Manic Street Preachers
This Is My Truth Tell Me Yours


3.5
great

Review

by Elliott S. Edwards STAFF
March 11th, 2014 | 13 replies


Release Date: 1998 | Tracklist

Review Summary: Under Neon Loneliness, CHAPTER 5: “Sweet Cherry Blossom Tree, At Least You Are Free…”

By 1998, it was no surprise that the Manic’s were making continuous strides into noticeably different musical genres. By now, the glam punk gesturing the band had built themselves on had all but disappeared with a rather smart working-class look now being the preferred presentation for the band. Predictably, as they moved further away from the memory of Richey Edwards, so too did they the myth and majesty of youth they once pioneered. As maturity became an ever growing concern for an aging band, This Is My Truth Tell Me Yours was in a way a continuation of what was formulated on Everything Must Go, with the band no longer fuelled by electric guitar and fierce political lyricism. However gone now was the excitement, which while in parts was made up for in clever songwriting, became much too difficult to forgive in spots.

Initial signs of punk treason are evident on opener “The Everlasting”, a quaint and mechanical opener that drifts along rather than explodes like the generic Manic’s opener has been known for. While lacking in energy, it remains a rather simple and beautiful song that was never quite achieved before in the Manic’s career, further continued on much of the albums other brilliantly down-tempo numbers. The anti-fascist rhetoric of “If You Tolerate this Your Children Will Be Next” coupled with “Tsunami” are perfect constructions of pop songs in the Britpop environment, never compromising lyrical content for melody that still, funnily enough, comes in spades- it’s safe to say that This Is My Truth is one of the most melodically gifted Manic releases ever.

And then there’s the ‘but’ of it all…

The problem is that, and often recurring across Manic’s releases, is that the band find it difficult to stretch their new found styles across albums, leaving songs that give the distinct feel of filler to them. Tracks such as “Born a Girl” and “Ready for Drowning” provide awkward phrasings and cold environments while the just plain offensive electric drum bounce of “You Stole the Sun from My Heart” is Wire’s ode to hating tours. Unfortunately, it leaves the rather brilliant tracks, of which there are ample, stranded between small sections of boring and disinterested numbers that try to prove Bradfield/Moore don’t need the electric guitar to write a tune.

Rather absent-mindedly, it’s the penultimate “Nobody Loved You” that hits hardest because of its electric guitars sticking out like a sore thumb. A take on the Nirvana/Pixies formula that was ever popular in post-grunge America post-’94, the verses move from quiet and ethereal stanzas to blasts of sonic overdrive and ever ascending vocal lines. Nicky Wire pens lyrics emotionally considered for the fallen Edwards, declaring “Nobody loved you/like me” in a sweet release of repressed emotional torment and alleviation of pressure (since Edwards had disappeared, Wire had been tasked the sole role of lyrical work). As one of the bands best expressions post-Edwards, it seems rather dour that comes in a time when the band tried their hardest to move away from the egotistical nature of the Les Paul and the fury of Bradfield’s lungs; a rather ironic twist of brilliance for the fans and misstep for the band.

This Is My Truth to this day remains the most indecisive piece of works in the Manic’s canon. Technically proficient and brilliantly written in spats, it still lacks energy and a blatant caress of controversy that powered the earlier releases. A necessary evil by some descriptions of the word, it must be said that were it not for This Is My Truth it’s unlikely we would have ever heard of the Manic Street Preachers again. Still, This Is My Truth’s spot as one of the bands weakest releases is often overstated, if only because the rot was just beginning and the future predicted a bigger storm to come.

NEXT: “Brain Dead Mother***ers…”



Recent reviews by this author
Future Islands SinglesAmine Good For You
Jay-Z 4:44Vince Staples Big Fish Theory
Katy Perry WitnessHarry Styles Harry Styles
user ratings (199)
Chart.
3.5
great
other reviews of this album
TrampInDenial (2.5)
...


Comments:Add a Comment 
Arcade
Staff Reviewer
March 11th 2014


8408 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

fifth part of my Manic's series. This is difficult to love but it's also hard to hate because of the greatness that is found here. This is really the last of their 'classic' period (which to some extent ended on EMG), so from here on in the criticism can be expected as harsh. Feedback appreciated

Digging: Zola Jesus - Okovi

Arcade
Staff Reviewer
March 11th 2014


8408 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

Side note; SYMM has got to be the bands worst song

HolidayKirk
March 11th 2014


1721 Comments


Another great review. This is a super boring album. But "The Everlasting" and "If You Tolerate This" are both top tier shit.

Arcade
Staff Reviewer
March 11th 2014


8408 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

yeah besides the singles (save the atrocity "You Stole the Sun...") and "Nobody Loved You" this is pretty average, but lucky enough those handful of songs are so good I decided it deserved a 3.5, although it's probably pushing more a 3.2/3.3

Arcade
Staff Reviewer
March 11th 2014


8408 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

Because I'm a total Manic's fanboy I find it difficult to distinguish their crap from their best stuff but generally speaking I'll accept EMG as their final classic (notwithstanding JFPL)

menawati
March 11th 2014


16582 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5

a few tracks i love on this but overall i never really liked it that much, nice rev and nice series arcade

VermTheImpaler
March 11th 2014


1359 Comments


Tsunami, the everlating and if you tolerate this are great, this album has great track but it has a considerable amount of filler

AliW1993
March 11th 2014


7511 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

I really don't understand the hate for 'You Stole the Sun...' I absolutely love that song.



This record is dull and difficult to get through, but when it hits it hits hard.



Fabulous review again.

Arcade
Staff Reviewer
March 11th 2014


8408 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

Thanks guys for all the kind words!



@Ali: "You Stole the Sun..." is incredibly terrible to me. I never thought the chorus was catchy, it always sounded overdone and besides the last few lines that close the song it's super forgettable

sheelanagig
March 12th 2014


52 Comments


You criticised all my favorite tracks ;(

Crawl
August 26th 2016


2291 Comments


Bought this in Poundland, after first listen I can tell it is pretty overlong. But Manics are never really bad and this isn't either. Just a couple of boring tracks which unfortunately last 5 minutes. "The Everlasting" though, is jut incredible.

becomesmusical
September 17th 2016


82 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Revisiting this review series (which is phenomenal, by the way). I didn't care for this album at all at first, but it really grew on me. I still think tracks 6 through 9, along with "S.Y.M.M.", take a dip in quality, but even then those songs are growing on me as well. Except "Born a Girl" and "S.Y.M.M."; both are throwaway tracks.

TVC15
May 10th 2017


8427 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

This album>Everything Must Go. Fite me

Digging: Godspeed You! Black Emperor - Luciferian Towers



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2017 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy