He is holding something when he's singing the 'you opened my eyes' bit on the oklahoma vid...what is the main verse section? 'so good to see you once again, i thought that you were hiding from me'? I'm not a big fan of that bit...I just love the bit 'So glad to see you i mised you so much'. I'm not a hater the song, it's just in a different league than the classics (push!t, No Quarter, Sober, Parabola)

Your and my idea of the classics vary greatly:

Third Eye, Lateralus, Reflection, Sober, Eulogy, etc.

Ok, last night I downloaded Tool's version of No Quarter. I actually prefer the original at this point. Tool really did make it their own, though. It's just different enough from the original to be cool.

I think Lateralus, Third Eye, and DRT are the best works (if you take it as DRT being one song, like I do).

[QUOTE=Sliptallica]I think Lateralus, Third Eye, and DRT are the best works (if you take it as DRT being one song, like I do).[/QUOTE]

I think those are my favorites as well.


[QUOTE=Dr. Jake Destructo]Ok, last night I downloaded Tool's version of No Quarter. I actually prefer the original at this point. Tool really did make it their own, though. It's just different enough from the original to be cool.[/QUOTE]

I never got in to that song, even though so many people praise it so much. I'm still open to the possibility that it's a great song, I just haven't discovered the glory, I guess.

No quarter is so atmospheric, that's what gets me...and maynards voice varies and is so strong in the song. I like lateralus a load too, reflection and triad bore me slightly :eek: I overlistened eulogy slightly (play count = 112 on itunes, and i used to play it on WMP too) it used to be my favourite but then kinda drifted out. The 4 i mention above and probably lateralus too are the real stand out tracks. Though i do like all of their stuff i'm not putting any of it down, just some is better than others.

The thing I do like about No Quarter better than the Zep version is that Tool seem to have a stronger grasp of dynamics.

Which is displayed in almost every one of their songs, one of their best qualities in my opinion.

:lol: he uses a megaphone in no quarter too...I think

Does he use a real vocal effect on Eulogy, or a megaphone there as well?

refl @ megaphones

[QUOTE=Kage]The thing I do like about No Quarter better than the Zep version is that Tool seem to have a stronger grasp of dynamics.

Which is displayed in almost every one of their songs, one of their best qualities in my opinion.[/QUOTE]

Tool had more range in No Quarter than LZ. That's why I liked the Tool version more.

[QUOTE=ThePatient]You need to get your hands on Salival, Third Eye and Push!t are better on that than the studio versions, IMO.[/QUOTE]
I've heard them before, and my they were magic! The only thing is that i don't ahve enough money to go and try and bid for a salival box set, unless i want to take out of my new bass money. I'm gonna stick with the new bass.

Maynard has either a guitar or bass or the like in Schism too, i've got the vid of them in Radio City and he's got one on him the whole song. I'll look closely at the videos and see what they are.

No Quarter was the best thing on Salival, IMO.

Maynard does play guitar in Triad I believe, or one of the DRT songs, and he says it is used to help him harmonize his vocals. Read it in an interview.

[QUOTE=In Chains 36]No Quarter was the best thing on Salival, IMO.[/QUOTE]
yes but im still not into pu**** live from salival

Yeah, i'm also pretty sure Maynard plays guitar on Triad...he did when i saw them live two yrs. ago.

Maynard does play guitar on schism...

[QUOTE=Darkness Of Greed]Maynard does play guitar on schism...[/QUOTE]
When I saw them live, there was no guitar within twenty feet of him during that song.

I've seen several live videos of Schism and never once did Maynard have a guitar.

Yeah, i don't remember him playing anything during Schism.

He's holding one on the Oklahoma vid.

ok maybe im late with this, maybe its a joke that you guys already all knew or found out about or whatever. So if im late with this dont get mad but is this true? Maynard quiting the band? please tell me this is just a joke

[url]http://www.soundgenerator.com/news/index.cfm?articleid=5266[/url]

theres the article,my friend sent it too me

1000002321424132 poster to come in here with that.

A little late? I think not!

haha ok so it isnt true then right?

Nope. Not true.

thank you god, and Kage your the man

:cool:

[QUOTE=Kage]Nope. Not true.[/QUOTE]

after this post i will change my name and disappear forever...but how do we know its not true. So far ive seen two messages on two websites suggesting the same thing.

[url]http://www.smnnews.com/friendsofsmn.php[/url]

I guess alot of people found Jesus that day then.
:rolleyes:

Pray Hard :lol: :lol: :lol: