Minus the Bear
Highly Refined Pirates


4.5
superb

Review

by YDload USER (16 Reviews)
May 13th, 2006 | 366 replies | 24,990 views


Release Date: 2002 | Tracklist


9 of 9 thought this review was well written

When a band like Minus The Bear arrives on the scene, it's hard not to hear their music and think to yourself "Wow, these guys sound so cool!" Not necessarily "cool" as in "awesome," but just totally and completely chill. When you hear the content, occasionally profound lyrics pour smoothly from vocalist and rhythm guitarist Jake Snider, you realize that he's just completely committed to hanging out at the beach on a cool California night and spending some time with his significant other (often after having a few drinks). Indeed, nearly every song on MTB's first full-length album is about nothing more than drinking and girls. But does that make them shallow? Is Highly Refined Pirates an album completely devoid of any real intellectual value? Of course not. The obvious meanings of the album's individual songs are nothing compared to the overall effect produced by the songs and the pictures they paint.

For some people, Minus The Bear's lyrics may be nothing more than mushy love songs or meaningless glimpses into the lives of a cosmopolitan Californian couple enjoying their relationship together as wild and carefree young adults. But to remove the lyrics from the context of the music is missing the point entirely! It's only by listening to the songs as a whole (and the album as well) that you can really understand how heart-achingly beautiful and full of meaning this record is. Not to mention that the total sum of Minus The Bear's efforts results in an album that is truly unique. But what kind of musicians could possibly unite to form such a one-of-a-kind band?

Dave Knudson is the lead guitarist of Minus The Bear, but before this band was formed he was in a very different group. Dave was once the guitarist for Botch, a metalcore band, and now that he is in a decidedly non-metallic group like Minus The Bear, what can his considerable shredding skills do for them? Quite a lot, as it turns out. Using two-handed tapping, Knudson is able to add delicate, almost piano-like melodies with a technique that is usually reserved only for lightning-fast Eddie Van Halen-types. Listen to the verses of "Spritz!! Spritz!!!" and you'll hear something that at first sounds like normal staccato guitar strokes. But listen more carefully and you'll hear no strumming at all; it's just Knudson providing his lead guitar skills in a completely different style than some might be used to. The rhythm section is certainly not going to underperform on this album, either. Bassist Cory Murchy is nearly always audible, especially given the album's tendency for such subdued guitar melodies. As for drummer Erin Tate, his playing is simply phenomenal. His up-tempo, energetic beats on songs like the aforementioned "Spritz!! Spritz!!!" provide a great driving feeling to a song which is, not coincidentally, about driving. He also has some great danceable beats throughout the album, but doesn't fall into the trap of sounding like a New Wave drum machine. And in slower parts like the shimmering intro to "Absinthe Party At the Fly Honey Warehouse," his delicate cymbal crashes and snare rolls really add to the atmosphere of Knudson's quiet tapping. It makes the listener feel as if they're slowly tip-toeing into the calm night's sea, and as the drumming slightly picks up one feels as if they've finally taken that plunge into the deeper water and are ready for a nice swim. Such an amazing, controlled use of percussion is just one aspect of why Minus The Bear is so unique. Their song titles are another...

You may notice that I've only mentioned a few individual songs by name here, and a glance to the album info column to the right shows them all. The song titles are ridiculous and usually humorous, while the titles of some of the interlude tracks are quotes from the film Starship Troopers. If you were to judge the band by the song titles alone, you might think they were a pop-punk band. But make no mistake about it: while Minus the Bear may share the catchiness and carefree spirit of many MTV-favorite power pop groups, their musical technicality and lack of whininess thoroughly sets them apart (not to mention that they just don't sound anything alike!).

So while you may scoff at the band on the basis of their song titles, I highly encourage you to look past that unpleasant labeling and really explore the album for its true nature. Check out their [url=http://youtube.com/watch?v=6igPbVaUSAU&search=minus%20the%20bear]live performance of the previously mentioned "Spritz!! Spritz!!!"[/url] to get a feel for one of the albums highlights. It also showcases Dave Knudson's guitar tapping and the extreme power behind the drumkit. Although I may have been a little harsh on the lyrics of the album, I think that there are certain examples that really stand out. Take the chorus of the beautiful-yet-subdued song "Get Me Naked 2: Electric Boogaloo":

You said, 'My life's like a bad movie,'
And I said, 'It's true of all us.'
You said, you said, 'I've got to wake up so fucking early,'
And I said, 'Maybe the directors turned on us.'


Even if those words don't strike you as profound at first glance, it's hearing them sung and in the full context of the song that really allows them to hit home. Every once in a while, the protagonist of the songs in Highly Refined Pirates knows when to stop talking about having sex in the water (i.e. "Women We Haven't Met Yet") and makes the observations that really mean something. I hope that in time, more people can discover the unique and "chill" qualities of this band, but until then I can't exactly call this album a 5/5 classic. I'm giving it a 4.5 because it will never be "perfect" until it has the kind of impact it deserves, but it's always possible in the future.

I also wish I could have taken more time to talk about individual songs. After all, most of my reviews are in the infamous track-by-track format. But I've given so much thought to the album as a whole, that the only thing you should imply from it is that you should really hear the whole album. That's probably my best recommendation to give you, rather than just a few songs. I hope you can find this band as interesting and captivating as I clearly do.



Recent reviews by this author
Minutemen Double Nickels on the DimeAt the Drive-In Vaya
Iron Maiden The Number of the BeastSublime Sublime
Weird Al Yankovic UHFWeird Al Yankovic Running With Scissors
user ratings (807)
Chart.
4
excellent
other reviews of this album
Eric (4.5)
The sound of a humid, summer night gone right...

Adam Turner-Heffer (4.5)
...


Comments:Add a Comment 
FA
May 13th 2006



127 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

Great review, YDLoad. I completely agree with you that you should really hear the entire album. Listening to a couple songs might not make as big of an impression on the listener like the entire album would. Nice review.This Message Edited On 05.13.06

YDload
May 13th 2006



1207 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

How did I do on the length of this review? I keep thinking it looks a little short, but that may just be the album info box being so long (with all the song titles). I guess my track-by-track reviews were longer because of all the paragraph breaks, but this took me a while to write so I guess the length is good?

JohnXDoesn't
May 13th 2006



1267 Comments


I like your review. The length is just about perfect, and you made it an entertaining read. I don't know if this is my cup of tea, but your review has convinced me to at least check it out. It get's the thumbs up. But I swear to you if I find even one stolen riff on the whole disc, it's getting microwaved! :pThis Message Edited On 05.13.06

Zebra
Moderator
May 13th 2006



2647 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

The review was informative and like JXD said the length was just about perfect. I'd actually give this album a 3.5/5 rather then a 4.5/5. There are some excellent songs such as the first two and my personal favorite Get me Naked 2: The Electric Bogaloo. However I think the album gets a bit boring and almost to chilled out at points especially on songs like We Are Not a Football Team and the lengthy Let's Play Guitar in a Five Guitar Band.

Pyramidman
May 13th 2006



1340 Comments


Its alright YDload, your review is great

I love these guys, and i never realized how amazing their guitarist was, and thankx for the live vid, sweet!!!

Dancin' Man
May 13th 2006



719 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

It starts to sound boring after a while but I love it. Good review too.

Med57
Moderator
May 13th 2006



1001 Comments



How did I do on the length of this review? I keep thinking it looks a little short, but that may just be the album info box being so long (with all the song titles). I guess my track-by-track reviews were longer because of all the paragraph breaks, but this took me a while to write so I guess the length is good?


Yeah, it's a great review all round. Kind of like the middle bowl of porridge selected by Goldilocks. It's a very cool album though. I don't love it as much as you do, but you've got the mood of it exactly right.

YDload
May 13th 2006



1207 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

There are some excellent songs such as the first two and my personal favorite Get me Naked 2: The Electric Bogaloo. However I think the album gets a bit boring and almost to chilled out at points especially on songs like We Are Not a Football Team and the lengthy Let's Play Guitar in a Five Guitar Band.


Yeah I know what you mean, that was one of the things I neglected to mention about certain songs. "We Are Not A Football Team" is a bit too chill and doesn't really go anywhere as a song. But it's really great to listen to through headphones when walking around on a calm night, I can tell you that much!

But then again "Get Me Naked 2" is probably the most subdued song on the album, and I don't have a problem with it at all. It's probably because of the lyrics I mentioned, or the addition of female background vocals. That makes it feel like the girlfriend mentioned in almost every song is finally speaking for herself


STFDood84
June 20th 2006



179 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Great album, a bit more rockin' and uptempo than Menos El Oso, but still retaining those chill qualities that Minus is known for. Dave Knudson's guitar work is simply brilliant here, too. I slightly prefer the newer one over this, but you can't go wrong with Monkey Knife Fight, Spritz, or Electric Boogaloo 2. 4/5

halfdeadhippo
December 10th 2006



52 Comments


This band has moments that go from reminding me of "Subterranean Homesick Alien" to reminding me of Dredg to reminding me of the trashiest 80's dance music I can imagine. I love it.

UrbanM11
December 10th 2006



117 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

great review. I totally got that chill feeling from listening to this cd too. Minus the bear rock

alurny
January 27th 2007



22 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Great CD. Nice atmospheric and often technical indie/rock. Nice review, you captured the albums style perfectly. Really, really digging their music right now.

Also the interlude song titles are from the greatest film ever ;)

aircycle
July 9th 2008



890 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

I love this. End of Crisco Twister, Absinthe Party, Get Me Naked 2, Spritz!!! Spritz!!!, and We Are Not a Football Team are really really really good.

Let's Play Guitar... could have been at least one minute shorter though.This Message Edited On 07.09.08

natey
September 10th 2008



4170 Comments


"We Are Not A Football" team is the best

HighandDriving
September 10th 2008



3261 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

Not the best on the whole album but an awesome song indeed.

Digging: Nightmares - Suspiria

Granfalloon
October 6th 2008



176 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

this album is stupendous, absinthe is my favorite with women we... in a close second

McP3000
October 6th 2008



3941 Comments


albums so much fun

HighandDriving
October 6th 2008



3261 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

http://www.pitchforkmedia.com/article/record_review/19929-minus-the-bear-highly-refined-pirates

Can I get a "fuc k pitchfork"?This Message Edited On 10.06.08

Granfalloon
October 6th 2008



176 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

"fuc k pitchfork"

*many voices of MTB adorers in unison

McP3000
October 6th 2008



3941 Comments


i love how the guitars on this disc involve so many tapping riffs

its refreshing, albeit monotonous at timesThis Message Edited On 10.06.08



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2013 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Privacy Policy