Tramp Stamps We Got Drunk And Made An EP
» Back to review

Comments:Add a Comment 
Tranqyl
July 22nd 2021


432 Comments

Album Rating: 1.5

I really think it's as simple as this. Is there any essence of technical skill or creativity? Either can offset a 1 to 1.5 or 2. This has no creativity whatsoever, but the technical skill isn't 'God, please fucking end me.' it's more 'this shit is terribly boring and the instrumentals suck'.

Digging: Calabrese - Flee The Light

parksungjoon
July 22nd 2021


33798 Comments


if that works for you then great [:

Digging: Morgoth - Feel Sorry for the Fanatic

Jots
Staff Reviewer
July 22nd 2021


7371 Comments


imo every album starts at a 0/5 (maybe a 0.5/5 if we're being nice and applying the RYM system) and builds up from there depending on how much i enjoyed it, and other subsidiary factors. which means the majority of music probably should rate at about a 2/5 or so, tho tbh most albums in that ballpark I don't finish ergo don't rate, which is why I still have relatively few ratings lol

i've just accepted that "objective ratings" don't really work and are too much deliberation.

Eakflanderyof
July 22nd 2021


3486 Comments


"When there's shit like Brokencyde or Onision's albums, I don't think this album quite warrants a 1"

I'm pretty sure brokencyde is actually satire though. Look at their album titles

parksungjoon
July 22nd 2021


33798 Comments


with ya jots

Valzentia
July 22nd 2021


1156 Comments

Album Rating: 2.0

"I'm pretty sure brokencyde is actually satire though"



they're not but they never took themselves seriously at all

Trebor.
Staff Reviewer
July 22nd 2021


58040 Comments

Album Rating: 1.0

Which is why this is worse, it's so fake

Supercoolguy64
July 22nd 2021


10702 Comments


I think the conclusion I made from this conversation is that rating systems are arbitrary and at the end of the day the music is either worth a listen or isn’t.

Digging: Kalibas/Rune - Kalibas | Rune

TheSpirit
July 22nd 2021


28202 Comments


maybe this is the conversation the tramp stamps were going for all along



must 5 this now

Digging: Saidan - Jigoku: Spiraling Chasms Of The Blackest Hell

Eakflanderyof
July 22nd 2021


3486 Comments


This shows in the new comment area as "we got drunk and mad" and that's a better album title

veninblazer
July 22nd 2021


12235 Comments

Album Rating: 1.0

this EP is so bad omfg, dudes will be unnecessarily mean to genuinely inoffensive crap but this can't just be 1'd and done that's so funny

Tranqyl
July 22nd 2021


432 Comments

Album Rating: 1.5

all along, tramp stamps were really the friends we made along the way.

veninblazer
July 22nd 2021


12235 Comments

Album Rating: 1.0

for example, tranqyl, i fail to see how this is better than Father of All. but i guess i'm in the minority, because i think that was kinda okay.

parksungjoon
July 22nd 2021


33798 Comments


>I think the conclusion I made from this conversation is that rating systems are arbitrary

god bless, ive done my job then

veninblazer
July 22nd 2021


12235 Comments

Album Rating: 1.0

yeah its all arbitrary nonsense but i prefer for it to follow some level of pseudo objective logic, there's no way this would be better than an album thats worst crime is just being a bit dumb and boring

parksungjoon
July 22nd 2021


33798 Comments


follow what u want

Tranqyl
July 22nd 2021


432 Comments

Album Rating: 1.5

Personal preference I guess. I think I just gave that album a one because of how hard Green Day has fallen. But yeah, park is right that none of this shit is objective or all that worthwhile for any more than categorizing your own feelings on an album.

veninblazer
July 22nd 2021


12235 Comments

Album Rating: 1.0

yeah id drop a hard 1 here and a 3 on FoA, for all its faults, its at least better than the trilogy and i had fun with it

SitarHero
July 22nd 2021


13328 Comments


This band isn't an industry plant so much as it is a bunch of industry insiders cynically trying to capitalise on a trend they think exists, which is probably the antithesis of punk. This is the auditory version of the "how do you do, fellow kids" meme. brokeNCYDE may have sucked, but at least the kids did seem to like it.

Also, wasn't the main reason this got flak its rapey lyrics?

Kompys2000
Contributing Reviewer
July 22nd 2021


6228 Comments


Tbh this is bad enough on its own terms that whatever industry connections the band members may or may not have is prob the least damning aspect of their whole thing

Like "I'd Rather Die" does not suddenly become excusable if this band can pass whatever sniff tests of authenticity we want to subject them to

Digging: John Donne - A Mutable Feast or: The Ghost of a Flea



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2019 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy