it with members of this forum is to get intelligent responses about influence and talent, not have people say "Zeppelin is better because Jimmy Page Rules!"

[QUOTE=lunch998]The point of debating it with members of this forum is to get intelligent responses about influence and talent, not have people say "Zeppelin is better because Jimmy Page Rules!"[/QUOTE]


That's why I'm so horribly thankful that few noobs have found their way into this thread.

Yea me too. Anyways, I'm out, peace guys.

I'm just saying that debating which band is better is stupid. No good could come of it. Everyone has their own opinons and neither side could ever be right. So why not debate something worthwhile?

edit: see ya.

We could always set something up like they have in the Politics forum...

Pick teams for a debate, first a member from one team posts then the other.. And there could be 3 rounds or something, each member posting once per round. And we could do that right here in the forum.

[quote]Why not debate which one had more influence or more talent? Not which one is better?[/quote]

Well i suppose the 'whos better' sorta encompases influence and talent.

DVG.

Then again, on the "Which band had more influence" debate, people can just argue that "Led Zeppelin had the most influence because they had Jimmy Page and he R0x0rs" Then again a debate is all opinionated.

Okay, I'm here now.

We're not debating to see who's better. We're debating just for the sake of arguing against one of your peirs about a topic that is serious to both of you. So, some great opinions can arise.

We can debate several bands in one session.

We need to pick teams, but I'm not sure who's in.

No it doesn't, who's better is who makes the better music. And music is subjective, everyone has their own tastes, so nobody would ever be correct.

edit: to dvg

We can debate both topics, we'll just split um up.

Fine, we will see how it turns out.

[QUOTE=badmoon349]Okay, I'm here now.

We're not debating to see who's better. We're debating just for the sake of arguing against one of your peirs about a topic that is serious to both of you. So, some great opinions can arise.

We can debate several bands in one session.

We need to pick teams, but I'm not sure who's in.[/QUOTE]

*Peers :P

I'm in for sure.

I. Band vs. Band
A. Skill
B. Influence
c. Originality

EDIT: 2nd outline in one day :thumb:

ahh.. but then you can change the debate question... 'which band is better in term of influence, skill and overall music?'

tada

DVG.

omgz badmoon you've gone over 1000 posts i nthis thread.

:eek:


Dvg: sounds good, just no "which band is better (period)". it's not productive.

[QUOTE=MalcolmYoungRock]*Peers :P

I'm in for sure.[/QUOTE]

It's that kind of s[COLOR=White]hit[/COLOR] that gets people killed. And I figure because I'm American I can be half [COLOR=White]as[/COLOR]sed. :p

I just wrote a killer banjo tune.

lol, he makes up almost 1/7th of this thread.

DVG.

[QUOTE=badmoon349]It's that kind of s[COLOR=White]hit[/COLOR] that gets people killed. And I figure because I'm American I can be half [COLOR=White]as[/COLOR]sed. :p[/QUOTE]

I'm American too....

So I'll kill you back :p

I have 800 posts in this thread. 400 of which are about music and only about 20 of those are worthwhile.

Okay, what will be the two bands?

How can you tell how many posts you have?