Technically, it's that close to a 3.5, but there's a lot of pretty uninteresting songs here to tell you the truth, the "Bullet With Butterfly Wings" and the "Tonight, Tonight" ep's are pretty redundant (though I do love Rotten Apples and Jupiter's Lament), they don't hold a candle against the "Zero" and the "Thirty Three" stuff.

A handful of memorable tunes here but I wouldn't see myself ever giving this more than 3.5.

Found the full box set brand new for $20 at the record store today. Can't wait to finally check this out

Album Rating: 4.0

Had this when I was 16, but somehow misplaced it a long time ago.



Having not heard it for 15 years, I rebought it. Had forgotten how good this was. Favorite songs are The Aeroplane Flies High, God, Marquis of Spades, set the Ray to jerry and Medellia of the Gray Skies.

Album Rating: 3.5

I got this for Christmas when it came out in like 97 as I was a huge Pumpkins fan, and it got stolen shortly after. I had forgotten how awesome Set the Ray to Jerry, Cherry, Pennies, and The Boy are.

Album Rating: 3.5

How the hell did Set the Ray to Jerry not make it onto Mellon Collie man

Album Rating: 3.5

Agreed, it's better than half of Mellon Collie and their best b-side