People would be too lazy to do it, it would be a good idea though.

[QUOTE=zeppelinfan2k3]So...second idea: Composition Competition? I don't know how many people can record judging from the problems we've had with the forum band, but would there be an interest in trying it out at least?[/QUOTE]
Yeah, Dan's right. Effort in this forum is a rarity

I was thinking of doing another Battle Of The Pop-Punk Bands, but it's kinda early for that I think

Should I do mine then ?

Well see, I like composition myself because I have no band but still can participate. It's too bad effort is so rare, but if I don't come up with something better I might just try it anyways :-/

[QUOTE=Rancid Dan]Should I do mine then ?[/QUOTE]
I'd wait till the top 75 is totally done and listed, since the reviews are still needing to be done and such, but maybe start it in 2-4 weeks, depending on when the list is done. I'm still in preference of a profile over a competition on it though.

The Competition is over now.

The reviews aren't all done yet and the list isn't posted yet. It'd be wrong to shift attention to something new without finishing the other thing.

Ok, sorry.

[QUOTE=Rancid Dan]Yeah, cool.

I was thinking of doing a 'Legends of pop-punk' competition, where you all nominate for the people who you think should be in their and we vote for the most influential and important people in the genre ?
Kinda Like the top 75 albums but obviously not too similair.[/QUOTE]

I tried that before, but it was more of just alist. Everyone's just gonna pick someone from Green Day or Blink-182, so I don't see a point.

Ok, whatever.

[QUOTE=chips88]I tried that before, but it was more of just alist. Everyone's just gonna pick someone from Green Day or Blink-182, so I don't see a point.[/QUOTE]
Well to be honest they have been very influential in the scene. In the same way people list Metallica in metal influences even though they're nowhere near the best at what they did. The bands that make the music mainstream still have tons of influence even if they weren't first, or best at it.

Stupid post:
[url]http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showpost.php?p=7655634&postcount=3[/url]

User Profile:
[url]http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/member.php?u=172976[/url]

[QUOTE=zeppelinfan2k3]Well to be honest they have been very influential in the scene. In the same way people list Metallica in metal influences even though they're nowhere near the best at what they did. The bands that make the music mainstream still have tons of influence even if they weren't first, or best at it.[/QUOTE]

I didn't say that they didn't deserve it, even if I was thinking it, it's just we all know it will be someone from those bands, so why even go through with it?

[QUOTE=chips88]I didn't say that they didn't deserve it, even if I was thinking it, it's just we all know it will be someone from those bands, so why even go through with it?[/QUOTE]
That's why I'm in favor of profiles instead of a competition :)

[QUOTE=zeppelinfan2k3]That's why I'm in favor of profiles instead of a competition :)[/QUOTE]

I was thinking of doing a melodic hardcore profile, but since you ask I was thinking of doing a general jazz profile...

I'm not sure what you guys are talking about, but whatever. My internet access will be limited this week, so I dunno how often I'll be able to come on. Go bug the other mods if you need anything.

If your alive joel close the PPOTM nominations thread, or just let it fade into obscurity either way im fine...

I think he's dead...

i shall close it

/moment of brilliance

Many thanks mr mod

anytime..

I'm done with the NOFX FA. Let me know when you want it posted. :thumb:

haha, is there like a schedule or anything ? If its time for the other one to come down then go for it right away.. i'll give you the benefit of the doubt.

The current one has been up 4 days, leave it up at least a week me thinks.

I was planning on posting it Saturday.

I was just wondering if I should wait longer.

that's fine i guess.. post it saturday and we can keep both up for a day or two

I can wait longer, it's no big deal. I guess it depends on how much discussion Dan's Alk3 one has.

so then anytime from saturday on would be good

Ok.

My Rise Against F.A will be teh secks

/probably wont finish it till next year

My two FA's this month have been ace :cool:

[QUOTE=Rancid Dan]My two FA's this month have been ace :cool:[/QUOTE]

Agreed, but why are the stickied?

[QUOTE=metty16]Agreed, but why are the stickied?[/QUOTE]

So people will see them and so they don't go to the second page.

correct

If a mod could sticky [url=http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showthread.php?p=7728352#post7728352]this[/url], it would be greatly appreciated. :D

Could someone actually put my Alk3 one on the FA page ?

It is...?

Well, it wasn't untill very recently

I put it in as soon as I unstickied it.

Alright... *looks at own shoes* Uhm... *looks at ceiling* ...