[QUOTE=SLY_GUY]Why's a Vs thread "against the rules"? It's a worthy debate, and I just asked for opinions, not for the Forum Nazis.... but thanks anyway kids. You'd think that in a Musician Forum, you'd be free to discuss anything about musicians... doesn't setting really strict rules go AGAINST the whole foundation of music?! How can regulate what you can and can't talk about when it comes to music? This is the worst forum I've EVER been on. If Axl Rose read this, he'd be impressed. James Hetfield on the other hand would call you all fags.

So i AGAIN ask the Mods to re-open this thread, or at least for there opinions, I gave my e-mail, so if this thread just simply CAN NOT be re-opened, I urge people to give me there oppinions.

the last thing I want to do is go onto the metallica thread and say that "guns and roses rocks!" ,or go onto the guns and roses thread and say that "metallica rocks!", just to get people's responces as to why they think differently.

I believe that a VS thread SHOULD be allowed, and would like to know why it isnt!

that is all.[/QUOTE]


Because people do it in a mindless fashion for the most part, and also compare or pit bands together that are not even comparable. And also it's all opinion, and fanboy's of the bands will come in and start a flame fest out of the thread. To many subjective opinions + fanboys + vs thread = flame fest and spam.

[QUOTE=SLY_GUY]
I believe that a VS thread SHOULD be allowed, and would like to know why it isnt!
[/QUOTE]

How long have you been here?

[QUOTE=SLY_GUY]Why's a Vs thread "against the rules"? It's a worthy debate, and I just asked for opinions, not for the Forum Nazis.... but thanks anyway kids. You'd think that in a Musician Forum, you'd be free to discuss anything about musicians... doesn't setting really strict rules go AGAINST the whole foundation of music?! How can regulate what you can and can't talk about when it comes to music? This is the worst forum I've EVER been on. If Axl Rose read this, he'd be impressed. James Hetfield on the other hand would call you all fags.

So i AGAIN ask the Mods to re-open this thread, or at least for there opinions, I gave my e-mail, so if this thread just simply CAN NOT be re-opened, I urge people to give me there oppinions.

the last thing I want to do is go onto the metallica thread and say that "guns and roses rocks!" ,or go onto the guns and roses thread and say that "metallica rocks!", just to get people's responces as to why they think differently.

I believe that a VS thread SHOULD be allowed, and would like to know why it isnt!

that is all.[/QUOTE]
Correct me if I'm wrong, but I believe the mods will alow you to make a verses thread if you put some thought into it, and the bands/artists are actually comparable. I agree that great disscusion can be made from these threads, but they are always ruined by idiots. We would get a few people actually dissucsing and giving reasons for why they prefer a band, but we would also get "omg u idiot band x is sooooo much better ten band y bany sux teh big 1!!!!1". The majority of these threads are also extreamly over done (ex:Metallica vs. Megadeth) I see your point, but the threads are ruined by idiots.

but these two bands ARE comarable, so simmilar, that this is a really good debate!

and I've been here for just over a day, so maybe I'm too 'new' to understand your crazy rules. (but you would have known that had you read my first post that is on page 161)

I apreciate you spelling it out for me in english EDDIE VAN HALEN 769

[QUOTE=EddieVanHalen769]Correct me if I'm wrong, but I believe the mods will alow you to make a verses thread if you put some thought into it, and the bands/artists are actually comparable. I agree that great disscusion can be made from these threads, but they are always ruined by idiots. We would get a few people actually dissucsing and giving reasons for why they prefer a band, but we would also get "omg u idiot band x is sooooo much better ten band y bany sux teh big 1!!!!1". The majority of these threads are also extreamly over done (ex:Metallica vs. Megadeth) I see your point, but the threads are ruined by idiots.[/QUOTE]


Werd, he covered the rest of it.

And also, if you don't like this forum or the rules, please leave. There are plenty of people here happy with the forums and the rules, and we don't need some new person coming in here and making a big deal out of the rules that doesn't understand how this forum works or its history of problems that are the reason those rules were created.

Ok, quick question. How come when somebody is banned, you cannot rep that person? I just read that "New Megadeth" thread about the best guitarists, and I REALLY wanna neg rep him. Not that my rep will have much effect, but I mean, that was just dumb.

[QUOTE=SLY_GUY]
and I've been here for just over a day, so maybe I'm too 'new' to understand your crazy rules. (but you would have known that had you read my first post that is on page 161)[/QUOTE]

Yes, I know, I did read your other post. I was making a point.

Page after page of vs threads gets annoying, especially after months of them. There are reasons for the rules here, and the basic idea is that rather than starting the 8,000th awful, overdone vs thread, you become a member of the community, and learn people's opinions of various subjects and bands through discussion in other threads. If you want a quickfire, "I WANT MY VS DONE AND YOU'RE ALL FAGS IF YOU DON'T LET ME" thread, to get context-less, shallow responses, go to a different music forum and leave this one alone.

Oh, and for the thing on your post on page 161, Guns N' Roses and Metallica are not comparable. They are not even in the same genre of music and you want to compare them?


[url]http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showpost.php?p=6445067&postcount=90[/url]

This guy deserves a nice ban slapping.

Okay, he's gone for a couple of days.

ok, thanks for the help....NOT!

i understand that they are slightly different, but what i wanted was oppinions on why, and some really thought out reasons responces

anyways you have my e-mail, please toss me a line

later all

that is all.

[QUOTE=SLY_GUY]ok, thanks for the help....NOT!

i understand that they are slightly different, but what i wanted was oppinions on why, and some really thought out reasons responces

anyways you have my e-mail, please toss me a line

later all

that is all.[/QUOTE]


Seriously, shut the fu[SIZE=2]ck[/SIZE] up. You know nothing about this forum, yet you come in here complaining about it, god da[SIZE=2]mn[/SIZE] you are just like a little 12 year old that cries when they don't get it their way.

And slightly different? Metallica is thrash metal for the majority of their releases, and GNR's is freakin' hardrock, how can you compare those two? There is no opinion's on why they play different, it is a fact of life of what type of music they play.

[QUOTE=SLY_GUY]ok, thanks for the help....NOT!

i understand that they are slightly different, but what i wanted was oppinions on why, and some really thought out reasons responces

anyways you have my e-mail, please toss me a line

later all

that is all.[/QUOTE]
Seriously, you're not off to a good start. Why don't you just join the disscusion going on in the threads now?

[url]http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showthread.php?t=295966[/url]

Posting the lemon party link...GG


[url]http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showthread.php?t=295961[/url]

Advertisement.

Thanks. Which one is **********? And I'd rather not just click to find out :)

He linked to it wrongly, anyway. Would have just brought up an error page.

It's the one with the 3 old men...

And ya, that is true, would have just brought up an error message. But some one could just copy and paste the link into the browser, and there is probably kids and such on this site as well...

Well yeah, it's no excuse. Just pointing out idiocy as I see it.

[url]http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showthread.php?t=296052[/url]

Favorite thread.

[url]http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showthread.php?t=204731[/url]

Bumped from around July.

[url]http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showthread.php?t=296195[/url]

Thread about hot topic

[url]http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showthread.php?p=6454309#post6454309[/url]
This guy has revived three or four old threads now. (and what he posts isn't even relevant sometimes.)

Got him.

how can you make a featured artist page

To do a featured artist you need to contact Med57.

[url]http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showthread.php?t=292718[/url]

why is this still open

Because I'm doing a Forced Listening.

[url]http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showthread.php?t=296266[/url]

ill leave it to the mercy of the mods

[url]http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showthread.php?t=296274[/url]

ads

[url]http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showthread.php?t=291983[/url]

jam session topics keep popping up here!

[url]http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showthread.php?t=295213[/url]

It's been going on too long. Should have been closed in the first place but I can see why you guys left it open.