Gorguts
Pleiades' Dust


5.0
classic

Review

by noinoeso USER (10 Reviews)
August 21st, 2016 | 25 replies


Release Date: 2016 | Tracklist

Review Summary: Gorguts create a fascinating narrative that uses music as its main vehicle to tell a story.

Gorguts is one of those bands that are always expected to push the envelope with each new release. Since their formation, the group has delivered some of the most well remembered technical death metal albums. Their debut, Considered Dead, was a showcase of raw brutality and power. Then came Obscura, which left its mark thanks to its bizarre experimentation and dissonance. After releasing From Wisdom to Hate, Gorguts disappeared for more than a decade. When the band came back with Colored Sands, a creative and mighty reflection on Tibet's culture and conflicts, they showed they were still at the top of their game. When Luc Lemay, father of this insane project, announced that the next release would be a single, half an hour long track, he set huge expectations.

The first thing that I noticed is how the song takes inspiration from a variety of musical genres, making it Gorguts’ most dynamic work to date. Influence from black metal pioneers Deathspell Omega can be heard on heavier parts of the piece, while calmer parts remove other instruments seamlessly. One of these ventures into a mesmerizing ambient passage that accomplishes a lot with utter minimalism. But perhaps the biggest influence on the track is classical music. Despite being a single piece, it is broken down into movements, each with its contribution to an overarching narrative, and a distinct, memorable sound. Even though the highs and lows are radically different from each other, everything is tied together coherently.

The album also bursts with creativity thanks to the way the EP was composed. Luc created the overall structure of the material and established the underlying mood, and then gave Kevin Hufnagel, Patrice Hamelin, and Colin Marston the opportunity to handle it as they saw fit. All of them are remarkably talented musicians, and their contributions to the music are evident. Kevin, creator of the band Dysrhythmia, is a master of guitar playing and dissonance. Patrice presents a surprising diversity in his drum playing, sometimes even taking the spotlight with his powerful presence. Colin, also a bassist in Dysrhythmia, and producer of this EP, perfects its sound giving texture with his bass playing. Last but not least, Luc delivers the trademark Gorguts screams and lead guitars, which have a dominant strength that guides the flow of the song.

But perhaps the most impressive element of Pleiades' Dust is the way it builds an engaging narrative throughout its 33-minute length. The song chronicles the rise and fall of the House of Wisdom in Baghdad. The lyrics describe how the house came to be in times of darkness. Scholars began using ink to record what they knew, and then built walls from stone to store their writings. Soon, this effort became an unquenchable thirst for knowledge, where insight was translated and put together in compendiums. The city reached a golden age of wisdom and prosperity that was harshly interrupted by the Mongol invasion of Baghdad. Rivers of blood and ink are pictured, as well as a return to the dark ages from which the House of Wisdom once rose: what began as dust returned to dust.

The storytelling is not limited to the lyrics, however. The music takes the central role as the narrator of this tale. At the beginning of the track, the group repeats musical themes, as if the library was being built brick by brick. After this, the music ventures into calmer sections that suddenly erupt into aggressive and chaotic passages, which represent very well the obsessive hunt for wisdom. The song then switches to the ambient passage, that feels like entering into the mind of a scholar, completely enthralled studying the works of the library. The peace is suddenly broken, as riffs that sound like a marching army take over. The music turns the most chaotic on this last movement, matching the described atrocities of war. Almost at the end, the opening riff is reintroduced, showing that everything came back full circle. As the music fades, one is left back in total silence, in a new age of darkness.

Gorguts managed to bring this ambitious idea to life in a way no other band could. The mesmerizing technicality of the song makes this a very tough but rewarding listen, where each detail perfectly fits together. Pleiades' Dust stands as a landmark achievement, where music and narrative intertwine themselves flawlessly. I am sure I will be coming back to visit this compelling story time and time again, to lose myself in its sea of books and exceptional sonic landscape.



Recent reviews by this author
Radiohead The King of LimbsImperial Triumphant Inceste
Cold War Kids Robbers and CowardsSpacebag Pareidolia
Blaze of Perdition Towards the Blaze of PerditionNechochwen Heart of Akamon
user ratings (408)
Chart.
4
excellent
other reviews of this album
Xenophanes STAFF (4.4)
Is "Pleiades' Dust" just 33-minutes of "Colored Sands" condensed into one song? Yeah, it basically i...


Comments:Add a Comment 
zaruyache
August 21st 2016


17533 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5 | Sound Off

Pos'd.

Digging: Gabor Szabo - Dreams

AsleepInTheBack
August 21st 2016


4713 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

Great review, posd. I take it this may not be the best release to get into these guys? A 30 min track sounds hard to digest haha

RikRoach7
August 21st 2016


2320 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

Most Gorguts albums are hard to digest, but this one especially and it's not one of their better ones either imo. I recommend going chronologically, even though I personally started with Colored Sands which is still my favorite of theirs.

AsleepInTheBack
August 21st 2016


4713 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

Cheers man, was considering starting with coloured sands but ill check their debut first

RikRoach7
August 21st 2016


2320 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

As the first paragraph says, Gorguts is a band that has evolved drastically, so don't expect it to sound anything like later outputs. It's quite an essential death metal release though. Later albums are much more extreme musically and technically.

frigyourgenre
August 21st 2016


3631 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Debut is kinda snore

SCREAM!
August 21st 2016


14732 Comments


Debut is a sweet "standard" DM album. Subpar by Gorguts standards but still as good or better than most dm

AsleepInTheBack
August 21st 2016


4713 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

Good to know. Looking forward to digging into these guys discog either way

noinoeso
August 21st 2016


9 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

The cool thing about Gorguts is that each album is unique. All their albums are great, but there is a lot of discussion on which one is the personal favorite.

SIIMBOLIC
August 21st 2016


706 Comments


Most prob prefer obscura but I'm a coloured sands man

RikRoach7
August 21st 2016


2320 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

Every album has its fanbase so it's just logical to listen to each of them to form an opinion about them. Like I said, Colored Sands is my favorite. Considered Dead and this one are my least favorites, but they're still good. Their sound changed from release to release, so it's every one's own decision which sound they like best.

Brewtality91
August 22nd 2016


666 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Considered Dead rules and it's a really great start to get into Gorguts.

AsleepInTheBack
August 22nd 2016


4713 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

Looking forward to checking their discog then. Btw noinoeso, your avatar rules.

AsleepInTheBack
August 22nd 2016


4713 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

Found a limited to 500 orange copy of this at my local record store, impulse buy. I suppose I'm starting with this one haha

Ocean of Noise
August 22nd 2016


9682 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Debut is a sweet "standard" DM album. Subpar by Gorguts standards but still as good or better than most dm




I find the riffing is pretty simplistic on that album. It works, and it's a very consistent album, but it's nothing spectacular. It's like a low 4

Digging: Therion - Vovin

BigPleb
August 22nd 2016


50974 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

Band is the best ever.



Great rev man, pos.

Ocean of Noise
August 22nd 2016


9682 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Still need to check this EP. I loved Colored Sands so I should dig

BigPleb
August 22nd 2016


50974 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

It's typically amazing, but you already knew that.



I mean...its Luc Lemay.

Totengott
August 22nd 2016


4123 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

And Luc Lemay stands for top tier metal.

Digging: Amenra - Live I

BigPleb
August 22nd 2016


50974 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

He's a god among men, dude is so humble in interviews as well.



It's almost as if he has no idea how good he is.



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2017 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy