Porcupine Tree
Signify


4.0
excellent

Review

by Kyle Banick USER (30 Reviews)
April 5th, 2006 | 95 replies


Release Date: 1996 | Tracklist

Review Summary: Caught between Porcupine Tree's psychadelic roots and their song-oriented future, Signify is a testament to Porcupine Tree's power as a dark, brooding album with excellent production and a thoroughly progressive heart.

Signify fits into a nice niche within Porcupine Tree’s extensive discography, while it is also suspended in a strange limbo within the same context. It marks the end an era, while simultaneously ushering in the dawn of a new age. It’s an album that screams, “I put my heart into this; this is what I’ve worked towards my entire life, and here it is,” but it’s also an album that whispers in our ear, telling us there’s much more to come, so much more; a foreshadowing of another decade of greatness and the coming-of-age of a band that would (arguably) almost single-handedly propel progressive rock into the 21st century.

It’s the album that culminates Porcupine Tree’s sound up until this point, and hints at what it would become in the future. While we see much more pop sensibility in this record (as opposed to the Sky Moves Sideways’ 20-minute compositions or Up the Downstair’s detached space rock), we still have those long, ambient, winding instrumental sections that lead us deep into our dreams and back again; from the somehow creepy introduction to the final, epic guitar solo, this album stands as the cornerstone of Porcupine Tree’s discography, and as an accomplishment in the world of rock.

The cover art is where the first step begins. It almost speaks for itself; this album is as enigmatic as it is ambitious and as artistic as it is rockin’. Don’t get the wrong impression, however, and think that when you pop this into your CD player, you’ll be nothing but a puppet, held at the strings by Steven Wilson’s dexterous guitar work and calculated atmospheres. Signify invites you in, lets you “kick your shoes off, and put your feet up and lean back and just relax.” But before the title track even comes to end, you’ll want to submit yourself and give over control. Whether you agree with its anti-religious tendencies or not, the lyrical content is nothing less than brilliant and the structure of the album is one of the best I’ve ever heard. Aside from all that, though, this is just great progressive rock, through and through.

The quote above is taken from the opening introduction track; it’s the crackling voice of an old-fashioned radio announcer, inviting us to take part in the album, an ironically genial supplication, given the overwhelming context of negativity and dark imagery prevalent on the album. Like I said before, several songs are extremely anti-organized religion, even bitterly so. But that brings me to another point: some of the highlights of this album for me are the samples Wilson uses. Whether it’s the voice of a radio announcer, an over-zealous preacher or the maniacal laughing of a madman, it’s used effectively to heighten the atmosphere and make the album more encompassing of its themes Another great thing about this album is that it’s conceptual in the way that it has certain ideas and motifs running through; it’s got several nods towards Wilson’s earlier works, but it’s also very independent of them. It seems to be album that’s just about life. From the chant of “Born. Live. Die. Signify” to the sprawling soundscapes of Waiting Phase II, the varying instrumentation and creativity spreads throughout so many different layers, just as life itself does. It’s about the absurdity of life, it’s about the beauty of it, it’s about the decay of it. It’s about hypocrisy, truth, hallucination. We see traces of existentialism in Wilson’s words as well as his music; Solos whose melodic phrasings are concurrently calculated, yet perfectly spontaneous owe a lot to his predecessors, yet speak volumes about Wilson’s approach to songwriting as an almost out-of-body ritual.

I tend to focus my writing around Wilson, given that he is the main songwriter for the band, but the rest of the members are just as important in their contributions to this album as his songwriting. Who else could bring Wilson’s compositions to life but the jazzy rhythm section of Colin Edwin and Christ Maitland, as well as Richard Barbieri, the analog keyboardist whose ear for texture and dynamics elevates Porcupine Tree’s music into new, unknown heights of experimentation?

Signify begins the album as the first piece of music, starting it off with a jam-based guitar riff that is soon accompanied by creepy, soaring keyboard effect and a very strong bass line. Next comes the album’s first keystone piece, Sleep of No Dreaming, which builds from a simple, quiet organ to huge dissonance at the climax as Wilson cries out from underneath layers of guitars and ambience. Waiting Phase I is a song about being burned out on life, be it from drugs or just general ineptitude. The song starts off with ethnic-sounding percussion and sparse guitar riffs; the chorus displays Wilson’s strange vocal harmonies over strummed acoustic guitar and ambient sounds. Phase II of the same name continues the same musical themes as the previous one, but turns them into a much more vague and sprawling instrumental piece that climbs the ladder of eerie effects and some great guitar work. Sever is a rather dark rocker that switches between tension-building creepiness in the verses with a pedaled piano note to a more soothing, keyboard-driven chorus with some more great vocal harmonies. A strong bass line keeps the rhythm tight and strong as the madman referenced earlier cries out, adding to the sense of unease this song evokes, while Wilson’s vocals brilliantly switch between a desperate cry-out from underneath distorted guitars to a soothing, calm croon in the chorus; one of the best vocal sections on the album comes as Wilson perfectly articulates the foreboding uneasiness, singing, “stage fright, black light, coma divine.”

The album then brilliantly turns the tables, allowing us to rest and be taken away from the nightmare of Sever, into a dream of cloud nine; the floating sound of a flute drives Idiot Prayer, a soothing, tranquil piece that almost seems as if our mind has been severed from our bodies, allowing us to float into a beautiful sunrise. Before long, however, we are unexpectedly blasted into a groove-beat jam, full of ambient tension and samples of a strange man crying out for help while under life-altering hallucinations. His defeated pleas of “please help” punctuate the soundscape, giving the song a strange sense of lost faith and hopelessness. It’s as if Wilson is jerking us back to earth, harshly informing us that our prayers are useless, and we’ve been deceived; heaven, indeed, does not exist.

All this before our hands even stop shaking from stage fright.

Every Home is Wired follows, another more straightforward song in the vein of Waiting Phase I. This is one of those songs that showcases Wilson’s vocal harmonies and foreshadows what was to come with Stupid Dream: more pop-sensible, melody-driven tunes.

The best song on the album follows. Intermediate Jesus is a downright masterpiece, a dark and jazzy instrumental that samples a preacher who tells of the fated Intermediate Jesus. The piano laces itself through the strange, jazzy bass line and jazzy drum beats, while strange and atmospheric guitar noises build and release tension beautifully like a spring. “What are we going to answer these young people today, the young people that are crying out; live fast, look beautiful, die young; tomorrow they drop the bomb,” says the preacher-man, which is followed by a burst of incredible, tension-building guitar noise that signals the climax of the song, fading out as a repetitious piano line creates a hypnotic atmosphere that drains most of our energy, putting us into a state of lethargy. Atmospheric, strange, experimental, beautiful “Intermediate Jesus” almost inescapable hypnosis leads us straight into the minimalist, reverberated sounds of Light Mass Prayers (interestingly enough, composed by Maitland), a floating slice of atmosphere with distant sound effects and a choir of voices that almost elevates, yet impedes peace and warns of danger.

Ah, and here it is. The fabled ending song, Dark Matter, definitely a landmark in the Porcupine Tree landscape. The song starts out with another jazz-tined introduction from the rhythm boys, who beautifully lay down the foundation for Richard’s atmospheric sounds, followed shortly by Wilson himself on guitar and vocals. The song stretches on and on, never ending; and let me tell you, we never want it to. It builds and builds, running the range dynamics until Wilson’s final, epic, climactic guitar solo, crying out above the backing instruments. The lyrics paint a beautifully bleak picture, and this song’s atmosphere ends the album perfectly.

And thus we find ourselves back where we started. The journey this album took us on was one of exquisite beauty and enigmatic intrigue. A perfectly produced, dynamic album full of excellent instrumental work, great lyrical imagery and themes, ambience, atmosphere and the range of human emotions. It contains sprawling, vague instrumental tunes as well as more straightforward, cleverly written songs with a clear-cut song structure. A precursor to Stupid Dream and an epilogue to Porcupine Tree’s psychedelic past.



Recent reviews by this author
Ra Black SunProjeKct X Heaven and Earth
Andrew Hill Compulsion!!!!!The Nels Cline Singers Draw Breath
Queen Elephantine YatraJohn Coltrane Live in Japan
user ratings (849)
Chart.
4
excellent
other reviews of this album
1 of

Comments:Add a Comment 
pattern_recognition
April 6th 2006


950 Comments


Excellent review.
Porcupine Tree rule.

pulseczar
April 6th 2006


2385 Comments


Undoubtedly Porcupine Tree's apex, great work Kage.

carolinaheels387
April 6th 2006


34 Comments


Very solid review, man.


I'm a huge PT fan but I haven't picked this one up. You convinced me, though; I'm getting this one later today.

Keep on reviewing.

Moses
April 6th 2006


32 Comments


Holy crap!! That's a long ass review. I still need this album to rekindle my addiction in PT.

denboy
April 7th 2006


85 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

Great review.. Amazing album
Nothing less than 5/5 from me for this album...

XSebbyMcMuffinX
March 17th 2007


339 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

I love this cd too much.

Yazz_Flute
July 19th 2007


18847 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

Mmm....I own Porcupien Tree's three newest albums, thats it. Should i get this album? It sound really good by your reviewI think i
will get this, itunes just got it, so i should probbly get it before it disapears (they once had every CoB album except HCDR and
now only have AYDY, and i rememebr when i first looked into porcupine tree that had this album and tupid dream as well, but
got rid of them, and now got signify back...itunes is fucked up 0_oThis Message Edited On 01.04.09

Digging: Kenn Nardi - Dancing With the Past

SynGates
July 19th 2007


2467 Comments


thats why i dont use itunes musicstore, that place is terrible. real albums are so much cooler to have, and if they are out of print, then I albumbase them because they're not worth my money.

Yazz_Flute
July 19th 2007


18847 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

yeah they are, but they just take me longer to get and are usually twice as expensive 0_o

SynGates
July 20th 2007


2467 Comments


so true. usually I can get them for ten dollars or less where I go though, which in some cases is less than itunes.
I should get this album.

Confessed2005
January 8th 2008


3314 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Just got hold of this. Listening now and so far it's awesome. Wonderful production too.

Altmer
June 8th 2009


5652 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

not my favourite pt album

scissorlocked
May 21st 2011


3511 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

probably the best porcupine tree album for me

thinkin abooy writing a review

Digging: Distance - Outer Limits

Voivod
Staff Reviewer
May 21st 2011


6269 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

thinkin abooy writing a review






by all means, do it man.

Digging: Electric Moon - Innside Outside

scissorlocked
May 21st 2011


3511 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

thanks bro,maybe I'll try it!!

Insurrection
Contributing Reviewer
July 23rd 2011


21602 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

dark matter is so damn good

Digging: Soen - Tellurian

qwe3
July 23rd 2011


21369 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

ya

linguist2011
Contributing Reviewer
February 12th 2012


1913 Comments


Having perfected their epic, psychedelic take on modern rock, PT were left with two choices: either they would continue their journey into the world of psychedelic music, or change their sound completely by steering towards a more mainstream approach using techniques from the progressive rock genre. It seems they ignored these two choices, and interestingly combined them, to make a somehow difficult yet pleasing transition from psychedelic to progressive rock. On 'Signify', there are still instances of Psychedelic rock that had been used earlier in their career, but the guitar has also been favoured more here, as on the title track and 'Darkmatter' (the latter of which featuring a beautiful solo mid-song). Except for the two tracks running under two minutes and 'Light mass prayers', this album should quench the thirst of modern progressive rock fans.

Digging: Obliterations - Poison Everything

Sound
February 12th 2012


3904 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

Personally 'Light Mass Prayer' quenches my modern progressive rock thirst.

dannyboy89
December 17th 2013


12708 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0 | Sound Off

Surprised that this album doesn't get much discussion.



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2014 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Privacy Policy