Heir Apparent
Graceful Inheritance


3.0
good

Review

by DrJohn USER (22 Reviews)
July 10th, 2014 | 17 replies


Release Date: 1986 | Tracklist

Review Summary: A forgotten metal gem?

Heir Apparent was a Seattle based metal band formed in 1983 by guitarist Terry Grole. Their 1986 debut album “Grateful Inheritance” was not released in the US, but had its share of semi-success in continental Europe. Terry Gorle and bassist Derek Peace, share most of the songwriting credits. A mix of early Maiden aesthetics governs over, traces of Dio Sabbath, Arch era “Fates” as well and the singer wants to copy a “The Warning” version of Geoff Tate. Hell of a mix if done correctly, most would nod. Many rank this as a forgotten metal gem.

What went wrong and Heir Apparent disbanded, following another release three years later? Putting aside band interrelationship friction (Terry’s bandmates tried and managed to screw him off the band), I will focus on musical incongruities traced back to this release.

Lyrics anent dragons, cloaks and heroic destiny certainly were not out of fashion in 1986, but be warned about that aspect, if you are not a fan of such narratives. Contrary to consensus, what really hurts “Grateful Inheritance” is the production, post production mainly. Semi-pro recording is one thing, justifiable by a low budget amounting to borrowed money… some may even state that this adds to the rawness or the sincerity of the recording, the cult effect. Bad mixing and mastering spells bigger problems though, unless you are fond of uneven sonic results or you fancy tracks sounding like they belong to a different cut.

Furthermore, regarding four string application; I could forgive unswinging metal bass lines, being frontline in the mix under certain conditions: The lines must add something to the tune, density perhaps or a trip away from the guitar parts. Either add counter lines like Geezer Butler, or unconventional rhythmic use of the instrument itself, like Steve Harris. Unfortunately, the appliances of Derek Peace are pretty generic and should have a less prominent spot... Plus bass frequencies have a nasty habit of engulfing all the other instruments, if not dealt properly during the mixing and mastering procedures (notice how trebly Steve Harris selects to be -or Martin selected him- when so in front). The end result in “Graceful Inheritance” is a vanguard of bass thumping round the root of each chord and underneath drums, guitars and vocals… muffled.

The above is unfortunate, because what is muffled underneath is actually good, not consistently great throughout the recording but in portions it can be satisfying for the classic metaller.
“Another Candle”, sounds like it came out from Queensryche’s EP, and that spells good stuff in my books. The guitar play through this album is smart regarding the rhythm parts, the riffs have a Manilla Road-esque fuzziness, unstatic as well, providing an element of much needed motion… too bad they take back sit in the mix. On the contrary, leads are not so smart, trying to tip toes in shredding waters as evident in “Running from the Thunder” -wanking the floyd rose won’t make you a shredder- nonetheless sporadic melodic fills, serve their purpose tastefully breathing brakes now and then. Paul Davidson is a competent screamer, but not a top class one…as in “The Keeper of the Reign” a promising tune in all honesty, at times he sounds like reaching for higher registers than he should, falling flat and falsetto thin . As I said in the prologue he wants to copy early Geoff maybe…or the songwriters wanted him to sound as such, he screaks out some Dianno like screams now and then…maybe more fitting of his range…maybe out of frustration.

Otherwise I presume that “Hands of Destiny” catchiness could even find some radio play back in the day, if it was not for the aforementioned four string anomalies. Derek Peace flirts out of rhythm here…
Regardless, along with “Keeper of the Reign” this maybe the best cluster of metal present, even if the latter should stop at the 2.51 mark instead of venturing into a redundant 4.50. Duration issues become further evident on tracks such as “Masters of Invasion”, which makes me point out… There are no epics with regard to time yet a bunch of 4.30 to 5.00 minute long tracks, would serve this album much better, if they where cut down to the three minute mark. “The Cloak” and “Dragon’s Lair” are excellent examples of what short tunes can accomplish. I am left with that demand for duration efficiency, throughout the three quarters of the hour this album lasts. Oh and there is a track with no reason to exist at all… filler definitive:
The instrumental “R.I.P”, needless guitar and bass interplay reaching the five minute mark.

At the end of the day and…Dogro lived on, borderlines lyric ponderosity contradicting adequate riffage, “Grateful Inheritance” as a whole, leaves me wondering what would happen if some of the former issues where addressed, it leaves me feeling sad for Terry Grole, cause some of these misdemeanours could have been subsided one way or the other…the bass in the mix, proper mastering attenuating sonic unevenness, track durations, a bunch not making the final cut…addition by subtraction to sum it up.

Historical value? Yes, when it pertains to US proto-power metal … A forgotten metal gem? Only if this was an EP containing five tracks.
I guess most of you are familiar with early Maiden stuff, go listen to “The Warning” by Queensryche, and early Fates to witness the kind of hybrid, this album wanted to achieve. Hell of a mix if done correctly, most would nod…

Shame I nod back, because… it could have been done, in a more effective manner.



Recent reviews by this author
Wayne Shorter Speak No EvilThe Crazy World of Arthur Brown The Crazy World of Arthur Brown
Wipers Over the EdgePat Metheny Question and Answer
BABYMETAL BabymetalKenny G Breathless
user ratings (15)
Chart.
3.7
great
recommended by reviewer
Queensryche EP

Comments:Add a Comment 
KILL
July 10th 2014


72090 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

nice one dude i prefer their next record tho

Digging: Steve Hackett - Out of the Tunnel's Mouth

DrJohn
July 10th 2014


489 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

“One Small Voice” had a better vocalist (technically at least) in Steve Benito, but production issues where still at large, and some tracks where out of context. Sound of Silence cover for example…

Voivod
Staff Reviewer
July 10th 2014


6286 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

unofficial album stream: http://www.metal-samples.com/search/label/Heir%20Apparent

Very well written review, pos.

Your arguments are solid for the most part, the album is partially flawed, yet it delivers if time and listening sessions are invested in it.

One Small Voice suffered production-wise, but the actual music is great and I like how the Sound of Silence cover turned out to be.

Digging: Madred - Supersonic Brainfuck Overdrive

DrJohn
July 10th 2014


489 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

The first time I listened to "We the people" from the following release featuring Benito, I though that Geoff Tate could file a law suit for vocal tone plagiarism.
This band unfortunately never made it through the point of attaining an identity of its own… that certainly hurt their chances along with the lack of professional approach, either in studio or management-wise.


zaruyache
July 10th 2014


7272 Comments


If I was going to call an album a "gem" I'd be giving it well higher than a 3/5, tbh.

Digging: Sleepytime Gorilla Museum - In Glorious Times

DrJohn
July 10th 2014


489 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

Hmmm... did you read through the review zaruyache?

Voivod
Staff Reviewer
July 10th 2014


6286 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

What I'm about to say may be a blasphemy, but Benito lies on the same level as Tate, if not higher. Even when he whispers (in the Sound of Silence cover), his vibrato is over the sky!

And just because Tate was a high-pitch singer, doesn't mean that other singers cannot sing like that.

As for Heir Apparent's lack of identity, I humbly beg to differ. Their "mistake" was that they joined Black Dragon Records, a small French label with weak distribution/promotion potential, hence they were doomed to fall into obscurity sooner or later.

From what you write in the review, Heir Apparent's lack of professionalism was a given for sure, but if they were signed to labels such as Metal Blade at that time, things would probably be better for them...

DrJohn
July 10th 2014


489 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

Well to each his own. In my opinion Benito could reach the higher registers of Geoff Tate, but not with a full voice (more falsetto approach). My argument though was based on the fact that Queensryche were a well established band by 1989; trying to copy them isn't the best way to go (of course Geoff doesn't have the monopoly of high pitch). As for the French Label which is true, isn't that a direct effect of bad or non-existent management?

ps. I am talking about 1983-1988 Geoff ;)

DrJohn
July 10th 2014


489 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

Btw does anyone know what happened to Benito after Heir Apparent?

Voivod
Staff Reviewer
July 10th 2014


6286 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

As for the French Label which is true, isn't that a direct effect of bad or non-existent management?

That's true.


trying to copy them isn't the best way to go

The Queensryche influences are there on both Heir Apparent albums, but I can't say that any of them was a shameless 'ryche rip off. That's just me, though.

As for Benito, metal archives have only One Small Voice filed under his name. Strange times. Lots of great bands were lost by the turn of the decade and the new music styles that emerged.


Some answers in the following interview explain the mediocre sound production on both Heir Apparent albums:

http://www.ballbustermusic.com/hard_talk/09-2000/heirapparent.html



This interview has some answers about the management, the lack of professionalism and commitment from the rest of the band etc.:

http://crystal-logic.blogspot.gr/2011/10/heir-apparent-terry-gorle-interview.html

DrJohn
July 10th 2014


489 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

No, they were not rip offs by any means (the term "copy" was hyperbolic). Anyway they had the capacity to achieve a greater status...shame.


Hmmm... Cool I will read through the interview later.

manosg
July 11th 2014


6529 Comments


Nice to see a review for Heir Apparent; quite underrated band. I haven't listened to this one but One Small Voice is a great album.

Digging: Witchfynde - Give 'em Hell

Necrotica
July 11th 2014


10063 Comments


Gee, I wonder where Opeth got their song title from, lol

DrJohn
July 11th 2014


489 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

(manosg)
I guess you must give this one a try as well, if you consider One Small Voice great.
Graceful Inheritance is less progressive; no keyboards for the greater part, the vocals are rawer, lyrics are based around fantastic elements contrary to Small Voice, which attempts to tackle more "serious" matters.
I find both albums ranging from adequate to good but that is just my point of view.

(FiveLeaves...)
I was wondering about that as well.

KILL
July 11th 2014


72090 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

or maybe mikaels just into the monarch

DrJohn
July 11th 2014


489 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

That may be KILL... I am not sure if these guys were well known in Sweden tbh.

Snowdog808
September 14th 2014


1722 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

This honestly does not sound up to the level of the Warning, Awaken the Guardian, or Ample Destruction, but it is still a great pre-Seven Keys power metal album.



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2014 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Privacy Policy