Pink Floyd
Wish You Were Here


5.0
classic

Review

by Blair Chopin USER (108 Reviews)
August 9th, 2006 | 68 replies | 3,690 views


Release Date: 1975 | Tracklist


1 of 1 thought this review was well written

After 1973's masterpiece, "Dark Side Of The Moon", Pink Floyd could have released anything and it would have sold plenty of copies. But the band decided a year later to release a omega 5 song album in "Wish You Were Here", every second of the album is just brilliance.

This is Pink Floyd's best album, no doubt. People only say "Dark Side Of The Moon" is because of the amount of copies sold and that it has more than this albums 5 songs. But I believe this is the best lyrical work the band has done. And on this album there are no fillers and it is all just great work.

I think what this album does to perfection is combine the bands to most successful albums "The Wall And Dark Side Of The Moon", the first part of "Shine On You Crazy Diamond", sounds like a crazy 13 minute interlude at first with some very light guitar in the background and what sounds like some noise from out of space. This is the kind of long and experimental song you would find on "Dark Side Of The Moon". But if you wait long enough the guitar gets heavier and it ends up being a perfect opener to this album. The lyrics are great with about every two lines the vocalist coming in and saying the chorus: "Shine on you crazy diamond", with sort of a choir in the background singing with him, this is an overall awesome piece of work done by this band. 5/5


This album is a lot like "The Wall", because of songs trying to make a difference in our society. Scary songs that make you want to pee in your pants "Welcome To The Machine" combines all sorts of weird instruments and it has a weird synthesized sound to go along with the great vocals by the bands lead singer. Near the chorus an acoustic guitar appears and the chorus is sang cleanly and sounds beautiful. Though the song is to weird in some peoples opinion with the combination of all those instruments that it has in it, the song distorted sound and meaningful lyrics make it a classic. 5/5

"Have A Cigar", is the most mediocre song on the album. It is another meaningful song were the band openly again try's to attack the music industry but overall the song lacks structure. I couldn't point out a particular part of the song to you and say "Oh yeah that's the chorus", and with that comes a decent guitar solo. But the impact of this song has inspired and motivated several bands to speak out against what a piece of crap the music industry is. But this is not when the band is at the best, they need the freaky sound of "Welcome To The Machine" and the catchyness and brilliant instrumental work of "Shine On You Crazy Diamond Part 1" to be successful. The song is decent but the instrumental work is sub-par and the song is a step backwards from everything on this album. 3.5/5

"Wish You Were Here", The next track, has to be one of the top 100 songs ever recorded. The song is a soft and simple song by Pink Floyd standards, with a beat that only gets a bit louder during the chorus and some guitar solo in between. But the lyrical work is some of the most beautiful I have ever seen. The opening line is a great tie-in to what the song is going to offer: "So you think you can tell? Heaven from hell" the chorus and the pre-chorus are just magnificent and it's the kind of song that evens though it is over 5 minutes long you just never want it to end. The song has been covered by virtually everyone that can play it, and it should be covered just out of respect. Now there are several songs called "Wish You Were Here", but I don't think any of those songs will ever compare to this one. What a great and timeless piece of work by the band. 5/5

There is no way the second "Shine On Your Diamond" could compare to this cd's opener but it comes pretty close. The beat basically stays the same, with some different lyrics and emotion put into the song. Still a great song but not quite as good as the first offering by the band. 4.7/5

Wow, what an album. There is no way an album like this should ever be overlooked as far as the greatest albums of all-time. This is were some of the freakiest beats and most complicated lyrics come from the band, and it ends up being some of there best work. It is more upbeat than "The Wall", but not as upbeat as "Dark Side Of The Moon" but it still combines both of the albums perfectly.



Recent reviews by this author
Sun Kil Moon BenjiSoundtrack Seeking a Friend for the End of the World
The Avett Brothers The CarpenterNick Drake Bryter Layter
M. Ward Transistor RadioYellowcard When You're Through Thinking, Say Yes
user ratings (4504)
Chart.
4.6
superb
other reviews of this album
1 of

Comments:Add a Comment 
MisterPilgrim
August 9th 2006



233 Comments


Decent review, nothing too great. There are now seven 5-Star reviews of this; just a thought.

Channing
August 9th 2006



497 Comments


Alright job. This was in no way necessary at all.

Angmar
August 9th 2006



2689 Comments


ahhh yes my 3rd fav floyd album!


Patrick
August 9th 2006



1891 Comments


ok review

Bron-Yr-Aur
August 9th 2006



4405 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

Not a good review. It's not bad or anything; just average. It doesn't add anything new, and there are six other 5 star reviews for this.


Oh, and just to throw it out there, I'm reviewing this, it's in the works. :thumb:This Message Edited On 08.09.06

MisterPilgrim
August 9th 2006



233 Comments


Oh, and Dark Side of the Moon was released on 1973.


/tight-ass


Oh, and just to throw it out there, I'm reviewing this, it's in the works


Good. Judging by your score, you're not going to give it a 5, so it seems like a good idea to me.

south_of_heaven 11
August 9th 2006



5433 Comments


Oh, and just to throw it out there, I'm reviewing this, it's in the works.

omg omg omg omg Bron is finally reviewing something again OMFGZ

Channing
August 9th 2006



497 Comments


[Quote=Bee Ron]Oh, and just to throw it out there, I'm reviewing this, it's in the works.[/QUOTE]
I can hardly contain my excitement. This Message Edited On 08.09.06

Bron-Yr-Aur
August 9th 2006



4405 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

Whoa, hey the Good Charlotte fan thinks he's funny. Custis, this is neither the time nor the place. Let us get back on track about this fellow's review, or Pink Floyd.

Channing
August 9th 2006



497 Comments


Whoa, hey the Good Charlotte fan thinks he's funny.

I hate Good Charlotte.

I haven't heard this album. But DSOTM doesn't make me too excited about it.

tom79
August 9th 2006



3363 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

I'm liking Animals more than this at the moment, but this is still a superb album. The review was decent, nothing really different from the bunch before it.

Digging: Joyce Manor - Never Hungover Again

Wildhoodlum
August 9th 2006



45 Comments


Who gives a damn if the review doesn't touch on anything new? The point of Sputnik is that people can review whatever they want, however they want (within reason). This review is fine. Sure, it may not be anything revolutionary, but that doesn't replace quality. I'm not saying it's the best review in the world, but you shouldn't berate it because of that. Oh, and Chan, lighten up, eh?

Bron-Yr-Aur
August 9th 2006



4405 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

Uh... Who said he couldn't review it? No one told him not to, no one reprimanded him for it. But it's hard to judge a review as good when you take into account that it's average, and says nothing that hasn't been said plenty of times already.

Wildhoodlum
August 9th 2006



45 Comments


You're missing my point :-

Anyhoo, that Mr. Pilgrim guy is right. It'll be good for someone to review this and not give it a 5.

Bron-Yr-Aur
August 9th 2006



4405 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

You're missing my point


Sorry

I still stand by what I said though. Mr. Pilgrim... Rather Mysterious fellow.

The Door Mouse
August 9th 2006



2092 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

i just wish there wernt so many 5s for this album

Sepstrup
August 9th 2006



1563 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

People only say "Dark Side Of The Moon" is because of the amount of copies sold and that it has more than this albums 5 songs.


I say it because I think it's a better album.

Digging: How to Dress Well - What Is This Heart?

Two-Headed Boy
August 9th 2006



4527 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

Maybe a non-5 review is in order.

Bron-Yr-Aur
August 9th 2006



4405 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

[quote=Me]Oh, and just to throw it out there, I'm reviewing this, it's in the works.[/quote]

Silly. I like this album more than Dark Side of the Moon, actually.

francesfarmer
August 9th 2006



1477 Comments


I really have a strong distaste for this, but the title track is so damned good. It pretty much brings up the score tenfold, as opposed to what it should be. I want to review it...



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2013 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Privacy Policy