Anyone here every watch the movie "The Pink Floyd and Syd Barrett Story?"

[QUOTE=DeusExMachina]Is there an official video of the WYWH tour? I would kill to get hold of that.[/QUOTE]
Yea but only for Have a Cigar
cause Shine on and Wish you were here have been remade on two official live albums which have video footage
Animals has never been remade..

KingofDudes: another one?!?! awesome! cant get enough of those pigs solos

Obi one: no problem, i just had to share this wonderful bootleg that every floyd fan MUST have with you guys

[QUOTE=Scooch86]Anyone here every watch the movie "The Pink Floyd and Syd Barrett Story?"[/QUOTE]

yeah, i liked it.

Haven't seen it. But I'd like to.

[QUOTE=WheepingGuitar39]here is the live version of pigs that I have
[url]http://s41.yousendit.com/d.aspx?id=042XXFQG080402DL89V2AS3C9W[/url][/QUOTE]


ehh i didn't like the vocals so much on that live track.

HEY guys i would like to say something , dont you think that A momentary lapse of reason and The division bell are pink floyds best albums. NO , i dont hate roger i really apreciate him but i think that those are the best albums . what do you think?.

[QUOTE=zetabossio]HEY guys i would like to say something , dont you think that A momentary lapse of reason and The division bell are pink floyds best albums. NO , i dont hate roger i really apreciate him but i think that those are the best albums . what do you think?.[/QUOTE]

Umm... I haven't heard enough of Division Bell to make judgements, but I think many of the other albums are far superior.

[QUOTE=zetabossio]HEY guys i would like to say something , dont you think that A momentary lapse of reason and The division bell are pink floyds best albums. NO , i dont hate roger i really apreciate him but i think that those are the best albums . what do you think?.[/QUOTE]

I think otherwise.

Has anyone ever been to the laser show? I went in April and it was amazing. The glasses they give you make it 10x better. Plus they play Wizard of Oz behind all the lasers and smoke. I'm not sure if it was exactly synced up to the music though, I was too overwhelmed. Anyone else ever been?

[QUOTE=zetabossio]HEY guys i would like to say something , dont you think that A momentary lapse of reason and The division bell are pink floyds best albums. NO , i dont hate roger i really apreciate him but i think that those are the best albums . what do you think?.[/QUOTE]
I think you're insane but people say the same thing about me when I say Syd Barrett era Floyd is better than Roger Waters era Pink Floyd. I don't enjoy Gilmour's era Floyd at all.

Syd > Roger > David (era Floyd)

[QUOTE=Schyma]I think you're insane but people say the same thing about me when I say Syd Barrett era Floyd is better than Roger Waters era Pink Floyd. I don't enjoy Gilmour's era Floyd at all.

Syd > Roger > David (era Floyd)[/QUOTE]

Isn't Gilmour's era basically everything Floyd did except for PATGOD and The Final Cut?

I think by Gilmour's era he means MLoR and The Dvision Bell, and Roger's era is Saucerful to the Final Cut, I could be wrong though.

Even though I prefer Gilmour to Waters, the era that Waters fronted the band was definitely their pinnacle greatness.

[QUOTE=thunderzstruck]ehh i didn't like the vocals so much on that live track.[/QUOTE]
meh
gilmour's solo pays up for it

[QUOTE=Lunch]I think by Gilmour's era he means MLoR and The Dvision Bell, and Roger's era is Saucerful to the Final Cut, I could be wrong though.[/QUOTE]

That makes more sense.

[QUOTE=Lunch]I think by Gilmour's era he means MLoR and The Dvision Bell, and Roger's era is Saucerful to the Final Cut, I could be wrong though.[/QUOTE]
I think Animals - The final Cut is Rogers era. Saucerful - WYWH was a team effort in my opinion.

I'd agree with you, I was just interpretting what I thought Schyma meant.

[QUOTE=Lunch]I'd agree with you, I was just interpretting what I thought Schyma meant.[/QUOTE]

Ahhh, I see now.


edit: pigs is coming

[QUOTE=Kingofdudes]I think Animals - The final Cut is Rogers era. Saucerful - WYWH was a team effort in my opinion.[/QUOTE]
thats for sure
i mean
just to give an example, One of these days... Time... they have all 4 members credits
you dont see that often on Animals through Final Cut

hxxp://s48.yousendit.com/d.aspx?id=2ZJFZJSBR640C3V2MAEF6B892S
Pigs(3different ones)
Animals Tour, Montreal, July 6th, 1977

[QUOTE=Kingofdudes]hxxp://s48.yousendit.com/d.aspx?id=2ZJFZJSBR640C3V2MAEF6B892S
Pigs(3different ones)
Animals Tour, Montreal, July 6th, 1977[/QUOTE]
WOAAAAAAAAAAAAH
that is the one where Roger spits on the fan, its during that song
you found on hell of a treasure
thank you for this amazing amazing amazing bootleg
now i shall listen to this

[QUOTE=Kingofdudes]I think Animals - The final Cut is Rogers era. Saucerful - WYWH was a team effort in my opinion.[/QUOTE]
Agreed. Much more of a team effort. Except, even then it was mostly Waters and Gilmour.

Also agreed with Gilmour. After WYWH, Waters just slowly took over until he was basically in tota. control on The Final Cut.

[QUOTE=Kingofdudes]I think Animals - The final Cut is Rogers era. Saucerful - WYWH was a team effort in my opinion.[/QUOTE]
That would make more sense but I still consider it to be Roger's era of the Floyd. After Final Cut is where David's era began.

I never payed attention to "David`s Era"...

Got to admit, Floyd , the the Final Cut... that`s when we cut the cord.

Although, I`d give a hell of alot to see that band without Waters anyway.

Never got to see any of them :confused:

[QUOTE=Nektar]I never payed attention to "David`s Era"...

Got to admit, Floyd , the the Final Cut... that`s when we cut the cord.

Although, I`d give a hell of alot to see that band without Waters anyway.

Never got to see any of them :confused:[/QUOTE]
Welcome to the forums. Personally, AMLOR and The Division Bell were quite a bit better than the Final Cut, especially The Division Bell.

Sorry magicbus, ill have to wait till tomorrow to upload the song.

[QUOTE=Schyma]I think you're insane but people say the same thing about me when I say Syd Barrett era Floyd is better than Roger Waters era Pink Floyd. I don't enjoy Gilmour's era Floyd at all.

Syd > Roger > David (era Floyd)[/QUOTE]

im not saying that i think the pink floyds best songs are :wywh , confurtubly numb , heave a cigar , hey you , when roger share the composition with david , but the albums (complete) are better AMLOR , and the division bell.
Can you tell me a song that you dont like from those albums?

[QUOTE=Kingofdudes]I think Animals - The final Cut is Rogers era. Saucerful - WYWH was a team effort in my opinion.[/QUOTE]

why not The dark side too i thnik that is a team effort too. "if we all pull together as a team"

[QUOTE=Kingofdudes]I think Animals - The final Cut is Rogers era. Saucerful - WYWH was a team effort in my opinion.[/QUOTE]

I actually think the Waters era was just The Wall and The Final Cut. Waters only entirerly wrote Pigs on the Wing (parts I and II.) All the other songs were written by all of them. I guess Waters must have written all the lyrics, though.

the song Sorrow from AMLOR is AMAZING
it's a masterpiece and one of my favorite songs.
actually im listening to it right now.
There are other good songs too on AMLOR

[QUOTE=Obi One Kenodi]I actually think the Waters era was just The Wall and The Final Cut. Waters only entirerly wrote Pigs on the Wing (parts I and II.) All the other songs were written by all of them. I guess Waters must have written all the lyrics, though.[/QUOTE]
In the credits, it says Waters wrote everything entirely except for Dogs, which was a dual effort with him and Gilmour.

Zetabossio, Dark Side was written after Saucerful of Secrets and before WYWH, so that would put it in the teamwork period.

[QUOTE=zetabossio]why not The dark side too i thnik that is a team effort too. "if we all pull together as a team"[/QUOTE]
i did include that in the "team effort" category.

Have a Cigar isnt on DSotM

[QUOTE=WheepingGuitar39]the song Sorrow from AMLOR is AMAZING
it's a masterpiece and one of my favorite songs.
actually im listening to it right now.
There are other good songs too on AMLOR[/QUOTE]
I like it much more on Pulse

[QUOTE=Kingofdudes]i did include that in the "team effort" category.

Have a Cigar isnt on DSotM


I like it much more on Pulse[/QUOTE]
Yea i watch the pulse video of sorrow atleast 5 times a day.

You have a pulse video? Dude, give the hook up!

I have the whole Pulse video
but it's 1.3 Gigabytes :lol:
I could try to find a place to try and upload it
yousendit? maybe
or you can download it off of Bearshare / Limewire



edit:****.. it's up to 1gig.. let me try and see if i could compress it somehow to atleast 1gigabyte

edit2:
ok so i managed to compress it.. it took 10 mins..
from 1.3 gigs to 1.28 gigs

if you could, that would be unbelievably awesome. But, if it's going to be a hassle, don't worry about it, I can always wait for the DVD.

[QUOTE=DeusExMachina]if you could, that would be unbelievably awesome. But, if it's going to be a hassle, don't worry about it, I can always wait for the DVD.[/QUOTE]
ill find a way to put it up
no.. you cant wait for the dvd
which btw has been postpoened again to "early next year"

You rock.

Yeah, I know the DVD will never come out. That was my subtle little hint that you should upload it.

Anyone read the book Nick Mason wrote?

Any good?