[QUOTE=Happy]Well

Metal Militia
Motorbreath
Whiplash
Ride The Lightning
Fade to Black
Creeping Death
Call of Ktulu
Master of Puppets
Orion
Damage Inc.
Blckened
One
Harvester of Sorrow
To Live Is To Die

and the rest is up to them.[/QUOTE]

Nice list. Orion is probably in my top 5 favorite Metallica songs.

EDIT: Except, youre missing Dyers Eve

[QUOTE=Happy]What's the point in making a greatest hits? people will always moan about how some song didn't get on but some crappier one did.[/QUOTE]

Like the Megadeth one. If I were to choose a Metallica greatest hits CD, it'd probably go like this...

Hit The Lights
Jump In The Fire
The Four Horsemen
Seek And Destroy
Metal Militia
Fight Fire With Fire
Ride The Lighting
Creeping Death
Battery
Master of Puppets
Blackened
One
Dyers Eve

Probably about it.

Mine would be:

Ride The Lightning
Creeping Death
Master Of Puppets
Orion
Blackened
AJFA
Dyers Eve
Disposable Heroes
Call Of Ktutlu(sp?)
Hit The Lights
Four Horsemen
Seek And Destroy
Whiplash


Dont think im missing any...

I would have:

Blackened
The Four Horsemen
Seek & Destroy
Battery
Leper Messiah
Orion
One
Creeping Death
Fade To Black
Disposable Heroes
Nothing Else Matters
Dyers Eve
To Live Is To Die

Personally, I think there'd be an awful lot more stuff from after AJFA then you guys are putting down.

The Four Horsemen
Seek And Destroy
For Whom The Bell Tolls
Fade To Black
Battery
Master of Puppets
Blackened
One
Enter Sandman
Nothing Else Matters
Until It Sleeps
King Nothing
Where The Wild Things Are
Fuel (I hate that song, but it'd go on)
St Anger
The Unnamed Feeling

That's a list with 2 from each album. Though I think I'd like to see I Disappear and No Leaf Clover on there too.

:smash:

AJFA has too much filler.

Yes, but Blackened and One are the only two deserving ones to go on a Greatest Hits. To Live Is To Die, possibly, only as a Cliff tribute. A last track or something. I don't think Dyer's Ever should go on, no matter how awesome it is.

:smash:

[QUOTE=fatbandit]Yes, but Blackened and One are the only two deserving ones to go on a Greatest Hits. To Live Is To Die, possibly, only as a Cliff tribute. A last track or something. I don't think Dyer's Ever should go on, no matter how awesome it is.

:smash:[/QUOTE]

Why dont you think Dyers Eve should go on there ?

Please cease use on the hammer smiley.

It is quite annoying.

What exacly does it mean ?

I just don't think its Greatest Hits material. Like... Ktulu is an awesome song, as is Orion, as is TLITD. To put them all on would be overkill. or even two. Maybe even one is pushing it. Greatest Hits are the most accessible songs for the public in a lot of cases. Their main target audience ain't mainly established Metallica fans.

Oh, and... Gutted.

:smash:

[url]http://www.metallica.com/Media/Albums/albums.asp[/url]

Over threre on the right you can see their greatest hits

[QUOTE=Britton][url]http://www.metallica.com/Media/Albums/albums.asp[/url]

Over threre on the right you can see their greatest hits[/QUOTE]
I can't :confused:

[QUOTE=Happy]I can't :confused:[/QUOTE]


Can't what?

[QUOTE=Britton]Can't what?[/QUOTE]
See their greatest hits unless you meant all the albums are their greatest hits.

Yea that's what I meant. LoL

I love all the albums

it took me a while to get that.
You made me think on a weekend.

[QUOTE=Britton]Yea that's what I meant. LoL

I love all the albums[/QUOTE]

I find it impossible to love all of metallicas albums :P by the way anyone know roughly how many records metallica have sold i heard its about 85mil ..not sure , want to know just to prove a point to a mate of mine , cheers

Yea I beleive it's about 90...anyway that doesn't really matter.

The only one's I'm not that into are Load and Reload.

Sorry for making you think LoL I hate it when that happens on weekends

I'm the one who got this thread going :cool:

back when there where what, 20 posts per page?

Have any of you noticed all the similarities between "Kill 'Em All", and "St. Anger"? I have, and have prepared a list.

On both, James's vocals could have been better,
On both, the production could have been better,
On both, there is no "ballad", eg. "Ride The Lightning" has "Fade to Black", "Master of Puppets" has "Welcome Home (Sanitarium)", and "..And Justice For All" has "One",
On both, the front cover includes a hand,
On both, one of the main colors for the cover is red,
Both album titles are aggresive. "[U]Kill [/U]'Em All" and "St. [U]Anger[/U]",
Both albums were the first album for the bassist of the album,
Both could be classified as "Thrash",
Both kick a[COLOR="DarkOrange"]s[/COLOR]s!

[QUOTE=DaveTheAmazing 2.0]Have any of you noticed all the similarities between "Kill 'Em All", and "St. Anger"? I have, and have prepared a list.

On both, James's vocals could have been better,
On both, the production could have been better,
On both, there is no "ballad", eg. "Ride The Lightning" has "Fade to Black", "Master of Puppets" has "Welcome Home (Sanitarium)", and "..And Justice For All" has "One",
On both, the front cover includes a hand,
On both, one of the main colors for the cover is red,
Both album titles are aggresive. "[U]Kill [/U]'Em All" and "St. [U]Anger[/U]",
Both albums were the first album for the bassist of the album,
Both could be classified as "Thrash",
Both kick a[COLOR="DarkOrange"]s[/COLOR]s![/QUOTE]

That's true, and I agree they both kick ***. But they did want to name kill em all metal up your *** at first, but I like kill em all title better. :thumb:

St. anger is thrash too really, and more thrashy than metallica has made since like 1990s or so.

Imagine if it had been Metal Up Your A[size=2]s[/size]s. They'd be regretting that now.

[QUOTE=DaveTheAmazing 2.0]Have any of you noticed all the similarities between "Kill 'Em All", and "St. Anger"? I have, and have prepared a list.

On both, James's vocals could have been better,
On both, the production could have been better,
On both, there is no "ballad", eg. "Ride The Lightning" has "Fade to Black", "Master of Puppets" has "Welcome Home (Sanitarium)", and "..And Justice For All" has "One",
On both, the front cover includes a hand,
On both, one of the main colors for the cover is red,
Both album titles are aggresive. "[U]Kill [/U]'Em All" and "St. [U]Anger[/U]",
Both albums were the first album for the bassist of the album,
Both could be classified as "Thrash",
Both kick a[COLOR="DarkOrange"]s[/COLOR]s![/QUOTE]

if they are so similar, than if kill 'em all was the first, ironically st. anger would be the last :(:(

[QUOTE=\m/-CHeV-\m/]if they are so similar, than if kill 'em all was the first, ironically st. anger would be the last :(:([/QUOTE]

No way, Im pretty sure they're gonna keep making albums till they're like 60 or something. They're not just gonna stop all of a sudden. Plus they just hired Rob like 2 years ago, so they probably do have plans for at least few more albums.

[QUOTE=\m/-CHeV-\m/]if they are so similar, than if kill 'em all was the first, ironically st. anger would be the last :(:([/QUOTE]

God I hope not

[QUOTE=DaveTheAmazing 2.0]
Both could be classified as "Thrash"[/QUOTE]
negative

uh you mean positive... because they are.

**** i just saw an ad for racing, and they were using Fuel by Metallica.I suppose thats a big metal up your as$ to those sad sacks who rip off metallica because of St.Anger, Load and Reload albums.I reckon everybody is going soft because of the new music scene with those dickhead rappers and that r'n'b crap.St.Anger is some of the heaviest $hit people will hear, and they don't like it.thats sad considering most of the people who like metallica call themselves 'Hardcore' fans, but still choose to talk **** about St.Anger.

^ i like this guy!