[QUOTE=heavy metal kid]Umm, it's crappy because they are covers.

But they are the best covers made, it's kind of hard making an MF medley without killing it.[/QUOTE]

I'm quite aware it's covers. I still think the first CD is worthless, regardless.

Nobody should ever try cover Mercyful Fate, aside from maybe Priest.

[QUOTE=ThrashMaster27]Garage Inc is pretty crap if you ask me. The 2nd CD is the only one worth owning and it was horribly overpriced.

Currently the only Metallica album I don't own is Re-Load and that's because I lost it ages ago. I also have Kill 'Em All and Ride The Lightning on Vinyl.[/QUOTE]

There was a vinyl set that Metallica put together, only 5,000 made, and my friend could have gotten one. They're on eBay now. I want one badly. It's got I think the first 5 albums in it.

It's horribly overpriced, yes, but it's probably their best album since the Black album.

[QUOTE]Anyone want me to upload my very own version of Of Wolf And Man?[/QUOTE]

Yes

and PepsiMetal, that'd be great

[QUOTE=ThrashMaster27]
Nobody should ever try cover Mercyful Fate, aside from maybe Priest.[/QUOTE]
But still Metallica tried and got a B-:p

[QUOTE=ThrashMaster27]I'm quite aware it's covers. I still think the first CD is worthless, regardless.

Nobody should ever try cover Mercyful Fate, aside from maybe Priest.[/QUOTE]

Hey yo, chico.

[QUOTE=heavy metal kid]But still Metallica tried and got a B-:p[/QUOTE]

I'd give it a D- cause Hetfield doesn't scream during Curse of the Pharoahs. He just does that daft voice.

[QUOTE=vashts80]Hey yo, chico.[/QUOTE]

I'm gone carve...you...up mang!

[QUOTE=ThrashMaster27]I'd give it a D- cause Hetfield doesn't scream during Curse of the Pharoahs. He just does that daft voice.
[/QUOTE]

Fair enough.

I don't know, disc one is far away from disc two in musical styles.

Free Speech for the dumb is weird, but it is as good as the original.
Turn the Page was actually better than the original.
The Sabbath medley was 50-50.
It's Electric was crap.
Loverman is better than the original.
MF it's a challenge and they still made it.
Astronomy was great.
Whiskey in the Jar was great.
Tuesdays gone is 50-50.
The More I See is 50-50.

I think most people dislike disc one because it sounds softer than disc two, but come on the Mercyful Fate Medley was awesome(vocals were...meh), they still have the thrash in their blood, damn money.

Reason it's different musically is cause the first CD was new recordings, the second wasn't. You probably already know that anyway, plus it's easy to tell.

The instruments are spot on in the Mercyful Fate medley, aside from the drums being a bit odd. The only problem I have with it is indeed Hetfields vocals.

I really enjoyed both cd's of Gragage inc. I don't care if the songs don't sound as good as the originals might of, but I loved the Mercyful Fate medley, Astronomy, Turn The Page among many, many others.

There were a lot of songs on the second disc I didn't care for at all, not in the slightest bit. I thought there were only a select few alright songs on the 2nd disc. I still don't like the song "So What".

Turn The Page is such a great song, I love both the original and Metallica's version.

Who's the original by?

[QUOTE=blue3]Who's the original by?[/QUOTE]

Bob Seger.

Google lyrics says Bob Seger, but maybe his is cover too.

EDIT: Grr, beat. lol

[QUOTE=blue3]Who's the original by?[/QUOTE]

Bob Seger

Well, thanks for the all the answers.

whiskey in the jar and turn the page are excellent.
i really liked the guitar james used on s&m.think was an esp.

I love Kirk's bit in Turn The Page, it's so beautiful.

[QUOTE=iluvkirkhammett]I love Kirk's bit in Turn The Page, it's so beautiful.[/QUOTE]
You mean the transcribed Saxaphone part?

[quote=iluvkirkhammett]I love Kirk's bit in Turn The Page, it's so beautiful.[/quote]
Yeah, it's quite nice, but I haven't listened to it in ages.

Btw, your half an hour away from me:)

I liked Jason's improvising of the bass In Turn The Page he's Sadowsky sounds absolutely sick.

Which Album is 'turn the page' on

[quote=Jimmypageguitarhero]Which Album is 'turn the page' on[/quote]
Garage Inc.

Yeh thought so...

That album is entirly covers.

Quiet here... Where is everyone?

Who knows. Sleeping?

[QUOTE=blue3]Who knows. Sleeping?[/QUOTE]


What?

I like the seger cover. I asked the seger thread what they thought of it...I should go back and see what they said.

I got to play James' Signature ESP yesterday. It's pretty nice. But I'm not one who is gonna pay 1000 for someone elses guitar....

[QUOTE=blue3]Who knows. Sleeping?[/QUOTE]

i should be sleeping, school tomorrow, i need my 8 hours. anyway, so i've listened to most of Live Shít, and it's pretty good, IMO Hetfield on Live Shít > Hetfield in the studio. and the Die chant in Creeping Death is awesome.

I got enough sleep. I think I slept for 14 hours.

[QUOTE=Britton]What?

I like the seger cover. I asked the seger thread what they thought of it...I should go back and see what they said.

I got to play James' Signature ESP yesterday. It's pretty nice. But I'm not one who is gonna pay 1000 for someone elses guitar....[/QUOTE]He asked where is everyone. I said sleeping.

That's cool you got to play his ESP.

[QUOTE=blue3]Who knows. Sleeping?[/QUOTE]
Or hiding from Chad again.

Any news on the album?

4 songs finished, more on the way.

Cool. Sounds good so far. You know how many there'll be on the album?