Hard to say. Benefit is more straight forward in terms of rock and probably easier to get into because of that. Stand Up incorporates more genres and styles into the songs and probably takes a few listens to get into. I'd probably recommend Benefit first.

[QUOTE=Mister Blue Sky]Wow, why?[/QUOTE]

Because I've already sold my soul to rock 'n' roll.

[QUOTE=Krabsworth]How does everyone like the new username? Huh? Huh? :naughty:[/QUOTE]

You can change names? How?

[QUOTE=Fagsworth roflmao (jk)]Because I've already sold my soul to rock 'n' roll.[/QUOTE]

Yeah, I'd also reccomend Benefit.

[QUOTE=Obi Two Cannoli]You can change names? How?[/QUOTE]

By requesting a name change in Jim's name change thread in the site forum.

[QUOTE=magicbus]Ok, the next Tull album I'll get will be [I]Thick As a Brick[/I]. After that, would you guys say [I]Stand Up[/I] or [I]Benefit[/I] is better?[/QUOTE]

What's the deal with Thick as A Brick? From one article I read they made it seem like it was just the Song TAAB and it took up the whole album :confused:

[QUOTE=TheDMV]What's the deal with Thick as A Brick? From one article I read they made it seem like it was just the Song TAAB and it took up the whole album :confused:[/QUOTE]

It is just one 45 minute song.

Amazing song, good concept( even though it wasnt a serious concept) i prefer Stand Up, just because i like that type of Tull more, i dont know if you have A Passion Play, if you dont get that after TAAB

[QUOTE=magicbus]Ok, the next Tull album I'll get will be [I]Thick As a Brick[/I]. After that, would you guys say [I]Stand Up[/I] or [I]Benefit[/I] is better?[/QUOTE]

Benefit is really good...Son, WIth You There to Help Me, and of course Teacher are all really good....

[I]Benefit[/I] for sure, it has Teacher.

/constructive post.

Still waitin' for some Strawberry Alarm Clock.

[url]http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showpost.php?p=10663894&postcount=68[/url]

Read the middle part. What a jack-[I]a[/I]ss

[QUOTE=Led-Zeppelin]Still waitin' for some Strawberry Alarm Clock.[/QUOTE]

I don't think anyone can help you out, freeloader.

[url]http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showthread.php?t=421111[/url]

OMG TOMMY THRED READ NOW

It's long, and it took me a while to write and it'd be nice if someone would read it.

Anyone want The Yardbirds Greatest Hits Volume 1? I know it is a greatest hits, but the songs are all very good, and there is 18 of them.

[QUOTE=Mister Blue Sky][url]http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showthread.php?t=421111[/url]

OMG TOMMY THRED READ NOW

It's long, and it took me a while to write and it'd be nice if someone would read it.[/QUOTE]

Nice I'll read it now. I really like Stand Up but I don't have Benefit so I can't compare them.

Brought back my old Lennon avatar for the week.

Thanks for the rep Lunch.

[QUOTE]Brought back my old Lennon avatar for the week.[/QUOTE]
Heh, I though it looked like Chris Robinson for The Black Crowes.

I prefer Stand Up over Benefit and plus, it has Bouree.



[SIZE="7"][COLOR="DarkOrange"]BIG BIG NEWS:[/COLOR][/SIZE]

[B][SIZE="3"]I JUST HEARD ON THE RADIO THAT DAVID GILMOUR IS CURRENTLY WORKING ON A NEW SOLO ALBUM DUE OUT NEXT YEAR. RICK WRIGHT AND DAVID CROSBY, AS WELL AS THE GUITARIST FROM ROXY MUSIC WILL HAVE APPEARANCES ON IT.[/SIZE][/B]

[QUOTE=jpj][SIZE="7"][COLOR="DarkOrange"]BIG BIG NEWS:[/COLOR][/SIZE]

[B][SIZE="3"]I JUST HEARD ON THE RADIO THAT DAVID GILMOUR IS CURRENTLY WORKING ON A NEW SOLO ALBUM DUE OUT NEXT YEAR. RICK WRIGHT AND DAVID CROSBY, AS WELL AS THE GUITARIST FROM ROXY MUSIC WILL HAVE APPEARANCES ON IT.[/SIZE][/B][/QUOTE]

:eek:

/wets pants in anticipation

That is hardly any news...to me.

[QUOTE=Badmoon]That is hardly any news...to me.[/QUOTE]
Well, that's because you're a stupidhead.

[QUOTE=Badmoon]That is hardly any news...to me.[/QUOTE]

Shut up, hippie.









:p

Well I don't have Badmoon's connections so it's news to me. I have heard rumors that he will tour in 2006 though, so a new album would make sense. I hope he tours, I'd love to see him live.

np- Phish- The Moma Dance

[QUOTE]Well I don't have Badmoon's connections so it's news to me.[/QUOTE]

No, it's not that it's old news. I just don't really care. :p

[QUOTE=Badmoon]No, it's not that it's old news. I just don't really care. :p[/QUOTE]

Oh I see how it is:p

I have Gilmour's first solo album, and to be honest, I'm a huge Gilmour fan but it's just not very good. Definitely not bad, but it doesn't compare to his Floyd stuff. If the new album is true, I'll definitely buy it but I won't have huge expectations for it. I'm just really excited because it means he'll probably tour. I really, really want to see him live.

np- Van Morrison- Enlightenment

David Gilmour In Concert DVD is excellent.

[QUOTE=jpj][SIZE="7"][COLOR="DarkOrange"]BIG BIG NEWS:[/COLOR][/SIZE]

[B][SIZE="3"]I JUST HEARD ON THE RADIO THAT DAVID GILMOUR IS CURRENTLY WORKING ON A NEW SOLO ALBUM DUE OUT NEXT YEAR. RICK WRIGHT AND DAVID CROSBY, AS WELL AS THE GUITARIST FROM ROXY MUSIC WILL HAVE APPEARANCES ON IT.[/SIZE][/B][/QUOTE]

I heard that today too. His first one in 22 years.

[QUOTE=magicbus]Stop Making Sense is awesome.[/QUOTE]

That very DVD is what got me into the Talking Heads. Once In A Lifetime is my fav by them and its even better on that live DVD.

/puts on Psycho Killer

I prefer Stand Up.

The Gilmour album will probably be a decent album, but disappointing to a lot of Floyd fans because it won't be Floydish at all. That's my prediction. It would be awesome to see him tour though.

I just listened to Love and Theft, I think it's a great album despite his voice being so wrecked.

edit - I would like The Yardbirds album, Krabsworth.

[QUOTE=thickasabrick]I prefer Stand Up.

The Gilmour album will probably be a decent album, but disappointing to a lot of Floyd fans because it won't be Floydish at all. That's my prediction. It would be awesome to see him tour though.

I just listened to Love and Theft, I think it's a great album despite his voice being so wrecked.

edit - I would like The Yardbirds album, Krabsworth.[/QUOTE]
Too bad Gilmour won't tour through Regina. :p

But honestly that's sweet news, I can't wait for the tour!

Oh, shi[size=2]t, my toilet just clogged.[/size]

[QUOTE=thickasabrick]I prefer Stand Up.

The Gilmour album will probably be a decent album, but disappointing to a lot of Floyd fans because it won't be Floydish at all. That's my prediction. It would be awesome to see him tour though.


I just listened to Love and Theft, I think it's a great album despite his voice being so wrecked.

edit - I would like The Yardbirds album, Krabsworth.[/QUOTE]

Email, or AIM?

is Realaudio format alright? If not I'll convert to mp3 tonight and get it to you tomorrow

Yea, they said on the radio that he would do a tour also.

So which one of you guys wants to send me some Talking Heads?

[QUOTE=jpj]Yea, they said on the radio that he would do a tour also.

So which one of you guys wants to send me some Talking Heads?[/QUOTE]

I have The Best Of Talking Heads CD, but I'll send it to you later over IM; as I need to get off the computer for the night....

[QUOTE=jpj]Yea, they said on the radio that he would do a tour also.

So which one of you guys wants to send me some Talking Heads?[/QUOTE]
maybe if you got on aim i would!

[QUOTE]Too bad Gilmour won't tour through Regina. [/QUOTE]

Does matter, me and my friends will go anywhere to see him...what group of potheads would turn down a roadtrip to see a David Gilmour concert? One of my friends actually has a saving fund for plane tickets to see the Pink Floyd reunion tour. And yes, he is aware that there is no reunion tour. He's said he's just playing it safe, just in case there ever is one.

[QUOTE]Email, or AIM?

is Realaudio format alright? If not I'll convert to mp3 tonight and get it to you tomorrow[/QUOTE]

I would prefer email. [email]back_in_black256@hotmail.com[/email] I'm not sure about Realaudio, I don't think I've ever tried using it. If it isn't a hassle converting to mp3, then I wouldn't mind that....but I don't wanna be a drag, especially if Realaudio actually does work. Thanks.

What would be the closest venue? Calgary or Edmonton?

How far would you go?

im not going through the last couple of pages because my CP is running really slow, so if this has been said today, sorry

but i just relized its the 17th anniversary of Roy Orbisons death

R.I.P Roy :(

Oh noes. Roy. R.I.P, one of my favorite singers.

[QUOTE=Livewired]What would be the closest venue? Calgary or Edmonton?

How far would you go?[/QUOTE]Calgary, hopefully.. Yeah right. I doubt he'd even tour here.

R.I.P. Roy :(

Ok, I'll need some e-mail adresses now because I'm uploading The Queen Is Dead, so anyone who wants it post their's now.

[QUOTE=Livewired]Too bad Gilmour won't tour through Regina. :p

But honestly that's sweet news, I can't wait for the tour![/QUOTE]

I know a kid you used to live in Regina. And we make fun of him, becuase, well, the word Regina is funny.

Regardless, i've never been to much of a Floyd fan, but i'm greatly anticipating a David Gilmour solo album, seeing as he's one of my favs on the guitar.