Jane Live



by Joey Mankus USER (8 Reviews)
May 12th, 2017 | 12 replies

Release Date: 2017 | Tracklist

Review Summary: A fantastic live rendition of a classic album that will convert even the staunchest non-listeners of live albums!

Jane Doe is an album that hasn't been topped in the hardcore scene in its 16 years of existence. It's an album that I hated upon first listening, as I believe many fans of the album did, but slowly grew on me with each listen. Even if you find the music on the record completely unlistenable at first due to the density and beyond-intense nature of the music, there's an alluring quality to it that urges you to give it more listening time. It's unlike anything else you'll ever hear. For me personally, as well as a wealth of other listeners, it completely destroyed the barriers of what I thought music could be. I had never heard music this intense until I heard this album, and it opened me up to many new bands with similar styles that I now rank up there with my favorites. Jane Doe is an offensively chaotic exercise in a particular brand of dissonant, ugly and yet simultaneously heartbreaking brand of hardcore that Converge have become known for.

Admittedly, I looked at the announcement for Jane Live with relative indifference. I knew I would listen to it, but for me, live albums have just never been my cup of tea. Although not always true, many of them just seem to find a way to sap any energy that might have been found on the original recordings out of the tracks live, which is ironic considering that there should be MORE energy in a live album. On this live recording of the classic album, that is exactly what Converge did. In fact, I'll go as far as to say this recording blows the original out of the water. It's THAT good.

The major difference between this and the original is the production. On the original recording, the production can be described as midrange-y and harsh. That really isn't a bad thing, as I think it complements the vibe of the record well. However, this live recording is on a whole new level. The kick drum on Ben Koller's set is very noticeably louder and punchier, which really adds a whole new level of intensity to the music. In the original, the drums were present but never seemed to pop out like they do on Jane Live. Frontman Jacob Bannon's distinctive, unintelligible shrieks sound fresh and as subhuman as ever. Kurt Ballou's guitar tone cuts through better than on the original recording, and he does more with less in this setting, seeing as that he is the sole guitarist in the majority of the tracks, save for the last few. I found that I didn't even miss many of the overdubbed guitars found on the original, although when guitarist Steven Brodsky joins the band for the title track at the end of this album, it sounds absolutely massive. Bassist Nate Newton sounds very familiar on here; I couldn't find much difference from the original, however, his backup vocals, particularly the ones found on 'Hell To Pay' are much more present in this mix. I had honestly never heard them in the original, but after going back I could hear them way in the back of the mix to the point where it made no difference if they were there or not. Having his extra screams and backup vocals adds another dimension that was just lost on the original.

I can't review this album without at least touching on the incredible overhaul the artwork received. The main cover, redone by Ashley Rose Couture, is a real life rendition of the iconic Jane Doe artwork, and it is absolutely stunning. Converge have always maintained a visual aesthetic to complement their music, and they did not disappoint on that front in the slightest with this release.

I would highly recommend this live album for those who know and love Jane Doe. For newcomers, listen to the original first. It will give you that much more appreciation for how incredible this live release is!

Recent reviews by this author
Ryan Adams PrisonerAt the Drive-In in•ter a•li•a
Nas IllmaticBruno Mars 24K Magic
Deftones GoreTame Impala Currents
user ratings (102)

Comments:Add a Comment 
May 12th 2017


Great review. Completely agree with your first paragraph as it was a similar experience for me. I really need to hear this at some point.

Has anyone noticed the user ratings for this are sort of weird... has it been investigated? It's just odd that there are 5 '1.0' ratings yet no 1.5 or 2s & only one solitary rating for both 2.5 & 3. Very odd.

Digging: At the Gates - The Red in the Sky Is Ours

May 12th 2017


Album Rating: 3.0

I found this underwhelming but there were a couple of moments that stood out.

May 12th 2017


Album Rating: 3.5

This was good, but the album art is in fact porn.

May 12th 2017


Album Rating: 3.0

It was a bit of a revelation that her eyes are closed haha

May 12th 2017


Album Rating: 3.5 | Sound Off

Well that took a while

Digging: Boris - Dear

May 12th 2017


"It was a bit of a revelation that her eyes are closed haha"

What? They look pretty closed even on the OG

May 12th 2017


cover art is sick

May 12th 2017


Album Rating: 4.0 | Sound Off

I thought the OG was meant to be looking down at the listener, diminishing them in a sense

May 12th 2017


me too, but now I can't see it that way anymore
r u i n e d

Digging: Brandon Seabrook - Die Trommel Fatale

June 21st 2017


Album Rating: 3.5 | Sound Off

It's great at what it does and for what it is but I just wouldn't rate this as high as I would a "real" studio album

June 21st 2017


"I thought the OG was meant to be looking down at the listener, diminishing them in a sense"

Huh I'd never seen it that way before but I can see how it would look like that

I'd always seen it as her having her eyes closed although if I look at it a certain way it can also look like they're wide open and pupil-less and it's kind of terrifying

June 24th 2017


I'd love to hear an Axe to Fall live album. Imo it's the most coherent album this band has released and just as much deserving of a full playthrough as Jane Doe.

You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile


Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z

Site Copyright 2005-2017
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy