Is it just me or is David Gilmour's new album really underrated in most reviews?

Yes, there is. It's on the [I]Early Singles[/I] compilation. I love that album very much.

I just might have to go look for that. I'm sure it will be hard to find.

And yes I agree, On An Island is a very good CD.

[QUOTE=RNR;13625903]Is it just me or is David Gilmour's new album really underrated in most reviews?[/QUOTE]

:chug:
Yeah most people dont seem to think much of it, but I dig it a lot.

There's a studio version on Relics too. Unless that's what you're talking about.

EDIT: I actually already have it.

Err... I can upload the album for you guys if you like, it's no drama.

[url]http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/1/1b/Waters_Loses_Temper_With_Audience.ogg[/url]

The night Roger Waters spit on the fan. Awesome.

I got that bootleg. That isnt when he spits on the fan though. He does that during Pigs(3 Different Ones) when he starts to go batsh[I]i[/I]t insane during the middle.

Is that wikimedia the one where he gets pissed off about fireworks?

I love his accent "Go and set them off out thare"

[QUOTE=Jo Shoe Wah;13620292]How was it when you saw him?[/QUOTE]

To put it mildly...

Best show of my life :eek:

[QUOTE=Kingofdudes;13626378]I got that bootleg. That isnt when he spits on the fan though. He does that during Pigs(3 Different Ones) when he starts to go batsh[I]i[/I]t insane during the middle.[/QUOTE]

Its the same show. He doesnt actually spit on the guy for another two songs though. I just thought that was funny.

"Oh for f[size=2]u[/size]ck's sake!"

Id love to find footage of The Wall show, does anyone know where to get it?

There was one on a torrent at one point, im not sure about now. Thats how I got one of the concerts. The quality is pretty bad though.

You can always pick up a copy of Roger's solo concert of [I]The Wall[/I].

Is it the same theatrics and everything?

I'm fairly certain you'll find that Roger does a wonderful job of taking the stage show he concieved off from Pink Floyd to his solo career. :p

Also, I uploaded the Early Singles to the Daily Upload, so you guys can enjoy listening to studio versions of Careful With That Axe, Eugene among others.

So I heard David Gilmour is re-releasing two versions of Arnold Layne. One of them has Rick Wright on vocals, the other has David Bowie on vocals. Why anyone would collaborate with Bowie is un-explainable, I'm sure the Wright version should be nice to hear.

Well, I've already heard it in a live video, but still.

What's wrong with David Bowie?

[I]The Early Singles[/I] has Syd on vocals.

I cant stand David Bowie, that's all.

What all is on Early Singles? Are Lucy Leave, Apples and Oranges, and Vegetable Man on there? Those songs = good.

Not Lucy Leave or Vegetable Man.

1. Arnold Layne
2. Candy and a Currant Bun
3. See Emily Play
4. Scarecrow
5. Apples and Oranges
6. Paint Box
7. It Would Be So Nice
8. Julia Dream
9. Point Me At The Sky
10. Careful With That Axe Eugene

Well damn.

And I havent heard a lot of those songs. Maybe I should download the CD.

I'm finding myself liking Barrett-era Pink Floyd less though. I dont know why, I just am. Maybe I should listen to Piper and stop being retarded.

I uploaded the album for the Daily Upload, so you can get it tomorrow, I think.

I love Bowie. One of the coolest cats to ever hit the rock scene.

His music is just way too freaking weird for my liking.

And as much as I hate to admit it, his "glam-rock" clothing and glitter and eyeshadow and what have you factor into that also.

Yea that's true. I don't dig on guys dressing like chicks, but I look past that with Bowie. I mean he wasn't [I]too [/I]weird about it, just looked a little androgynous in the Ziggy Stardust era.

I find him boring, all of his songs just drag on. And to me they all sound the same.

I finally got the Pulse DVD. Great stuff, but from watching it, I think my next album will be from some of Floyd's earlier stuff. Partly because I don't enjoy the newer stuff as much and because I like the early stuff better.

You'll find a lot of people share the same opinion.As much as David was under-credited during the time Roger was in the band you really needed Roger.

Roger was still with them for much of the post [I]Live At Pompeii[/I] stuff though.

I'm now just understanding how awesome this band is. My first cd was Dark Side Of The Moon and I didn't like. I decided to give it another try with The Wall and I'm glad I did. I can now call myself a Floyd fan.
I have been wondering, though; Are they still together?