Album Rating: 2.5

In order the AFI albums



Sing the Sorrow>Crash Love>Decemberunderground>The Art Of Drowning>Black Sails in the Sunset>Answer That>Very Proud of Ya>Shut Your Mouth



in my most humble of opinions anyway, personally I think they only keep getting better.

Album Rating: 2.5

"this band has enormous potential. But with this album they have decided to abandon what they clearly loved doing (DU style music) just to please critics."



In a small way I can relate to what you're saying.

Album Rating: 3.5

thats an idiot statement

Or this could just be another evolution for the band... If anything DU was trying to please critics

Album Rating: 2.5

Yes the band has evolved but I found the style in DU to be fitting for the band. I don't think DU was trying to please critics though. The band has always been dark and havok has looked like a girly man for a long time now. The only reason I think DU did so well commercially is because "emo" was blowing up at the time I think afi just got caught at an awkward time which is why many called them sellouts.

Album Rating: 3.0 | Sound Off

yeah pretty much. i think they just do whatever they want, and it's awesome.

Holy shit I just read that conversation between qwe3 and the troll twat and I can't remember the last time I laughed this hard.
Amazing.

Album Rating: 4.0

I clicked on this review to get an alternate opinion of an album I thought was fairly good. I wanted to see why someone would not like it. Instead I get a review by an egotistic douche that has nothing to say other then his ignorant opinion. I even agree that DU was their best album but I am not going to start a review saying that torch songs opening is awful when it is simply amazing. This review is a rant and utter crap.

Album Rating: 4.0

get the hell out.

Album Rating: 4.0

this guy wrote a rant on blink too...

Album Rating: 3.5

This is a terrible excuse for an essay regarding your thoughts on our latest album. I'm glad the majority thought so as well.

Album Rating: 3.0

omg 3/35 damn.

you, sir, amused the hell out of me. i have to say you're wrong for at least two reasons. 1) decemberunderground as their best work. ummmmm... no. it was certainly their most accessible work and it made them more famous than any of their work to that point, but i am certain you are confusing popular with good. 2) the worst sin in music is BORINGNESS? really???
i was sure that the worst sin would be a lack of originality, or being contrived in form and fact, or perhaps, just being dissonant (and here i am not talking about the artistic use of dissonance, but the inability to form a proper tune). there are more reasons, but just based on these 2 i am going to jump out on a limb and say you are a pop whore. jus' guessin'.

OOOOO! "Spidery"! Good adjective, I'm gonna steal that off you.

yeah seriously? decemberunderground being their best album? i thought that was their weakest...i LOVE The Art of Drowning, along with the All Hallows EP and i thought crash love was still a pretty solid album. different, but good. medicate just has a great main riff and an epic bridge to it.