[QUOTE=Invicta_Veritas;15651687]Shai Hulud is just about as overrated as Converge. I'm so sick of hearing about those two bands.


Botch is where it's at, but no, all the glory goes to those two large bundle of sticksty bands.[/QUOTE]

How does Shai Hulud get even the shred of credibility and respect Botch does?

Honestly if you're too daft to recognize three huge contributors to the genre you should probably just **** off. I mean, you just said you were sick of hearing about Converge and Shai Hulud in the bloody metalcore thread.

Metalcore from their era is so much better than modern metalcore, let's leave it there.

Like, [I]Until The Day Breathes And The Shadows Flee[/I] is such an undeniably good album, so is [I]Jane Doe[/I], so is [I]The Changing Of Times[/I], etc.

KISS influenced a whole bunch of black metal bands. Influential =/= Good.

/argument

Oh my God, old A Life Once Lost. Why do we never discuss old ALOL?

[I]Open Your Mouth For The Speechless, In Case Of Those Appointed To Die[/I] > everything mentioned recently. Well not really, but I forgot how good this album is.

I personally enjoy and respect GNR.

///end arguement.

Tyler: Since when did I not recognize the main contributors to the genre? I was being half humourous about Converge getting more respect than Botch and you flipped out...:confused:

Matt: I never had the motivation to check out ALOL...any good?

I definitely didn't flip out, don't worry.

itt: Matt x 3

[quote=NemesisDivina;15651785]itt: Matt x 3[/quote]

Hey, it rhymes.

The past three albums ALOL has done are terrible, [I]Open Your Mouth For The Speechless, In Case Of Those Appointed To Die[/I] and [I]The Fourth Plague: Flies[/I] are amazing though.

I shall check them out sometime....

In this thread Matt times three.

I fail to see the rhyming scheme...

eye tee tee, matt times three

:lol: Oh, right.

Is [I]His Hero Is Gone[/I] any good?

His Hero Is Gone is great, but not really metalcore.

Whoops, my bad. I guess that's what I get for not researching the topic first.

All That Remains anyone?

No, go away.

no, you go away

I'm not the one bringing up **** bands

Since when is ATRs a $hit band?

Shut the f[size=2]u[/size]ck up HBP.

All That Remains owns half the crap that's out there.

You are all too convincing, Bra.

I know.

ATR is boring.

You're from Europe; what do you know? :p

[QUOTE=Sethcanes;15653644]ATR is boring.[/QUOTE]

This

Listen I like metalcore, some of it, but fact is alot of it sounds pretty much alike eachother, ATR have done some decent songs, but they're boring because they don't exactly have anything that sets them apart from the rest of the metalcore scene.

And who else sounds like ATR? Tell me please?

[quote]but fact is alot of it sounds pretty much alike eachother[/quote]

yeah i don't see this happening much in other genres. Sethcanes is legit

Are you asking for bands that have screamed verses and sung choruses with some melodic guitar parts?

And I'm not saying I don't like it, I just find it quite boring.

Oh my God, old A Life Once Lost. Why do we never discuss old ALOL?

[I]Open Your Mouth For The Speechless, In Case Of Those Appointed To Die[/I] > everything mentioned recently. Well not really, but I forgot how good this album is.

Dude, I was just giving you ****.


All That Remains set themselves apart for me for several reasons. First, Phil shows far better lyrical talent and depth than any other band in the scene. Second, he has a killer vocal range. Listen closely to the songs on The Fall of Ideals, the underlying growls are poorly mixed but are there and very low.

Also, They are extremely talented musicians. Oli and Matt are extremely talented guitarists, and it shows.

Simply because they have the typical song structures doesn't mean anything.

But I still find them boring. But I do agree with most of what you said.



But still

Boring...

Oh my God, old A Life Once Lost. Why do we never discuss old ALOL?

Open Your Mouth For The Speechless, In Case Of Those Appointed To Die > everything mentioned recently. Well not really, but I forgot how good this album is.

I haven't listened that much to ALOL, liked what I've heard of them so far though (Vulture)

Their old stuff is loads better, but on the re-release of [I]Open Your Mouth For The Speechless, In Case Of Those Appointed To Die/The Fourth Plague: Flies[/I] it says A LIFE ONCE LOST REFUSES TO PLAY THESE SONGS LIVE. :sad:

[url]http://www.fileden.com/files/2007/7/9/1252962/03%20-%20the%20dead%20sea.m4a[/url]

Why won't they play them live?

I ALOL was mediocre when I had to see them.

That's why I'm saying old ALOL silly.
[QUOTE=Sethcanes;15653732]Why won't they play them live?[/QUOTE]

Because they're sellout [FONT="Verdana"]fag[/FONT]gots.

Oh I see