A cuople of brilliant songs, there are a dusin of brilliant songs on black album. Enter Sandman, Sad But True, Wherever I may Roam, The God That failed, Of wholf and man, Nothing else matters, ect ect

I think It's just the fact that for about 3 months thats all our drummer would try (black album stuff) so I've become a bit sick of some of it

I just put Kill em All back in my Cd player for the first time in weeks and i'd fogotten how mind blowing this album is. If you own it go listen to it. now. :thumb:

It's etc BTW not ect.

^^ Maybe they wanna put their old days behind them but I think they still know all their fans love the old stuff more

Robe is right!!
After what I can see you put bob Rock on the bottom
I'm afraid i have to disagree with your list except S&M on the top

[QUOTE][i]Originally posted by Bomsen [/i]
[B]Robe is right!!
After what I can see you put bob Rock on the bottom
I'm afraid i have to disagree with your list except S&M on the top [/B][/QUOTE]

Fair enough every1 has different tastes
Out of intrest what way round would you put it

Sorry...but Metallica is quite terrible...

Kill 'em All is fast as hell, but in my opinion it's vastly inferior to the rest of their old stuff. A lot of it almost has a melodic punk sound to it, as far as the vocals go. Once Lightning hit that's when Metallica found who they were. They combined speed with a seriousness and intensity that wasn't to be seen on Kill 'em All.

[QUOTE][i]Originally posted by kirk_wylde [/i]
[B]Their In order (best to worst) IMO are
S&M
Ride the lightning
Master of puppets
Kill 'em all
Garage inc.
REload
Load
St. anger
..And justice for all
Black album

There are a couple of brilliant songs on black album but Some I just don't like at all [/B][/QUOTE]

Why is Justice so low?

^ That one has to grow on you... for me anyway. And Justice at first was awful to me. The only song i liked was one. But now i love blackened, one, dyer's eve, To live is to die, and i think that middle section of Freyed Ends of Sanity that surrounds the solo is some of the coolest set of riffs ever.

Today, Metallica sucks. Everything from Kill 'Em All to ..And Justice For All is amazing. The black album is also good, but the times when they were doing their own thing were great.

[QUOTE][i]Originally posted by Ted VanHammett [/i]
[B]^ That one has to grow on you... for me anyway. And Justice at first was awful to me. The only song i liked was one. But now i love blackened, one, dyer's eve, To live is to die, and i think that middle section of Freyed Ends of Sanity that surrounds the solo is some of the coolest set of riffs ever. [/B][/QUOTE]


I agree. And the reason I put justice so low is because I wan't to like it but it hasn't grown on me yet

Please tell me what you think of theese. Any comments (contsructive critisism)

edit 12/12/2003 Just realised I uploaded the wrong file soz

Metallica needs to go back to Flemming Rasmussen

[QUOTE][i]Originally posted by kirk_wylde [/i]
[B]Please tell me what you think of theese. Any comments (contsructive critisism) [/B][/QUOTE]

Its a bit short....

[QUOTE]quote:[/QUOTE]

kirk wylde is an idiot. Justice is an awesome cd, how could u put S&M on top? i dub thee unforgiven. haha

i still dont know what IMO means

forgot to include black on my list a while ago, id put it right after ride.

it means IN MY OPINION......took me a while to get that one aswell.

Justice is an awesome CD indeed.....my list would read.

Kill 'Em All
Ride The Lightning
Master Of Puppets
...And Justice For All
The Black Album
S&M
Garage Inc
Load
Reload
St. Wanker

my list 'o Metallica..
1. Ride the Lightning
2. Master of Puppets
3. S&M
4. Binge & Purge
5. Kill 'Em All
6. Master of Puppets
7. Black Album
8. Load
9. St. Anger
10. Re-Load

I hate that kinda thing..IMO..just flat out SPELL it...hell, when I first heard emo..I thought it was the bird..

My list:

1 Kiill Em All
2. Master Of Puppets
3. AJFA
4. Black Album
5. S & M
6. Ride the Lightning
7. St. Anger
8. Re/Load
9. Load

(Not Counting Garage Inc or Live Sh[i][/i]it)

My list:

1.Master Of Puppets
2.And Justice For All
3.KIll Em' All
4.Ride The Lightning
5.Garage Inc
6.Black Album
7 Re/Load
8.S&M
9.Load
10.St. Anger

Am I the only one who thinks Garage Inc kicks A$$? I know it's just a bunch of covers but it's one awsome cd. And Whys everyone putting s&m so high? It's really not that great people the only songs that sound cool are battery and puppetz.

ONE, best song ever. i lived off of it for 3 months straight probably one of the best songs ever, the music video just made the song even better for me, it brought a new perspective on the song for me.

oh jeeze i posted too late sorry guys

my list:

Master of Puppets
Ride the Lightenling
Kill em' All
. . . And Justice For All
Black
S&M
Load
Reload
St. Anger

bob rock must die.

hey here is my take on the first solo to Fade To Black...

I kinda went a little too heavy on the reverb...and i ****ed up the middle (fast section) at the time when i recorded it. Now I can play it with NO problems!

[url]http://www.digitalsoundplanet.com/Members/000113907_000014069.mp3[/url]

^ No actually the reverb sounds awseome! thats pretty sweet man, what kinda guitar do you have?

Small bump...

My list
1. Master of Puppets
2. Ride the Lightning
3. Kill'em All
4. ... And Justice for all
5. Black
6. St. Anger
7. S&M
8. Re-Load
9. Load

My rating
Load ****
...And Justice for all *****
Black album ******
St. Anger ****
Ride the lightning *****
Reload ****
S&M ******
Master of puppets *****
Kill'em all ****
Note: every record are great in different ways!

[QUOTE][i]Originally posted by chimairaforlife [/i]
[B]Its a bit short.... [/B][/QUOTE]

Firstly Its Just the solo (gonna be short) Seccondly my Mp3 recorder program is shareware and so only allows 40 sec of audio so had to keep it short

[QUOTE][i]Originally posted by chimairaforlife [/i]
[B]Its a bit short.... [/B][/QUOTE]

ah crap I uploaded the wrong one