Album Rating: 3.5

This was much better than I was expecting after Marrow, so I am pleased. It doesn't, however, even touch their old stuff. I like how heavy - how unexpectedly heavy - this was, but the riffs are still lacking and the variety in instrumentation isn't nearly as important a feature as before.

let's go back to 2006

There are a fair few things that need fixin' in this here review, such as:

For a band with such a mutual creative talent, it's a lot better for them to just let them continue forging their own path and not paying attention to what people want or expect.

Also, 'farcry' is two words, not one.

Album Rating: 4.0

shit is tight yo

I absolutely love this. I feel like a lot of people on this site will never listen to agalloch again unless they release Ashes pt. II

sounds cool..

dank as fuck

I think you'd really like this, Zed, its very good. Just finished listening to it.

Good review, Noctus.
POS'd

I thought Marrow was awesome so I'll check this soon.

Album Rating: 3.5

It doesn't, however, even touch their old stuff. I like how heavy - how unexpectedly heavy - this was, but the riffs are still lacking and the variety in instrumentation isn't nearly as important a feature as before.



Dropping the acoustic atmosphere is seriously going to kill Agalloch for me. But I do like how they upped the production standard on this one. Did not expect this to be so heavy.

Album Rating: 4.0 | Sound Off

fixed minor errors, thanks guys! :]



and yeah wizard i definitely wouldn't want the lack of acoustic atmosphere to be permanent, but i still love how this turned out

nice work Noctus and grats for the feature!

nice review mr. Noctus.

i thought you werent enjoying this album, guess it grew on you. gotta check it out m/

Album Rating: 3.0

"Dropping the acoustic atmosphere is seriously going to kill Agalloch for me."



Exactly how I feel. I need to give this a good listen though.

Album Rating: 3.5

Dropping the acoustic atmosphere is seriously going to kill Agalloch for me.

Album Rating: 4.0 | Sound Off

i don't think they're dropping it at all, it would have distracted from the heart of this ep which definitely isn't nature or atmospherics. i can definitely see why it wouldn't be to the liking of a lot of people but i can p. much assure you that this isn't a permanent direction. or at least if it is, i'll likely be in the same boat. :]

Great review.

Need to give this another listen before I can form a proper opinion but I definitely found it enjoyable upon first listen.

hmmm well i was gonna pos your review because i feel it's well written but it looks like you already have enough pos'

I'm sure he wouldn't mind another.