Alesana A Place Where the Sun is Silent
» Back to review

Comments:Add a Comment 
Rbaten61
October 14th 2011


32 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

Seriously man a 3 -_- outa 5 i'll admit they have gotten softer and pushed their screamer to the curb but really a 3 ? they have gotten alot catchier and the songwriting is tightened up alot too im listening to the whole thing now and it's not intolerable it's amazing

Trebor.
Staff Reviewer
October 14th 2011


56233 Comments


1

Acanthus
October 14th 2011


9812 Comments


I pos'd, as you make good points.

Still like their first and third album, love them even.

TravisAllen507
October 14th 2011


1 Comments


This review is just terrible. It seems as if you have something against a screamo band, if so, then why in the hell are you reviewing their music? Usually when i don't like a band, i simply do not listen to them.

Of course you are probably one of those people that wants every hard band to be mainstream so they can sell out for radio play. If you don't like harder music, then don't review it. Plain and simple. Go listen to Escape the Fate or Blink-182 if you can't handle screams, maybe that would suit your mainstream type of music.

Pharoh
October 14th 2011


3325 Comments


"This review is just terrible. It seems as if you have something against a screamo band"
Theyre not screamo.


"If you don't like harder music, then don't review it"

Telling people what not to do will get you nowhere.

Nikkolae
October 14th 2011


5405 Comments


1 comment

Digging: Drive Like Jehu - Yank Crime

Nikkolae
October 14th 2011


5405 Comments


they sound like a less symphonic (?) I Am Ghost now lol

Vespiion
October 14th 2011


1224 Comments


Woah, Travis. Yeah, because all Sputnik ever listens to is mainstream music that isn't "screamo". I'm sure your perception of "screamo" is derived from your favorite scenexcore bands, amirite?

TrstN01
October 14th 2011


799 Comments


Dude, Travis. This isn't screamo. This is post-hardcore. Learn the difference.

Deviant.
Staff Reviewer
October 14th 2011


32190 Comments


hmmm could that be an alt maybe


Doubt it. Remember the Sum 41 thread? Fanboys google reviews and drop hate if they disagree with said assessment


Nikkolae
October 14th 2011


5405 Comments


it still baffles me why anyone would write just one coment and leave dev

IfYouRun
October 14th 2011


311 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

@TravisAllen507, if you check my music scores you would see one of my favourite bands is Funeral For A Friend, and alongside this i love bands such as Your Demise. The fact is however, that this band does heavy badly. They seem to think heavy means shouting over each other while playing breakdowns that never break the 4/4 time signature. Good god.



Also, thank you Andacas, i knew people would diss this before they even gave it a chance.

TomAkaVeto
October 14th 2011


1956 Comments


I've sampled some of this on Youtube and it's pretty bad. "Hand In Hand With The Damned" is the best from what I've heard and it's still not that great. Probably one of the better songs I've ever heard from them, though.

TrstN01
October 15th 2011


799 Comments


Have you heard Circle VII? It's my favorite off this album.

Pharoh
October 15th 2011


3325 Comments


needs more ambrosia

Mabbitt
October 15th 2011


1677 Comments


I didn't really like The Emptiness, so this is better than that from what i've heard so far. Where Myth Fades to Legend is probably my favorite. These guys are kind of a guilty pleasure, since they're one of the first post-hardcore bands I liked, and they pretty much got me into the genre.

Pharoh
October 15th 2011


3325 Comments


My dig is far much better than alesana even though it's only a ep ;]

Acanthus
October 15th 2011


9812 Comments


myth sucked.

123

I couldn't believe that it was the same band when I heard that album, it never struck me right.

LG
October 16th 2011


3050 Comments


ahhh, its not good, but i don't really have a problem listening to it.

Trebor.
Staff Reviewer
October 16th 2011


56233 Comments


A place where the sun don't shine



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2017 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy