[QUOTE=EightMilesHigh]Out of curiousity, does anyone here listen to any ska? I've recently discovered ska and I'm addicted.[/QUOTE]
Oh, oh! Pick me, I love ska I just bought like 4 used Fishbone albums for like 2 dollars awhile ago but haven't got a chance to give them a good listen. But my favorite ska and is by far Might Mighty Bosstones but followed by Aquabats I like the more up-tempo ska... (All ska is up-tempo :S)

[QUOTE=robo2448]Didn't Lunch upload Fresh Cream like last week though?[/QUOTE]

Yeah I've had it on my computer for a while, but I'm gonna buy it next.

David Gilmour is cool. He's such a good guitarist and I like his vocals on "Shine On You Crazy Diamond" better than Roger's.

NP: Fat Old Sun - David Gilmour in Concert

he's a much better singer than waters. waters shouldnt even be in the vocalists comp.

[QUOTE=PinkFreud]he's a much better singer than waters. waters shouldnt even be in the vocalists comp.[/QUOTE]

Yeah, what the hell is up with that?

I often have trouble telling them apart, but I'm not a huge Pink Floyd fan.

im assuming that a lot of people are retarded and think he sang for most of pink floyd's songs. it could also be a matter of taste, but his voice is so thin and weak and one dimensional and lame that i dont know how ANYone could enjoy it.

edit: i sounded like a jerk. im sure a lot of people are like illmatic, casual listeners of pink floyd who have a hard time.

no offense meant.

Who sings on Money, and Wish You Were Here? I actually like the vocals on Piper at the Gates of Dawn better, I'm not a big Pink Floyd fan.

[QUOTE=Jacaranda]Who sings on Money, and Wish You Were Here? I actually like the vocals on Piper at the Gates of Dawn better, I'm not a big Pink Floyd fan.[/QUOTE]

Gilmour sings both of those. He sings all the songs on DSOTM.

Waters became the main singer late in the band's career. I actually liked Waters voice, it's so cold and depressing. I like Gilmour's voice much more, but Water's voice really fits well on some of the depressing songs like on The Wall. I reallly love the duets parts on the Wall like Waters sings Pink's part and Gilmour's sings the mother's part in Mother. That's awesome stuff.

[QUOTE]Who sings on Money, and Wish You Were Here? I actually like the vocals on Piper at the Gates of Dawn better, I'm not a big Pink Floyd fan.[/QUOTE]

Gilmour on both. Syd is all PatGoD

[QUOTE=Jacaranda]Who sings on Money, and Wish You Were Here? I actually like the vocals on Piper at the Gates of Dawn better, I'm not a big Pink Floyd fan.[/QUOTE]
I don't think you can compare the two. Both Syd and Gilmour had the perfect voices for the type of music they were playing. "Bike" and "The Gnome" wouldn't be the same without Syd's extremly distinctive(sp?) British vocals. None of [I]Dark Side[/I] era Floyd wouldn't be the same without Gilmour's vocals that sound so slow and calming it's almost trippy. Gilmour's voice is kinda like his guitar playing honestly not that great but with that kind of style how can you not just fall in love with him. I still wouldn't include Gilmour or Barrett in a top 20 of greatest singers though....

I'd include Gilmour, but I'd definitely hesitate to include Barrett.

Sweet. Power outtage in the school=10:30 let out.

:)

[QUOTE=Mister Blue Sky]Gilmour on both. Syd is all PatGoD[/QUOTE]

Waters sings on TW does he not.

[QUOTE=JonG]Sweet. Power outtage in the school=10:30 let out.

:)[/QUOTE]


Awesome. I'm stuck in school until 7:30 for jazz band

NP:Sister Disco

[QUOTE=NightHorse]Waters sings on TW does he not.[/QUOTE]
yeah, he does.

[QUOTE=leppermessiah]I'd include Gilmour, but I'd definitely hesitate to include Barrett.[/QUOTE]
Gilmour would be in my top 20 no question, but Barrett doesn't deserve to be anywhere near a top vocalist list, IMO.

[QUOTE=robo2448]Gilmour sings both of those. He sings all the songs on DSOTM.

Waters became the main singer late in the band's career. I actually liked Waters voice, it's so cold and depressing. I like Gilmour's voice much more, but Water's voice really fits well on some of the depressing songs like on The Wall. I really love the duets parts on the Wall like Waters sings Pink's part and Gilmour's sings the mother's part in Mother. That's awesome stuff.[/QUOTE]

Actually, Waters sings on Brain Damage/Eclipse, as well as time I think, and Wright does vocals on Time (the "tired of lying in the sunshine..." parts) and Us and Them (the reframe.)

I agree, though that the duets on The Wall are awesome. I think I'm the only guy on here who likes Waters more than Gilmour. Sure, Gilmour is more skilled, and his guitar playing second to none, but I love Waters dark depressing, and often cynical sound.

[QUOTE=Obi One Kenodi]Actually, Waters sings on Brain Damage/Eclipse, as well as time I think, and Wright does vocals on Time (the "tired of lying in the sunshine..." parts) and Us and Them (the reframe.)[/QUOTE]
I was just about to say that.


Gilmour+Wright>Gilmour

I really like Wright's voice, it's very mellow. Did he sing on anything else?

Everyone go check out my write up on Gregg Allman in YDload's thread.

[QUOTE=jpj]I really like Wright's voice, it's very mellow. Did he sing on anything else?

Everyone go check out my write up on Gregg Allman in YDload's thread.[/QUOTE]

He sang on a few songs on Saucerful of Secrets and Obscured By Clouds. He also did a lot of harmonies with Gilmour on Meddle and DSOTM.

[url]http://www.pinkfloydfan.net/pink_floyd_discography.php[/url]

That has the a list of the studio albums and who sang on each.

[QUOTE=jpj]I really like Wright's voice, it's very mellow. Did he sing on anything else?

Everyone go check out my write up on Gregg Allman in YDload's thread.[/QUOTE]

I thought the write up was great, one of the most informative. Mind telling me your thoughts on my Waters one?

[QUOTE=Obi One Kenodi]I thought the write up was great, one of the most informative. Mind telling me your thoughts on my Waters one?[/QUOTE]
Thanks, I worked on it from about the time I got home from school until whenever it was I posted on it (little over a half hour I guess).

I'll go read yours now.

EDIT: Yours was good, brief and to the point. I was afraid mine was gonna come out too wordy. I also like how you started by calling him an arrogant prick. Both attention grabbing and 100% true.

I'm doing a Neil Young one now.

/:cool:

/probably won't be that good

EDIT-I still havent started, maybe later tonight

[quote] EDIT: Yours was good, brief and to the point. I was afraid mine was gonna come out too wordy. I also like how you started by calling him an arrogant prick. Both attention grabbing and 100% true.[/quote]

Thanks. :)

[QUOTE=jpj]Gilmour would be in my top 20 no question, but Barrett doesn't deserve to be anywhere near a top vocalist list, IMO.[/QUOTE]
I agree about Barrett but he's not by any means a bad singer as for Gilmour he's a good singer but he isn't great.

Great job on doing Waters, Obi One.[QUOTE]Everyone go check out my write up on Gregg Allman in YDload's thread.[/QUOTE]He put alot of the Southern taste into the Allman Brothers. Great singer, great job. :thumb:

I just got finished listining to [I]Eat a Peach [/I]which could quite possibly be the greatest album to come out of the 70's.

[QUOTE=Schyma]Great job on doing Waters, Obi One.He put alot of the Southern taste into the Allman Brothers. Great singer, great job. :thumb:[/QUOTE]
Thanks :)

[QUOTE]I just got finished listining to [I]Eat a Peach[/I]which could quite possibly be the greatest album to come out of the 70's.[/QUOTE]
As stated many times before, my favorite album of all time...ever.

Over the past month it's reached into my top five favorite albums and it gets better and better with each listin.

Can anyone please hook me up with [I]Live at Fillmore East[/I]?

I did John Fogerty :cool:

CCR is such a fun band to listen to.

In other news, Simon and Garfunkel's Greatest Hits is like perfect. I can't find one song from it that isn't awesome.

I think I like [I]Live at the Fillmore East[/I] better than [I]Eat a Peach[/I].

I dont know though.

i love simon and garfunkel.

april, come she will is like, the prettiest song ever made by jewish men.

Nah, Eat a Peach > Live at the Fillmore East, most definitely.

I hate it when I'm not entiltled to my own opinion. :(

[QUOTE=Livewired]I hate it when I'm not entiltled to my own opinion. :([/QUOTE]
I figured that you'd be used to it by now, you being Canadian and all.

[QUOTE=robo2448]I did John Fogerty :cool:

CCR is such a fun band to listen to.
[/QUOTE]

I thought your one on Fogerty was good. Jacaranda did a good job, too.

Spencer call me. (justin)

[QUOTE=robo2448]In other news, Simon and Garfunkel's Greatest Hits is like perfect. I can't find one song from it that isn't awesome.[/QUOTE]

Simon & Garfunkel are like totally awesome.

[QUOTE=Schyma]Spencer call me. (justin)[/QUOTE]
How in the hell do you know my password for this?!!?

Edit: Your phone isn't working by the way.

Schyma, I was at hunters and you were signed on so it was just easier. But seriouslly, get on AIM or call me.

Schyma, I was at hunters and you were signed on so it was just easier. But seriouslly, get on AIM or call me.