ratcfc
User

Reviews 2
Approval 100%

Soundoffs 6
Album Ratings 205
Objectivity 71%

Last Active 12-13-08 1:49 pm
Joined 12-05-08

Review Comments 28

Average Rating: 3.62
Rating Variance: 0.54
Objectivity Score: 71%
(Fairly Balanced)

Chart.

Sort by: Rating | Release Date | Rating Date | Name


2010
Flying Lotus Cosmogramma2.5
Jonsi Go3.5
Wait What the notorious xx4.5
Broken Bells Broken Bells3.5
Hot Chip One Life Stand4.0
Vampire Weekend Contra3.5

2009
The xx xx3.5

2008
Kanye West 808s and Heartbreak1.5
6) 808's & Heartbreaks: Kanye West

Ok so I got around to listening to this and it is awful I find it bewildering that so many reviewers gave it good to decent marks. The only think I can think of is that they were so taken aback by differences between this and his previous work that they felt intimidated enough to give it critical praise ("I don't wanna look like I don't 'get it' so i'll pretend that I do. I mean, if its like, different, then it must be good, right?"). Let me break it down for them.

i) The production is NOT groundbreaking! It is well within the limits of what many electronic producers have been doing for a very long time. Just because Kanye just discovered the minimal techno sound doesn't make it trailblazing. A lot of it sounds like Kanye just adapted some Junior Boys and Slam beats, threw in a few soul sounds, and called it a day. It's lazy, unconvincing, and disingenuous

ii) For once, 50 Cent was right about something. This does sound like a T-Pain album. Kanye makes the baffling decision to sing rather than rap throughout 90% of the album. Of course the trouble with that is that he can't really sing to save his life. Even the 'ahem' liberal use of Auto Tune can't disguise how below par his singing is. In a sense, it actually makes this worse than a T-Pain album, because at least T-Pain can hold a note. Auto-Tune pitch distortions are ok if they are used sparingly for effect, but throughout the entire album? It doesn't sound 'futuristic' unless your perception of futuristic is Cher circa 1999. It comes as little surprise the the two bearable songs on the album include some rapping by Kanye or Weezy ('Heartless' and 'Tell Everybody That you Know')

iii) The lyrics will make you vomit unless you are an adolescent cretin.

I'm not lovin you, the way I wanted to
What I had to do, had to run from you
I'm in love with you, but the vibe is wrong
And that haunted me, all the way home
So ya never know, never never know
Never know enough, til it's over love
Til we lose control, system overload
Screamin no no no, no no
- Love Lockdown

Do we really deserve to endure this garbage?

We can only hope that Kanye's neurons have been overloaded with post breakup chemicals which have only temporarily rendered his musical ability null and void.
Black Milk Tronic4.5
I felt strangely embarrassed and stupid after listening to Black Milk's Tronic last week. How was it possible that I could be caught completely unawares by an artist who has quietly managed to make the best Hip Hop album of the year? How is it possible that I had not even heard of him until recently? I'm not a hip hop expert, but this was a terrible lapse....unforgivable!
Tronic is everything we want from a Hip Hop album. It boasts fantastic, fist pumping production, thoughtful, well delivered rhymes, and a sense of hunger and earnestness that sadly tends to get lost once artists reach a certain level of stardom.
The other reason for my high review is that the album has consistent quality throughout. We are not subjected to pointless skits or vapid 'filler' songs. I get the sense that Black Milk believes in quality control and probably has a fair amount of material that he deemed not worthy for this release.
From a production standpoint, I hear echoes of so many producers who must have influenced Black Milk. RZA, DJ Premier, Kanye, DJ Muggs are all easily discernable in the production, but Black Milk has also definitely been listening to UK grime artists (I definitely heard echoes of Dizzee Rascal’s ‘Brand New Day’ on ‘Hell Yeah’), old Jazz and Blues records, and Electro/Minimal, displaying that he has an appetite for music which transcends traditional Hip Hop influences.
From a delivery standpoint, Black Milk gets his stylistic cues from Eminem. While he does not yet possess the vocal acrobatics and emotive ability of his Detroit colleague, there is no doubt that Black Milk is more than a producer who raps from time to time.
Get this one. Trust.
Ryan Adams Cardinology3.0
Oasis Dig Out Your Soul3.0
The Streets Everything is Borrowed2.0
Kings of Leon Only By The Night4.5
Metallica Death Magnetic3.5
The Game LAX3.0
Ida Maria Fortress Round My Heart3.5
Nas Untitled4.0
The Bug London Zoo3.0
Sigur Ros Med Sud i Eyrum vid Spilum Endalaust4.0
Flying Lotus Los Angeles3.5
Nine Inch Nails The Slip3.0
The Roots Rising Down3.0
The Black Keys Attack & Release3.5
Guilty Simpson Ode to the Ghetto2.0
Foals Antidotes3.0
Lykke Li Youth Novels3.5

2007
Lupe Fiasco The Cool3.5
Wu-Tang Clan 8 Diagrams3.0
Faker Be The Twilight3.0
Jay-Z American Gangster3.0
Burial Untrue4.5
Pinch Underwater Dancehall3.5
Saul Williams The Inevitable Rise and Liberation of Niggy Tardust4.0
Radiohead In Rainbows4.5
Radiohead are truly in fine form with In Rainbows. I had 'All I need' on rotation for ages....love that reverb
Ian Brown The World is Yours3.0
Eddie Vedder Into the Wild4.0
M.I.A. Kala3.0
The Smashing Pumpkins Zeitgeist2.0
Ryan Adams Easy Tiger4.0
The White Stripes Icky Thump4.0
Silverchair Young Modern2.5
Kings of Leon Because Of The Times4.0
The Field From Here We Go Sublime3.0
Jesse Malin Glitter in the gutter3.5
LCD Soundsystem Sound of Silver3.0
Arcade Fire Neon Bible2.5
Lily Allen Alright, Still3.0
The Good, The Bad and The Queen The Good, The Bad & The Queen2.5

2006
Nas Hip Hop Is Dead3.5
Clipse Hell Hath No Fury4.0
IMO one of the best Hip Hop releases in 2006 and possibly since. The material is hard edged but diverse enough to be interesting, and the guys definitely have the ability to delve beyond the basic brag and brawl raps that many in the hardcore hip hop scene seem to be unable to transcend. The production is sparse yet well done, props to Pharrell and co.
The Game Doctor's Advocate3.5
Amy Winehouse Back to Black4.0
Lupe Fiasco Food & Liquor3.5
Kasabian Empire2.5
Junior Boys So This Is Goodbye4.0
Citizen Cope Every Waking Moment3.0
The Black Keys Magic Potion4.0
The Roots Game Theory4.5
Silversun Pickups Carnavas3.0
Muse Black Holes & Revelations3.0
Regina Spektor Begin To Hope3.5
Burial Burial3.5
Pearl Jam Pearl Jam3.0
Gnarls Barkley St. Elsewhere2.5
The Streets The Hardest Way To Make An Easy Living2.5

2005
Blackalicious The Craft3.0
Damian Marley Welcome To Jamrock3.5
The White Stripes Get Behind Me Satan3.5
Faker Addicted Romantic3.0
Oasis Don't Believe the Truth3.0
Sleater-Kinney The Woods2.5
M.I.A. Arular4.0
Nine Inch Nails With Teeth3.5
The Game The Documentary4.0

2004
Eminem Encore2.0
Kasabian Kasabian3.5
Kings of Leon Aha Shake Heartbreak3.0
Junior Boys Last Exit4.0
Green Day American Idiot4.0
Citizen Cope The Clarence Greewood Recordings4.0
Bjork Medulla2.5
Diplo Florida2.5
Sasha Involver4.0
The Killers Hot Fuss3.0
Zero 7 When It Falls3.5
M.I.A. Piracy Funds Terrorism, Vol. 13.0
The Streets A Grand Don't Come For Free4.5

2003
Jay-Z The Black Album4.5
Joe Strummer and The Mescaleros Streetcore4.0
The Police Every Breath You Take: The Classics4.0
Infected Mushroom Converting Vegetarians3.5
Radiohead Hail to the Thief3.5
The White Stripes Elephant4.0
Jesse Malin The Fine Art Of Self Destruction3.5

2002
Sasha Airdrawndagger4.5
Truly a benchmark for progressive EDM. Sasha's ability to mix melody with cathartic peaks and complex yet very danceable beats is second to none.
Silverchair Diorama4.5
The Streets Original Pirate Material4.0
Oasis Heathen Chemistry3.5

2001
Wu-Tang Clan Iron Flag3.5
Nas STILLmatic3.5
Oasis Familiar To Millions3.5
Radiohead Amnesiac3.0
The White Stripes White Blood Cells3.5
Ben Harper Live From Mars3.5

2000
Snoop Dogg Dead Man Walkin'2.5
Green Day Warning2.5
Radiohead Kid A4.0
The Clash The Story of the Clash4.5
Eminem The Marshall Mathers LP4.0
Rage Against the Machine Renegades4.0
Oasis Standing on the Shoulder of Giants4.0
Pearl Jam Binaural2.5
Jurassic 5 Quality Control3.5

1999
Nas Nastradamus2.0
Nine Inch Nails The Fragile3.0
Red Hot Chili Peppers Californication3.5
Snoop Dogg No Limit Top Dogg3.0
Nas I Am...3.5
Eminem The Slim Shady LP4.0
Rage Against the Machine The Battle of Los Angeles3.5

1998
Pearl Jam Live On Two Legs4.5
Oasis The Masterplan4.5
Manu Chao Clandestino4.0
The Smashing Pumpkins Adore4.5
Lou Reed Perfect Night: Live In London4.0
Public Enemy He Got Game2.5
Pearl Jam Yield3.0
Sigur Ros Live at the Icelandic Opera House4.0

1997
Green Day Nimrod2.5
Buena Vista Social Club Buena Vista Social Club3.5
Oasis Be Here Now4.5
Twista Adrenaline Rush2.5
Wyclef Jean The Carnival3.0
Radiohead OK Computer5.0
Wu-Tang Clan Wu-Tang Forever4.0

1996
Snoop Dogg Tha Doggfather3.5
Ghostface Killah Ironman3.5
Nirvana From the Muddy Banks of the Wishkah3.5
Pearl Jam No Code4.5
Mobb Deep Hell on Earth4.5
Pantera The Great Southern Trendkill3.0
Rage Against the Machine Evil Empire4.0
DJ Shadow Endtroducing.....4.5
Jay-Z Reasonable Doubt4.0
Nas It Was Written4.0

1995
The Smashing Pumpkins Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness4.0
Green Day Insomniac3.0
Red Hot Chili Peppers One Hot Minute3.0
Silverchair Frogstomp4.0
Pink Floyd Pulse4.5
Oasis (What's the Story) Morning Glory?4.0
Mobb Deep The Infamous4.5
Radiohead The Bends5.0
Brotha Lynch Hung Season of da Siccness3.5
Nine Inch Nails Further Down the Spiral (US)3.5

1994
Pearl Jam Vitalogy4.5
Method Man Tical3.0
Nirvana MTV Unplugged in New York5.0
Oasis Definitely Maybe4.5
Nas Illmatic5.0
Pink Floyd The Division Bell4.5
Pantera Far Beyond Driven3.0
Nine Inch Nails The Downward Spiral5.0
Aphex Twin Selected Ambient Works Volume II4.5
The Notorious B.I.G. Ready to Die5.0
Green Day Dookie3.0
1993
Snoop Dogg Doggystyle5.0
Wu-Tang Clan Enter the Wu-Tang (36 Chambers)4.5
Pearl Jam Vs.4.5
Nirvana In Utero3.5
The Smashing Pumpkins Siamese Dream5.0
About as perfect as an album can be. It's all there. Angst, earnestness, artistic vision, catharsis, melody, ballads, all out rockers, soaring vocals, and on and on. What I really love is how the music mimics the lyrical content. At times its angry, over the top, almost violent. Other times, its quiet, almost sweet, and introspective. Yet throughout it is engaging and melodic. There isn't a dud track on the album and although Corgan was said to have been disappointed with the final production, I think that few albums have been produced as expertly as Butch Vig produced this one.
It is and always will be one of my favorites.
Radiohead Pablo Honey3.0
Tool Undertow4.0

1992
Nirvana Incesticide3.0
Rage Against the Machine Rage Against the Machine4.5
R.E.M. Automatic for the People4.0
Nine Inch Nails Broken2.5
Stone Temple Pilots Core3.5
Pantera Vulgar Display of Power3.5
Aphex Twin Selected Ambient Works 85-924.5
1991
Nirvana Nevermind5.0
Red Hot Chili Peppers Blood Sugar Sex Magik4.5
Pearl Jam Ten4.5
The Smashing Pumpkins Gish3.5

1990
Pantera Cowboys from Hell4.0

1989
Nine Inch Nails Pretty Hate Machine4.0
Nirvana Bleach3.5

1988
The Beatles Past Masters, Vol. 24.0
Muddy Waters Hoochie Coochie Man4.0
Public Enemy It Takes a Nation of Millions to Hold Us Back3.5

1987
R.E.M. Document3.5

1984
Dire Straits Alchemy: Dire Straits Live4.5

1983
The Police Synchronicity4.0
1979
The Clash London Calling5.0
Pink Floyd The Wall5.0

1976
Creedence Clearwater Revival Chronicle, Vol. 14.5

1975
Pink Floyd Wish You Were Here4.0

1971
Pink Floyd Relics3.5
Crosby, Stills, Nash and Young 4 Way Street4.0
1970
The Beatles Let It Be5.0

1969
Pink Floyd Ummagumma2.5
Pink Floyd More2.5
The Who Tommy4.0

1967
The Who The Who Sell Out3.5
The Beatles Magical Mystery Tour4.0
STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2023 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy