Silverstein
When Broken Is Easily Fixed


3.0
good

Review

by Michael Roberts USER (99 Reviews)
April 3rd, 2006 | 63 replies


Release Date: 2003 | Tracklist


Silverstein has drive; let that sink in. Their slogan is always on tour, and they sure is hell do not lie. I have had the privilege of seeing them twice in less than four months. Over the past few years they have built of quite a fan base. In fact, at both of the shows I saw them, they were co-headlining and when the headliner got on stage their crowd was noticeably smaller than Silverstein's; with good reason I might add. Silverstein is on Victory Records, easily one of the most ridiculed labels out there today for being bland, unoriginal and bland. Silverstein is none of those things. To me, Victory is only temporary for Silverstein as the band has the potential to move on to bigger and better things. When Broken Is Easily Fixed is Silverstein's first release after signing to Victory and they have only improved since this album.

Silverstein is
Shane Told - Vocals
Josh Bradford - Guitar
Neil Boshart - Guitar
Bill Hamilton - Bass
Paul Koehler - Drums

From the intro of Smashed Into Pieces anticipation and excitement are present. Its build up is the perfect for the start of the album as Shane screams out the first few lines. His scream has its moments but for the most part is pretty mediocre in this album; definitely listenable nevertheless. The singing is much better. Shane has a great range which has only improved as time has gone on. The verse is a nicely done with a chord progression and a mix of screaming and singing. In the chorus it becomes obvious that Silverstein uses their two guitarists to their advantage. A nice riff plays throughout the chorus while the rhythm section holds it all together nicely. The chorus seems to grasp onto your brain and never let go, as it is very nicely done. Some more little leads are played toward the end of the song and Smashed Into Pieces starts this album off on a good note.

Variety is shown right away as a clean riff opens up in Red Light Pledge . Shane's vocal range is shown on this as the singing is great. However I feel the screaming brings it down. Some very fitting melodic guitar plays through the outro of this song. Not the best this disk has to offer at all. Giving Up starts off at the same pace as the previous track but picks up on during the chorus. The chorus becomes a bit too repetitive and once again the screaming brings it down. Another soft intro courtesy of November is upon us. The album has been at a much slower pace since its opener, which is not a bad thing at all. This is a good song, not too much to say about any instrument drastically sticking out aside from some nicely placed drum rolls towards the end. The vocals are great on both ends, the screaming fits in and everything else stays tight. The screaming at the very end does get a little tedious but overall November is a great track. Last Days of Summer follows the same slow first half and sped up last half formula as some of the preceding tracks. I like the flow and mood created by the verses and chorus. However the breakdown towards the end is a bit cheesy but is listenable at very least.

Time for a change, Bleeds No More picks things up. The little riff played during the chorus is very nice, not over done but simple, fitting and effective. One major complaint is the songs slower clean part. It just does not feel right and I feel the song would have been stronger if it had kept its fast pace throughout. Not a bad song, but there are some flaws to pick at.

Ok Hear Me Out gets its own paragraph. Right from the intro you know you are in for something cool. The perfect amount suspense is built by the effects until a clean riff and a bass drum come in. This song has so much going for it. The singing is excellent and seems to be the focal point of the song as the guitars form a tight rhythm section throughout the first verse and chorus. As the second verse comes in, some riffs are brought out perfectly complimenting Shane's vocals. The little bit of screaming present is sprinkled in very tastefully, and once again Shane shows his amazing range. The clean bridge in this song works much better than its previous attempt and a superb harmonized riff follows. One last chorus is sung over the harmonized riff ending one of the best songs on the record.

The Weak and the Wounded opens clean but quickly has the silence sliced by screaming. This song goes back and forth between quiet singing and screaming for the first 35 seconds or so. I find it to be quite annoying actually. Around the first minute a pretty sweet riff comes through along with some pinch harmonics. Yes pinch harmonics, who said you had to be a metalcore band to use them anyways. After the intro the rest of the song is pretty enjoyable. There is a good deal amount of screaming towards the end but it is much better than in some of the previous songs. At this point in the record it is hard to tell whether the screaming is actually getting better or whether it is growing on the listener. Similar to the previous track Wish I Could Forget You starts off with a clean guitar, much more upbeat however. The song drags on a bit but the clean guitar work is very enjoyable. The vocal presentation is a bit tedious thus the lugging on of the song.

When Broken Is Easily Fixed opens heavy on the vocal front. Someone else I believe screams on this song, allowing for dual vocals to come through. They work fairly well overall but I am not a huge fan of the screaming here. The clean bridge works alright, does not fit the song all that great but is listenable. The ending drags on but some cool guitar harmonization is present. At the very end of the song the dual vocals reach a peak, sounding very nicely complimenting each other. Friends In Fall River does not sound like a song Silverstein would right. That is more of a compliment than an insult as this is a very interesting song. Once again the guitar is praiseworthy throughout the song. The verse licks are extremely tasteful and add a nice touch to the song. Shane�s singing at the end sounds fantastic and even more great guitar is played under it, creating a very nice outro. This would have been a great song to end the record on.

The album closes with Forever and a Day opening with great dual guitar work. The bass stands out on the intro creating one of the most enjoyable instrumentals of the album. No crazy guitar or bass is going on, it just all sounds very thought out and well placed and executed. This song sounds a little more depressing as a whole than most. The vocals are sung very well and the guitar remains consistent throughout. Overall this is a pretty good song but its placement is not very good. This would have been a much better song towards the beginning or middle of the album. In other words, I like the song just not the album ending on it.

With their Victory debut, Silverstein has done a very nice job. Their overall sound changed throughout the album as variety is shown, the guitars work great together, and the vocals are great for the most part. If you picked up this album expecting constant screaming and power chords you will either be disappointed or pleasantly surprised. The labels put on this band are very deceiving. Silverstein is a very talented band and more importantly they possess the drive it takes to be noticed. This being their first album is truly something, as they have only improved from here.

Pros...
-two guitarists are very present and commendable throughout
-excellent singing
-variety in sound and structure
-mood changes throughout the album add a nice touch

Cons...
-some of the softer songs drag on
-the screaming is very mediocre at times
-drums do not stand out much

The bottom line with this album is that it is a great start for a very talented band. If you enjoyed this album and have not already picked up their latest release Discovering the Waterfront you need to right away. Even if you were not a big fan of this record I think checking the new album or at least a few songs is a decent idea. If you are a fan of Hawthorne Heights you should definitely check this band out, they will most likely have you saying "Hawthorne who?" Overall this is a great release by the band and is recommended.

Final Rating 3



Recent reviews by this author
Dead By Sunrise Out of AshesLoveHateHero America Underwater
All Time Low Nothing PersonalSilverstein A Shipwreck in the Sand
Sing It Loud Come AroundA Skylit Drive Wires...and the Concept of Breathing
user ratings (670)
Chart.
3.4
great
other reviews of this album
RobH (4.5)
While not quite as spectacular then some of the albums that have succeeded it, Silverstein created a...

labonza01 (3.5)
...

screamo_rocks_101 (4)
...


Comments:Add a Comment 
Thor
April 3rd 2006


10200 Comments


A very solid review, good sir. I'm not big on Silverstein though.

The Jungler
April 3rd 2006


4827 Comments


I don't mind some Silverstein though they are pretty unoriginal. They have a decent singer, but he should stick to singing and stop screaming, because he's bad at it.

Good Review.This Message Edited On 04.03.06

Tam-Tam
April 3rd 2006


93 Comments

Album Rating: 1.0

Good review. Terrible band.

B
April 3rd 2006


26 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

Great review, Silverstein are great live, but on record they lack something.

pixiesfanyo
April 3rd 2006


1223 Comments


They're pretty typical and shitty.

Storm In A Teacup
April 3rd 2006


13161 Comments

Album Rating: 1.0

This album is dreadful, their second is an improvement, but still lacks something.

Iluvatar
Staff Reviewer
April 3rd 2006


16089 Comments

Album Rating: 1.5 | Sound Off

They are a bland, unoriginal, bland band on a bland, unoriginal, bland label. Good review though.

Two-Headed Boy
April 3rd 2006


4527 Comments

Album Rating: 1.0

I've been thinking of getting this for quite some time.

Good review.

pattern_recognition
April 3rd 2006


950 Comments


Good review. Pretty naff band. The singer annoys me. Smashed Into Pieces has a few good riffs though.

labonza01
April 4th 2006


546 Comments


dear lord people, what is up with all the "i hate Silverstein" comments. not to be offensive, but i doubt any of you could do better, and i dont mean this to be mean, its just what i believe to be true. anyway, good review, too bad it overshadows mine. i agree mostly, except november has some of my favorite guitar parts on the album aside from smashed into peices and when broken is easily fixed, in which the guest screamer is kyle bishop. the sreaming has improved since here though, its not so girly in DTW, but i think he screams well here too.

Iluvatar
Staff Reviewer
April 4th 2006


16089 Comments

Album Rating: 1.5 | Sound Off

It doesnt matter if we can do better or not, they're the ones who put out below average music to the masses.

jrprankst
April 4th 2006


4 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

are you sure the last two are on this cd cause they're not on mine or are they listed on plyrics.com under the cd.

Tam-Tam
April 4th 2006


93 Comments

Album Rating: 1.0

I forgot the part where being able to do something better than someone else, rules out the opinion of the non-participant.
This is a review site. People post comments about reviews, artists and albums. If one cannot handle the opinions of the public, perhaps one should either shield themselves from it, or stay away altogether.

ToWhatEnd
April 4th 2006


3172 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

jrprankst,

They are bonus tracks.

Storm In A Teacup
April 4th 2006


13161 Comments

Album Rating: 1.0

[quote=]dear lord people, what is up with all the "i hate Silverstein" comments. not to be offensive, but i doubt any of you could do better, and i dont mean this to be mean, its just what i believe to be true. anyway, good review, too bad it overshadows mine. i agree mostly, except november has some of my favorite guitar parts on the album aside from smashed into peices and when broken is easily fixed, in which the guest screamer is kyle bishop. the sreaming has improved since here though, its not so girly in DTW, but i think he screams well here too.[/quote]:rolleyes: Oh please. This is almost another form of etlitism because you're trying to tell us we can't have our own opinions because of this, or that. Anyone can think anything about whatever they want, and oh yeah, I've played guitar for only a few months, and I've written better licks than what is on this piece of crap.This Message Edited On 04.04.06

labonza01
April 4th 2006


546 Comments


wow, that got blown way out of proprotion. i never said you cant voice your opinions, so stop putting words in my mouth. i just implied a minor annoyance at all those types of comments. and kripes, are you not one of the people who wrote a raving review for DTW? and i would absolutely love to hear some of your "amazing" guitar licks. i have nothing against you, try not to change that.

Iluvatar
Staff Reviewer
April 4th 2006


16089 Comments

Album Rating: 1.5 | Sound Off

If you didnt meant it in that way, then why mention it?

And I hate to say something for someone else when I havent been here long, but Kripes' review of BTW gave it a 3.5. Far from raving, more of a general approval, wouldn't you say?

pattern_recognition
April 4th 2006


950 Comments


Iluvatar speaks the truth.
That 'amazing guitar licks' thing was a bit low too, IMO.

labonza01
April 4th 2006


546 Comments


well, because im doing what all of you so strongly advocate, im voicing my opinion. its all just an opinion, so take no offense to it, and if i say he is raving, then that is what i think, if you say he wasnt, then thats what you think.

Iluvatar
Staff Reviewer
April 4th 2006


16089 Comments

Album Rating: 1.5 | Sound Off

Well, if the opinion has no point to it, it's rather useless, so dont take offense to us advocating what you advocate we advocate.

And I dont think I took offense, I was just presenting my opinion on the matter. It's all indirectly giving this album more attention by keeping it commented, so lets all give a round of applause for Silverstein. Excuse me while I go put on my the Bled shirt and throw in The Silence in Black & White.



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2014 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Privacy Policy