Porcupine Tree
Octane Twisted


3.5
great

Review

by Alex Beebe USER (126 Reviews)
November 21st, 2012 | 53 replies


Release Date: 2012 | Tracklist

Review Summary: Even if it’s an inferior version of the original studio recordings, Octane Twisted accomplishes the tricky task of performing a concept album live.

When an artist releases a concept album, touring the record can be risky. If the concept album is very involved in itself and is meant to be listened to - as well as best enjoyed - as a whole, performing the album’s songs out of context, out of order, not playing most of the songs from the concept album, or arranging them to be mixed in a setlist among songs from the band’s other albums that are not involved with the records specific concept, can usually really detract from the immersive effect of the music’s concept.

But Porcupine Tree chose not to deprive their audiences of a single second of their ambitious concept double LP The Incident while touring the album throughout 2010. Much like the studio version, Octane Twisted is spaced out across two discs, and just like the studio version, the first of the discs features The Incident’s 55 minute self titled suite performed live in its entirety. The aspect of The Incident that played the most major primary role in the album’s concept was this self titled 55 minute epic the first disc was comprised of, so Porcupine Tree excludes performing the whole second disc of The Incident - and the complete album in general - most likely for the sake of variation. To appease the crowds, Porcupine Tree exchanges all but one of the less critical songs to The Incident’s concept on the second disc for some of their most well known songs from past albums such as “Arriving Somewhere But Not Here” and “Hatesong”; leaving “Bonnie the Cat” as the only song from The Incident’s second disc that was performed and included on Octane Twisted.

Being live renditions of a concept album, the first disc doesn’t differ too much from its studio version counterpart, in order to grant the crowds with the same desired effect of the original. These performances aren’t identical per say, but the entire performance of “The Incident" seems to follow a set structure far too strictly, as if just exactly going by the numbers and through the motions of the original. The little room for flexibility there is would have allowed for some very intriguing instances of playing around with a typical rendition of a song that could be considered an album, but this potential was sadly not taken advantage of as much as it could have been, making a song as long as this a little too similar to the album version to make it worth the investment.

The other issues with hearing a concept album transfered to the live stage is all the conflicting elements of a live show that can't be helped, but will unavoidably take you out of the element the concept album is trying to convey. From the crowd cheering, to Steven Wilson interrupting the experience by greeting the crowd just as the buildup of the intro piece “Occam's Razor” had engulfed you in its world, there is ultimately a lot of minor annoyances that consistently distract from the 55 minute epic, and make the journey weaker than that of the original studio version.

Though there are positives that put this above a standard every day live Porcupine Tree performance, one of them being the raw and un-finalized feel a live rendition gives a colossal composition like “The Incident”. This piece is absolutely gargantuan, and performing it all in one live take and unaltered by studio touch-ups is just another one of the many examples of how much finesse, and magnificent talent Porcupine Tree possesses. There is a certain newfound organic feel that gives this ambitious song a visceral perspective much different from the finalized studio version that was mastered and mixed with certain effects; a certain something the original could not obtain for that very reason. Wilson’s brutally sincere emotion in his melodic delivery, and the natural feeling of the wailing guitar distortion and pounding drum assaults make this an astonishing album to hear unfold before listener’s ears.

The contents of the second disc aren’t much worth mentioning or delving into. The elongated versions of staples among the band’s fan base sound just as potent and thrilling as they have before on every other one of the band’s previous tours, making Octane Twisted sort of like an live album that’s half conceptual, and half normal live performance.

Despite the live setting preventing Octane Twisted from having the same effects as the studio versions of the conceptual tracks that it hosts, the live setting also brings out another completely different and unique side of The Incident that could not be achieved on the studio LP, and stands as another great testament of the magic Porcupine Tree’s showmanship can work for audiences while performing live.



Recent reviews by this author
Les Claypool's Duo de Twang Four Foot ShackPeriphery Clear
Nickelback The Best of Nickelback Volume 1Eminem The Marshall Mathers LP 2
Active Child RaporJustin Timberlake The 20/20 Experience 2 of 2
user ratings (45)
Chart.
3.8
excellent

Comments:Add a Comment 
Insurrection
Contributing Reviewer
November 21st 2012


21469 Comments


didnt even know this existed, will check it out. great review too. pos'd

Digging: Aspherium - The Fall of Therenia

SgtPepper
Staff Reviewer
November 21st 2012


4443 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Really good review, Alex as always. I loved this. POS'd.

KerfuffleinaHussle
November 21st 2012


783 Comments


Don't really see the point in this unless you get the "Super Limited Deluxe Special Edition" with the DVD...

breakingthefragile
November 21st 2012


2961 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

Yeah, I'm sure the DVD naturally enhances the experience by a lot, since that would be the closest you'd come to actually being there. I'm glad you guys liked my review, Paperback and Insurrection, and I had a feeling you'd be fond of this album Hernan. Also, you should totally check it out Insurrection, I'm sure you'll like it a lot, it's worth digging into all in all.

So yeah, I realized I've only been reviewing either a lot of mainstream rock and pop music, or a lot of really bad music (sometimes both in one album). So I thought it was about time I got back to reviewing some good new releases from some ambitious experimental acts that I oh so love. I think I'm gonna try to review some more hip hop in the future as well since I haven't in a while.

IMZA1793
November 21st 2012


843 Comments


Favorite band. Will check this out.

insomniac15
Staff Reviewer
November 21st 2012


3450 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Great review, pos. I have to get the DVD, because I can't wait to see the whole Incident live. I love the record. Unfortunately, the second disc isn't included on the DVD..I'd love to see Stars Die, Bonnie The Cat and Russia On Ice recorded properly.

Digging: Mark Lanegan - Phantom Radio

Gee
November 21st 2012


228 Comments


Bought for the DVD, and it doesn't disappoint (as long as you play it through a good sound system). Brings back memories of the real thing. Was thinking about doing this for my second ever review but you beat me to it haha. Great review

KILL
November 21st 2012


71955 Comments


cool

Digging: Exodus - Blood In, Blood Out

JamieTwort
Contributing Reviewer
November 21st 2012


21029 Comments


not heard in a while


^lol wtf this has only just come out.

Probably won't check this out seeing as I didn't like The Incident much.

KILL
November 21st 2012


71955 Comments


skele only pretends to listen to music dw

Arron
November 21st 2012


57 Comments


Nothing will beat anesthitize! I just found the last album way too dreary.

CaptWaffles
November 21st 2012


192 Comments


Might check this out, it was a cool tour

Keyblade
November 21st 2012


15029 Comments


not heard in a while

teehee

Digging: Submotion Orchestra - Alium

Wolfhorde
November 21st 2012


13648 Comments


This is probably meh.

Voivod
Staff Reviewer
November 21st 2012


6205 Comments


whoa double feature

Digging: Seduced (AT) - The Proclamation

Lambda
November 21st 2012


2452 Comments


Kind of an overly wordy review, but it gets the point across. 3.5 seems generous for what you've written here.

MiniatureHorse
November 21st 2012


908 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Great release by an amazing outfit. I love me some Porcupine Tree. m/ Great review, btw

YoYoMancuso
November 21st 2012


11153 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

i'll be getting this solely for the second disc, but good review. pos'd

OmairSh
November 21st 2012


11550 Comments


Russia on Ice desparately needs to be on a DVD.

Digging: Mono - Hymn To The Immortal Wind

NightmareCinema16
November 21st 2012


2016 Comments


Who would give a neg to this? I didn't. By the way, nice review, man. POS.



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2014 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Privacy Policy