Lots of people think "hey you" is one of skillet's not so great albums, but it is actually one of my favorites of theirs. I understand this may be because it has sentimental value to me personally, as i listened to it a lot at a crucial time in my life. It doesn't reach the heights of comatose or collide, but personally i do love it.
Don't get me wrong, Skillet is a great band, but Hey You is not there best by a long shot. There is too much whispering and the songs have the same style. There is not too much creativity. The songs are hard to distinguish from each other. It is not terrible, but I can't say it is good for Skillet.