planewreck
Lew is
Emeritus

Reviews 66
Soundoffs 16
News Articles 6
Approval 98%
Site Rank 148

Album Ratings 125
Objectivity 70%

Last Active 11-23-09 6:21 pm
Joined 04-15-07

Forum Posts 5900
Review Comments 2975

Band Edits 12

Average Rating: 3.8
Rating Variance: 0.86
Objectivity Score: 70%
(Fairly Balanced)

Chart.

Sorted by Rating | Sort by Name

5 classic
Animal Collective Here Comes The Indian
Animal Collective Feels
Animal Collective Merriweather Post Pavilion
Arcade Fire Funeral
Armchairpolitician Seven Segment Decoder
Clipse Hell Hath No Fury
Converge Jane Doe
Deerhunter Microcastle
Guided By Voices Bee Thousand
GZA Liquid Swords
King Crimson Red
My Bloody Valentine Loveless
Neutral Milk Hotel In the Aeroplane Over the Sea
Pink Floyd Wish You Were Here
Sonic Youth Daydream Nation
Storm & Stress Under Thunder & Fluorescent Lights
The Microphones The Glow pt.2
The National Alligator

4.5 superb
90 Day Men To Everybody
A Sunny Day In Glasgow Ashes Grammar
Animal Collective Sung Tongs
Animal Collective Strawberry Jam
Animal Collective Fall Be Kind
Based on early versions of "What Would I Want? Sky" (not to mention the recent "Brother Sport" single with a 9-minute version of "Bleeding"), Fall Be Kind seemed poised to be a continuation of AC's experiment with repetitious pop, a style that served them well only earlier this year. And yet, this "EP" (I hesitate to even call it that, such the mini-album success it is) is a larger leap forward than maybe even Merriweather was; it embraces the possibilities behind the shared experience Animal Collective always has been and now will continue to be. This is a band excited to see us excited, evident in the transformation of the disc's clear highlight "What Would I Want? Sky" from an earlier version's anxious trance trip into full on, freak-folk trip-hop. There are no pretenses or effects to further us from the band; Avey Tare rocks the mic and we can understand him! We can sing with him! Animal Collective continue to respond to us as much as they push themselves, and we meet somewhere in the uncharted middle where a band's popularity is relative to the boundaries they push. And I haven't even talked about the other four clear highlights.
Beach Boys Pet Sounds
Belle and Sebastian If You're Feeling Sinister
Burial Untrue
Charizma and Peanut Butter Wolf Big Shots
Converge Petitioning The Empty Sky
Daitro Laisser Vivre Les Squelettes
Deerhunter Cryptograms
Gospel The Moon is A Dead World
Grizzly Bear Yellow House
Grouper Dragging a Dead Deer Up a Hill
More than just a pretty acoustic record, Liz Harris (a.k.a Grouper) has created a startlingly vivid and brooding shoegaze gem in Dragging a Dead Deer Up a Hill that works in spite of its length and sprawling, claustrophobic design. This has every bit to do with Harris’ stylistic choices, from the production’s hazy layer of feedback, to the attention on the effects of the guitar, right down to the levels at which Harris’ voice is pushed into the mix, so that every bit of Dead Deer feels personal and different. No two moments ever fully meet, and that’s what makes it captivating. If my reaction to the album is also overwhelmingly personal, then it’s only a testament to how strong I find the material to be. Dragging a Dead Deer Up a Hill is not an album I’d recommend to just anyone; an audience will eventually find Grouper, and when they do, it’ll be more than well-deserved.
Guided By Voices Alien Lanes
Joanna Newsom The Milk-Eyed Mender
Joanna Newsom Ys
Micachu Jewellery
Modern Life Is War Witness
Off Minor The Heat Death of the Universe
Shugo Tokumaru Night Piece
Shugo Tokumaru Exit
Craig Eley over at Cokemachineglow described Tokumaru this way: "Listening to Shugo is like watching a foreign film with the subtitles off. You can't 'know' what's being said... but you can 'understand' what's happening. You can feel. And at the end, you can say 'that was delirious and beautiful and fun.'" More so than anything, this is what makes Exit Tokumaru's best album to date, each song a different template and story. Tokumaru experiments with his sound here, employing more traditional folk, electronica and pop into his own unique, abrasive songwriting style. But the album is best because of his attention to detail, to the subtle nuances that create such an effortlessly diverse album. Exit is delirious and beautiful and fun, and it should make Tokumaru a star.
The Dismemberment Plan Emergency and I
The Flaming Lips Embryonic
See that cover? This is the same Flaming Lips, with that same childlike wonder at the limits of rock (argument: there aren't any), but hairier. Quite unshaven. Being re-birthed out of a vagina of light, all thrilled, ravaged, insane, and deeply, affectionately human. Party like it's 2009.
The Flaming Lips The Soft Bulletin
The Microphones It Was Hot We Stayed In The Water
The National Boxer
Wu-Tang Clan Enter the Wu-Tang (36 Chambers)
Yo La Tengo Popular Songs

4 excellent
Animal Collective Spirit They've Gone, Spirit They've Vanished
Animal Collective Animal Crack Box
Animal Collective Prospect Hummer (feat. Vashti Bunyan)
Atlas Sound Let the Blind Lead Those Who Can See...
Atlas Sound Logos
Beirut Gulag Orkestar
Brother/Ghost Black Ice
Circulatory System Signal Morning
Converge Axe To Fall
Cymbals Eat Guitars Why There Are Mountains
Deerhunter Fluorescent Grey EP
Deerhunter Weird Era Cont.
Kidcrash Jokes
King Crimson In the Court of the Crimson King
Modest Mouse The Moon & Antarctica
My Bloody Valentine You Made Me Realise
Neutral Milk Hotel On Avery Island
Off Minor Some Blood
Paavoharju Laulu Laakson Kukista
Raekwon Only Built 4 Cuban Linx... Pt II
Say Anything ...Is A Real Boy (re-release)
Sonic Youth Sonic Nurse
Sonic Youth EVOL
Stag Hare Black Medicine Music
The Millennium Begin
I once saw Begin described as "if the Beach Boys covered Sgt. Pepper" and, well, yeah. Surprisingly ahead of its time in terms of implementing various structures and production quirks even if the actual melodies don't hold up to the more cherished classics. That is a small quibble considering the Millennium pack this album full of quality (and criminally overlooked) material.
Yo La Tengo I Can Hear The Heart Beating As One

3.5 great
90 Day Men Panda Park
Animal Collective People [EP]
Beirut The Flying Club Cup
In 2006, Beirut released the auspicious Gulag Orkestar, a festive, lively album inspired by Zach Condon's romp through Europe as an impressionable teen. In 2007, he grew up. Over the span of one year, Beirut had evolved, becoming mature and slightly diminished in character, more interested in fable storytelling than impressing in style. And, all the better for it, for The Flying Club Cup (even the title feels older and less cool) brings a lasting sense of melancholy to its perverse, European orchestration. Horns bombard "A Sunday Smile," violins shroud "Forks And Knives (La Fete)" in "big, glorious, over-the-top pop arrangements," and a simple ukulele commandeers "The Penalty." And Condon, though sounding slightly weary under the drama, still keeps his own, maintaining a strong head in the pop highlight "In The Mausoleum," a classically trained piece full of pianos, organs, and strings. It might not be immediate, but The Flying Club Cup is still full of that wide-eyed explorer charm, even if it takes a little digging to find it. It's more than worth the effort.
Circulatory System Circulatory System
Clues Clues
Converge You Fail Me
Daitro Y
Dan Deacon Bromst
Deltron 3030 Deltron 3030
Fuck Buttons Street Horrrsing
Girl Talk Feed the Animals
Girl Talk Night Ripper
My Bloody Valentine Isn't Anything
Regina Spektor Soviet Kitsch
Shels Sea of the Dying Dhow
The Field Yesterday and Today
Yo La Tengo I Am Not Afraid of You and I Will Beat Your Ass

3 good
Aficionado The Myth About Real Life EP
Animal Collective Danse Manatee
Animal Collective Water Curses EP
Beirut Lon Gisland EP
Converge No Heroes
Daitro Des Cendres, Je Me Consumme
Dan Deacon Spiderman of the Rings
Deerhunter Rainwater Cassette Exchange EP
Fucked Up The Chemistry of Common Life
Grizzly Bear Horn of Plenty
Grouper Cover the Windows and the Walls
Kidcrash Snacks
Modern Life Is War Midnight in America
Regina Spektor Begin To Hope
Say Anything In Defense of the Genre
The Field From Here We Go Sublime
The Flaming Lips Christmas On Mars
Why? Eskimo Snow
Yoni Wolf has always been a man who lets conviction speak for his content, where the vibrant imagery of "Good Friday" is bowled over by his lack of charisma, turning fractured pop into bursts of slice-of-Hell-hole realism (for pasty white kids in suburban hell holes, anyway). It certainly didn't hurt that Why? side-saddled hip-hop like it was going out of style. So what is Eskimo Snow? It is the band being influenced by the influences Wolf is always spouting but never really indulging. It is Wolf growing up but not out, for the first time letting his big emotions yield bigger results. It is an Indie Rock Record without the elements that made WHY? who they were, left instead to flounder about Wolf's unhinged (and unchanged) lyricism. The effect is mostly haphazard and creepy, with standout "Into the Shadows of My Embrace" highlighting all that is haphazard and creepy about what ends up being the musical equivalent of all the different words eskimos have for snow. 50 different personalities for the same basic result.

2.5 average
A Sunny Day In Glasgow Scribble Mural Comic Journal
Deerhunter "turn it up, faggot"
Fuck Buttons Tarot Sport
Grizzly Bear Veckatimest
My Bloody Valentine Sunny Sundae Smile
Regina Spektor Far
Vivian Girls Vivian Girls

2 poor
Beirut March of the Zapotec EP
Idiot Pilot Wolves
MGMT Oracular Spectacular
Say Anything Say Anything

1.5 very poor
Idiot Pilot Strange We Should Meet Here
Of Montreal Skeletal Lamping
Panic! At the Disco Pretty. Odd.
Passion Pit Manners

1 awful
Panic! At the Disco A Fever You Can't Sweat Out

FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Site Copyright 2005-2009 Sputnikmusic.com
All Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Privacy Policy