A Perfect Circle
Thirteenth Step


4.5
superb

Review

by Xander_Christ USER (10 Reviews)
February 6th, 2006 | 653 replies | 63,074 views


Release Date: 2003 | Tracklist


30 of 32 thought this review was well written

I was first introduced to A Perfect Circle through their cover album Emotive, which I borrowed from a friend. Thankfully I did not pay one cent for it, as it possesses the same musical integrity as urinating in a Pepsi bottle and throwing it at a basement wall. However, after hearing singles The Outsider and Judith I became more familiar with the band in their glory days and I was compelled to purchase their first two albums. Their second effort, Thirteenth Step, would go on to become one of my favourite albums of all time, and one of few that I could listen to for years on end without tiring.
At first I was thrown a little by the title, which seemed like one of the generic meaningless titles assigned to alt-rock albums at random. However, once I caught on to the addiction and recovery concept that runs through the album, I understood the title for what it means. The songs to follow are all excellent and all contribute to the central story or meaning of the album. Although I am not a die-hard fan of A Perfect Circle and do not know the exact stories behind many of Maynard's lyrics, I could draw enough from them that I gained a deep appreciation for the bands songwriting.

A Perfect Circle was (is?):
Maynard James Keenan- Lead Vocals
Billy Howerdel- Guitar and Vocals
James Iha- Guitar
Jeordie White- Bass
Josh Freese- Drums


The first stage of alcoholism is denail, and that seems to be what we're greeted with on the opening track, THE PACKAGE. Over in 7 minutes in length, its the album's longest and almost overstays its welcome. The song brings in with light guitar and a rim beat, then Jeordie enters with a smooth bass line. Maynards vocals are dark and hollow, "Eye on what I'm after, I don't need another friend". Then, halfway through the song the guitar cuts into a heavy riff as Maynard utters "Mine!" under the music. A powerful start to an equally epic album.

Next comes the huge radio single WEAK AND POWERLESS, which does kind of live up to its name. The song is clearly about addiction, in which the narrator now admits to their problem and how it affects them. Not one of the abums strongest songs, its never really captivated my interest in the same way as most other tracks. However, although not very dynamic or powerful, it still conveys a bleakness that makes it a worthwhile track, and makes for an obvious single. I only really feel the need to skip it when desperate to hear the next track, likely my favourite on the album.

THE NOOSE always seemed out of place to me, such a strong and impactful track would have done well as the album's closer. The song seems to be written about someone who has recovered from an addiction or illness, but then becomes overly righteous. I like dedicating it to my ex-anorexic girlfriend who recently left me. The song has an almost ambient feel at the beginning, with a soft piano chord which is joined by light but innovative drums, guitar, bass and vocals. Much like The Package, it builds and climaxes near the end of the track, however the end result is a beautiful cascade of some of the most emotionally powerful strings I've ever heard. Maynard's final line, "Your halo's slipping down to choke you now" echoes long after the song to haunt the listener for hours to folow.

Then comes BLUE, another radio single. This song has a little more 'pop appeal' to it with a more upbeat guitar and vocals. However, it is still an excellent track and a nice break from some of the bleakness found on the album. The song sounds like an ex-girlfriend revenge fantasy, particularily the chorus in which Maynard sings about her 'turning blue', possibly from strangulation? An enjoyable, livelier track.

VANISHING took a little while to grow on me, as it isn't a vocally driven track nor does it have solic catchy instrumentals. However, the song is enjoyable for its raw power and emotion. The music sounds like a dark ambience laced with guitar and steady ride cymbal. I'm not sure what to make about deeper lyrical meanings, so I won't try. Next we have A STRANGER, an acoustic song with Maynard's superb singing cast under the spotlight. The song is about the narrator's/Maynard's views on God and how he doesn't feel that God cares about him or is relevant to his life (a sentiment that I have found in several addicts). The single guitar notes are met with strings and light strummming that layer the song nicely. Got to respect any band that can make a drum-free song still sound somewhat like it has balls.

And enter THE OUTSIDER, the song that truly drew me towards this band. One of their angrier songs, it most defenitly is of the anti-ex-girlfriend theme. The song is about a girl described by Maynard as a 'narcissistic drama queen' whose self destructive nature damages those around her. The music stays true to the bands alt-rock format, the guitar only really thickens on the second verse for a few moments. Much of the volume is conveyed through Josh's creative yet consistent drumwork. However, the lyrics are bitter and vitriolic from start to finish, making for a dark driving song that sounds great when up late at night.

Then we come to the first of two semi-instrumentals; CRIMES is dismissed by many as pure filler. However, the throbbing drum beat and soft background guitar makes for an enjoyable track musically. While the only words are Maynard's counting in the background, the light effect paints a colourful result of a person who has lost all respect for society and laws.

The next one really caught me off guard at first. A cover track done originally by the band Failure, THE NURSE WHO LOVED ME is a mellow, disney like tune that utilizes very little instrumentals, no drums and choir-like bakcup vocals. The happy yet childlike song is almost laughable at times, however it works well ironically as the 'nurse' being pined over is clearly a metaphor for a drug, representing the narrator's need-driven ambitions.

After the last track closes on an airy, peaceful note, PET slaps the listener in the face with its heavy guitars, bass and drums. The albums loudest and perhaps moodiest, the lyrics take a political swing, which is vastly different from the rest of the album. "Don't fret precious I'm here", sings Maynard, "Step away from the window. Go back to sleep." On the surface we hear a father consoling his son and his nightime fears, but this is but a metaphor for the American government and its way of assuring the blind American citizen that they can be trusted with their lives. Satirical rock at its finest, with some catchy and edgy guitars to boot. Next comes LULLABY, another largely instrumental track which serves as almost an outro to Pet. The music is even simpler this time, with a female voice singing "Na-na-na-na-na-na' in the background over faint drumming. While not a stand out track in itself by any means, it works well as an aftertought to Pet and as a way to set up the listener for the finale.

GRAVITY is one of the most beautifully optimistic tracks ever the conclude a concept album. Musically, it recalls The Package, which brings the album around to a full circle (no pun intended). However, the vocals on the chorus are the best on the album, shining brighty across the musical landscape; "Catch me, heal me, lift me up to the sun, I choose to live". The song has an uplifting feel despite the title, and lets the listener know that everything turns out well in the end. I truly believe that this song could prevent half of all suicides if only played at the right moment.

The thirteenth step as we know it, and as this album illustrates, is to love onself. The theme of self embrace and acceptance echoes through this album as resoundly as any instrument, and makes it one of the most beatiful anf powerful works of art to ever make it onto a disc. I would recommend this album to anyone who has ever had a rough day, or just anyone with a throurough enjoyment of powerfully transcendant music.

Stand-out Tracks: The Noose, The Outsider, Pet, Gravity



Recent reviews by this author
Nick Oliveri and the Mondo Generator Dead Planet: SonicSlowMotionTrailsDeftones Saturday Night Wrist
Kyuss ...And the Circus Leaves TownDeftones Deftones
Rammstein RosenrotRammstein Mutter
user ratings (2282)
Chart.
4
excellent
other reviews of this album
1 of

Comments:Add a Comment 
AlienEater
February 7th 2006



716 Comments


one of your favourite albums of all time?
good review.

Tarantino's Tarantulas
February 7th 2006



819 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Only heard about 4 tracks from hear, but theyre all beautiful. Agree with everything you said about Gravity - amazing song - except I think it has some really depressing parts to it, like the bridge about driving "another nail into another needy hole" (from what Ive heard thats a metaphor for needle aided drug abuse)

NuMetalMania
February 7th 2006



325 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

Good review. One of all my all time favourite Cd's along with Mer De Noms. Loved Jeordies bass in this CD. Hurry up maynard and make the next apc masterpeice im waiting man!

Med57
Moderator
February 7th 2006



1001 Comments


Good review. I don't think this is as good as you do, but it's probably my favourite APC album (I've decided I prefer it to Mer De Noms now), and some of the songs on here are great, especially Pet.

ktstein
February 7th 2006



438 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

I agree with Med on this one. This album is a little better overall than Mer de Noms. On the hole, it feels good.

I love the 4 minute buildup on The Package...how does that overstay its welcome? Have you ever listened to TOOL? Talk about some buildups. Anyways, Pet is also pretty awesome, and Vanishing. This is about a 3.5/5.

Too bad Judith still owns any song off here...

AlienEater
February 7th 2006



716 Comments


What about the nurse who loved me? I've no idea why, but I love it. pet and the package are good too

3rdplanet
February 7th 2006



46 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

I liked your review and agree with you on most parts; however, I do find Crimes, The Nurse Who Loved Me and Lullaby come as a bit of a let down (even in a "work well" with the rest of the album's feel sorta way).

If there was material on a similar level to The Noose/Gravity in their place, the album would be a stone cold 4.5 for me.This Message Edited On 02.07.06

Cravinov13
February 7th 2006



3854 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

Gravity is IMO the best APC song ever along with Magdalena, Passive, and The Noose.

Zebra
Moderator
February 7th 2006



2647 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

Nice review, it was smooth and easy to read.
I enjoy this album from time to time. The last half of the album is sort of meh but the first half makes up for it.

CushMG15
February 7th 2006



1802 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Agreed. The first have of this album is choice...but the second drags in down a bit (except Pet). I found the 1st one to be much the same.

1n F14m35 B01
February 7th 2006



4 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

Great review favorite album of all time but have you seen the aMOTION DVD? On Maynard's commentary on the music videos, he rather blantly states out some of the underlying themes about the songs. All songs are up for interpretion but Maynard says that The Outsider, Pet and Blue are all again about drug addiction. It's the theme of the entire album really. Pick of the DVD and listen to his commentary and you'll hear him. Pet is political but actually Couting Bodies off "eMOTIVe" is the political side of the song.

Then again it's Maynard so who knows? Just kind of struck me as off. Overall great review of a great album. (But I still hold that eMOTIVe is still a great album not piss ina pepsi can -.-)

IsItLuck?
Emeritus
February 7th 2006



4926 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

The Noose is simply fantastic, one of my favorite APC songs. Crimes, The Nurse Who Loved Me and Lullaby were simply garbage in my opinion, it really drags this album down. The rest of the album is really good also.This Message Edited On 02.07.06

Digging: Joyce Manor - Never Hungover Again

Xander_Christ
February 7th 2006



132 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

Thanks to all for the positive feedback.
I've been looking for aMOTION, I hope to pick it up sometime soon. From what I've heard the remixed versions of their songs are excellent.

IsItLuck?
Emeritus
February 7th 2006



4926 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

Oh yeah, I meant to say good review, forgot to add it in ;)This Message Edited On 02.07.06

ocelot-05
February 7th 2006



807 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

There are no perfect circles in nature. Neither are there perfect albums, but this one comes close, even though it's not quite one of my all time favorites.

Six Foot Revolver
February 11th 2006



73 Comments


[QUOTE=Med]Good review. I don't think this is as good as you do, but it's probably my favourite APC album (I've decided I prefer it to Mer De Noms now), and some of the songs on here are great, especially Pet.[/QUOTE]
Pretty much sums up my opinion on it.

ocelot-05
February 12th 2006



807 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

I'm so glad he became Maynard James Keenan, the singer/songwriter, instead of James H. Keenan, the soldier.This Message Edited On 02.12.06

riobravo1023
February 20th 2006



274 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

I thought this CD was alright, with "The Outsider" and "A Stranger" being the best songs on here. The reason I pick Mer De Noms over this is because of the half-effort (at least, in my opinion) tracks on here, such as "Blue," "Weak and Powerless," "Vanishing," "Crimes," and "Lullaby."

Cravinov13
February 20th 2006



3854 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

The only tracks I hate on this album are A Stranger, Lullaby and Crimes. Everything else is marvelous.

Tarantino's Tarantulas
March 7th 2006



819 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Wow! I hadnt listened to APC for a while...Then I downloaded the Noose...Wow!
It reminded me of NIN's A Warm Place for some reason, don't know why...Probably because they are both so fvcking beautiful



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2013 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Privacy Policy