Album Rating: 3.0

its soooo bad

Album Rating: 3.5

please elaborate

Album Rating: 3.5

hmm i somehow thought this was the catch for us thread nvm. yeah this album is their weakest but it still has many of the elements that i love in the band

Album Rating: 4.5

nah ten stories is the weakest this is just different

Album Rating: 4.0

I don't know what to think anymore. They're about equal

Album Rating: 3.0

this is far worse than essentially any mwy release

Album Rating: 3.5

Ten Stories beats the pants off of this, imo. There are 3 or 4 really awesome songs here and the rest ranges from plain jane to b-side-quality stuff.

Album Rating: 4.0

No, it just needs more listens than any mwy release

Album Rating: 4.5

this is the happiest album and it constantly just feels hopeful and pleasant and i love it

Album Rating: 3.5

Might deserve more than a 3, but I can't even say when the last time was that I listened to the whole thing front-to-back which isn't the case with most of their other albums.

Album Rating: 4.5

Purely based on how much I listen to them cover to cover my order would be Pale Horses > It's All Crazy... > Ten Stories > A to B > Catch For Us > B,S.

Album Rating: 5.0

This album would be so much better without Fig With A Bellyache, that song just rubs me the wrong way. This album is probably tied for their "worst" with A to B, but it's still overall outstanding.

Album Rating: 3.5

Interesting to see someone else put A->B and CFUTF that low, because I thought I was the only one. Since the most recent release, mine is probably like this:

B,S > Ten Stories > Pale Horses > CFUTF > A->B = I'ts All Crazy!

Album Rating: 4.5

you guys are nuts for having A to B that low. Brother, Sister is easily the worst thing they've done, stick that down there.

Album Rating: 3.5

@Danred, that's one of the only tracks on here that I love, but I can totally see why it may be loathed. I love the lyrics in that song and the creepy opening eventually bursting into a lush and circus-like second half.

"At the caterpillar picnic, Brother Butterfly stole a rhubarb stem, licked and dipped it in the sugar bowl."

Album Rating: 3.5

Brother, Sister is one of my favorite albums of all-time lol so I don't think that one is going to budge.

Album Rating: 4.5

It has In A Sweater Poorly Knit so I'll give it that

Album Rating: 5.0

@dbizzles That's actually my exact ranking, at the moment. mwY are one of those bands that my rankings/ratings change regularly.



@rufinthefury You are an absolute madman for thinking B,S is their worst. Of course, since that is my favorite album of all time, I'm biased.

Album Rating: 3.5

I think I'd be into their older albums more if I didn't get into them at the time I did. I was only familiar with a handful of songs by them before Brother, Sister came out and I picked that album up on a whim when it released.

Fast-forward 10 years and they are easily one of my favorite bands.

Album Rating: 5.0

My first mwY album was Pale Horses. It's my 3rd favorite, but B,S and Ten Stories are just overall better constructed albums. Their earlier stuff is still amazingly good, but I just don't have the connection to them that I do to B,S and later.